“The damage that economics inflicted on the other social sciences. This guy won a Nobel Prize in economics.” (Pablo Bortz)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) September 27, 2026
Gary Becker never understood profit and, as a logical consequence, how the economic system works. That's disqualifying. Even worse, he started talking about… pic.twitter.com/piyEeODjzQ
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.
September 27, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CCCLXVI)
September 5, 2022
Occasional Tweets: The futile attempt to recycle economics imperialism (II)
For 200+ yrs #Economics is a #FailedScience. #Economists are #Clowns in the political #CircusMaximus. They have a #Comment / #Opinion on everything, but scientific #Knowledge of nothing. This proto-scientific #ShitShow is known as #EconomicsImperialism. pic.twitter.com/8gwjZ38EpY
— E.K-H (@AXECorg) September 5, 2022
August 23, 2022
Occasional Tweets: The horror of economics imperialism
#Economics#FailedScience#FakeScience#Economists have a #Comment / #Opinion on everything, but scientific #Knowledge of nothing. This #Horror is known as #EconomicsImperialism.
— E.K-H (@AXECorg) August 23, 2022
Economists: Jacks-of-all-trades ― except economicshttps://t.co/cChZwVrq7J
January 15, 2022
Occasional Tweets: Economics claims to be science, actually it is cargo cult science
#Economics#FailedScience#FakeScience#CargoCultScience
— E.K-H (@AXECorg) January 15, 2022
The history of economic thought is the history of scientific failure.
Economics Imperialism ― political opinion on everything but scientific knowledge of nothinghttps://t.co/0oE5bq94Rm pic.twitter.com/bR43ojiQ0x
January 5, 2022
Occasional Tweets: Economics Imperialism ― political opinion on everything but scientific knowledge of nothing
#Economics#FailedScience#FakeScience#DisInfoTainment#Economists have a political #Opinion on everything but scientific #Knowledge of nothing. This defect is known as #EconomicsImperialism.
— E.K-H (@AXECorg) January 5, 2022
Economists: Jacks-of-all-trades ― except economicshttps://t.co/cChZwVrq7J pic.twitter.com/ydw1IGqeWJ
July 16, 2021
Occasional Tweets: Religion, science, fake science, economics (I)
#Econ#Economics is about how the #Economy works and NOT about the Latin Mass. #Economists are too stupid for the elementary #Algebra of #MacroEconomics. Bc of this, they get the foundational concept of #Profit wrong. Bc of this, economics is proto-scientific garbage. pic.twitter.com/LBBq14c5z0
— E.K-H (@AXECorg) July 16, 2021
- If religion is opium of the people, economics is crack of the people
- Fake religion, fake science, fake news, and false complaints
- Economics is not science, not religion, but proto-scientific garbage
- No religion, merely incompetence
- The Supreme Being handed over these Twelve Economics Commandments
- Economists: Jacks-of-all-trades ― except economics
April 7, 2021
Economics ― still the "science" of the mentally impaired
December 1, 2020
Clear thinking in economics: hahaha!
October 14, 2019
Scrap the EconNobel
Blog-Reference
Economists are NOT scientists but clowns and useful idiots in the political Circus Maximus. The EconNobel is a fraud. For details, see here.
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
Comment on Peter Dorman on ‘A Nobel for the Randomistas’
Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference
Peter Dorman comments: “I don’t think anyone was surprised by this year’s ‘Nobel’ prize in economics, which went to three American-based specialists in the design of on-the-ground experiments in low income countries, Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo and Michael Kremer.”
Indeed, the EconNobel has been criticized on various grounds: (i) male predominance, (ii) theory-predominance, (iii) rich-western-capitalism-focused, (iv) geriatric-predominance, (v) white-predominance, (vi) University of Chicago bias. All these biases have been addressed and solved to everybody’s satisfaction with the team of young/bi-gender/ poverty-concerned/empirical/multicultural Cambridge-MA prize winners.
One problem, though, has been carefully avoided, i.e., that economics is NOT a science to this day. The major approaches — Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT — are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent, and all got the foundational economic concept of profit wrong. Economics is a failed science.
Economics has NEVER been a science but a smokescreen for political agenda-pushing. Both orthodox and heterodox economists are NOT scientists but clowns and useful idiots in the political Circus Maximus. The “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences” has been a fraud for 50 years. #1
Peter Dorman wonders, “Carefully controlled social experiments can be very expensive! When I read the work of the prize-winners and their coauthors, I often find myself wondering how much did it cost to do this research, and who paid for it? This is a form of Big Science, and it requires big support.”
This is an easy question. Economics departments, chairs, institutions, and pre-selected individuals are traditionally funded by the Oligarchy. Rockefeller called the university ‘the best investment’ he ever made. In our days, though, the quality of sponsors/funders/ agenda-pushers has considerably deteriorated. The active players are not at all secret; the New York Times shows a meeting photo of well-known billionaire Jeffrey Epstein and well-known Harvard economist and political busybody Larry Summers. #2
From all this, one can conclude with a high degree of probability that the EconNobel is a well-calculated, Oligarchy-sponsored, aristocracy-decorated PR stunt that has much to do with the deception of the general public and NOTHING at all with science.
#1 For details, see Links on the Economics Nobel
#2 New York Times
You say: “To a large degree the Nobel for Chinese growth was given a long time ago to Robert Solow. A nation that invests more grows more. That is pretty much it, …” and “Look, Nobel prizes, including even the ‘fake’ economics one given out by the Sveriges Riksbank for the last half century, focus on people who generate new ideas, not policymakers who may have achieved successful outcomes. You suggest that ‘a poverty-oriented Chinese economist’ deserves the prize, but somehow you do not provide a name. And I would suggest you will not be able to because no Chinese economist has generated any important new ideas on this.”
Solow criticized the DSGE-Orthodoxy: “Since I find that fundamental framework ludicrous, I respond by treating it as ludicrous ― that is, by laughing at it ― so as not to fall into the trap of taking it seriously and passing on to matters of technique.” #1
The same holds, though, for Solow’s own growth model. #2
Nevertheless, the EconNobel “was given a long time ago to Robert Solow”.
It is obvious why the EconNobel will not be given to a Chinese economist. The EconNobel is a Hollywood production for the Western audience initiated and sponsored by the US Oligarchy to reward US economists for their propaganda services to “scientifically” prove the superiority of the US version of self-optimizing supply-demand-equilibrium.
The EconNobel had NO scientific significance 50 years ago and has none this year. And this is NOT because “no Chinese economist has generated any important new ideas” but because no US economist has generated any important new ideas. Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and MMT are ludicrous proto-scientific garbage to this day.
#1 Solow and the ludicrousness of economics
#2 Sending Solow’s growth model to the dump of proto-scientific history
You say: “Look, Nobel prizes, including even the ‘fake’ economics one given out by the Sveriges Riksbank for the last half century, focus on people who generate new ideas, not policymakers who may have achieved successful outcomes.”
This, of course, is absolutely correct. But then, is your discussion about whether China or the Massachusetts team has been more successful in alleviating poverty not a bit beside the point?
What you are constantly doing is confounding science and politics. This is a hereditary mental and moral disease among economists since Adam Smith. However, the founding fathers were at least honest people and called themselves Political Economists. The denomination “political” was later scrapped by Jevons. This was roughly at the same time when the War Ministries were renamed Defense Ministries.
What the general public does not understand is that there are political economics and theoretical economics. The main differences are: (i) The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda, and the goal of theoretical economics is to successfully explain how the actual economy works. (ii) In political economics, anything goes; in theoretical economics, the scientific standards of material and formal consistency are observed.
The fraud of economists consists of telling the public that they are doing science while, in fact, they are doing agenda-pushing. The fraud is in the title “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”. There would be no problem at all if the title were “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Propaganda on Behalf of the US Oligarchy”.
With regard to ‘Economic Sciences’, economists are still behind the curve:
• Science manifests itself in the form of the true theory.
• Truth is well-defined by material and formal consistency.
• Logical consistency is secured by applying the axiomatic-deductive method, and material consistency is secured by applying state-of-the-art testing.
• The true theory/model is the humanly best mental representation of reality.
• The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT ― are axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent, and mutually contradictory.
• Orthodox and heterodox economics are failed/fake/cargo-cult science, i.e,. political agenda-pushing without valid scientific foundations.
The “alleviation of global poverty” by the Massachusetts team is politically fictitious and scientifically worthless.
The political reality is that MMT academics claim on the basis of an algebraically false sectoral balances equation that public deficits are beneficial for WeThePeople and that they increase “private wealth” while the analytically correct balances equation says that Public Deficit = Private Profit, which is obviously beneficial only for the Oligarchy.
So, while academic economists pretend with this year’s EconNobel to care about the alleviation of poverty, they politically accept/promote the explosion of the Oligarchy’s financial wealth by exploding the public debt.
Clearly, economists have to be expelled from the scientific community.
You say: “Anthropologists and government policy designers went down this road, fruitlessly 50 years ago. The culture of poverty is a notion in social theory asserting that the values of people experiencing poverty play a significant role in perpetuating their impoverished condition, sustaining a cycle of poverty across generations.” and “If economists were educated beyond economic theories and mathematics and had at least a modicum of curiosity about events around them, they’d know that the work for which these folks [Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo, Michael Kremer] were awarded a Noble Prize is not either innovative or new.”
Yes, indeed, the culture of poverty is the subject matter of Anthropology/Sociology/ Psychology and other so-called social sciences. No, Psychology, Sociology, etcetera ― PsySoc for short ― is NOT the subject matter of economics. The subject matter of economics is how the economic system works. Economics is a systems science and NOT a social science. #1, #2
The fact is that economics is a failed science. The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent, and ALL got the foundational economic concept ― profit ― wrong. Economists have NO valid theory about how the actual economy works, but this does not prevent them from taking part in the political Circus Maximus and giving economic policy advice. #3
There have always been two economixes, political economics, and theoretical economics. The main differences are: (i) The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda, and the goal of theoretical economics is to successfully explain how the actual economy works (= true theory). (ii) In political economics, anything goes; in theoretical economics, scientific standards are observed.
The fact is that (i) theoretical economics (= science) had been hijacked from the very beginning by political economists (= agenda pushers), and (ii), political economics has produced NOTHING of scientific value in the last 200+ years. #4
Because economics is NOT a science but an oligarchy-sponsored political agenda-pushing, the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel” is a deception of the general public since the first EconNobel 50 years ago. #5
It is time to sue the Bank of Sweden for damages and waste of the Swedish people’s money.
#1 Economics is NOT about Human Nature but the economic system
#2 PsySoc — the scourge of economics
#3 Econogenics in action
#4 Economists: scientists or political clowns?
#5 Links on the Economics Nobel
You say, “Egmont, thanks for your comments. You’re correct that economists today spend little time or effort studying poverty. But anthropologists and sociologists do.”
In fact, I said that economists spend TOO MUCH time with PsySoc. The subject matter of economics is NOT Human Nature/motives/behavior/action, but how the economic system works.
Economists are known to have dabbled in virtually every discipline: Psychology, Sociology, Political Sciences, Geopolitics, Law, History, Anthropology, Social Philosophy, Philosophy, Theology, Pedagogy, Biology/Evolution, and whatnot. This somewhat perverse habit has been called Economics Imperialism. The perversity consists of the fact that economists have utterly failed in their own discipline. Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and MMT are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent.
In 200+ years, economics has not risen above the proto-scientific level. For details, see Economists: Jacks-of-all-trades ― except economics.
September 8, 2019
Links on Karl Marx
Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference
The age-old problem with economists is that they are strong on opinion but weak on knowledge and that they suffer from mental incontinence, that is, the unstoppable urge to blather about every issue between heaven and earth, that is, from crime, addiction, psychology, sociology, philosophy, religion, sport, art, literature, ethics to their heroic fight for the welfare/freedom/survival of humanity. This is known as economics imperialism. The fact is, though, that economists have to this day NO idea how the economy works. Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT, Pluralism are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent and all got the foundational economic concept of profit wrong. To this day, economists could not get their act together. Economists are scientifically incompetent and Marx/Marxians are NO exception. For details see:
► The economist as storyteller
► Karl Marx, fake scientist
► Profit for Marxists
► Marx, the moron
► Dear idiots, Marx got profit and exploitation wrong
► Here is the long-overdue scientific death certificate for Marx and Marxists
► Marx’s bicentennial ― nothing to discuss, nothing to celebrate
► 200 years in the dark ― how Marx got it wrong
► Capitalism, poverty, exploitation, and cross-over exploitation
► If we only had classes
► Socialism and scientific incompetence
► MMT and Marxism: A debate between proto-scientific zombies
► Marx and the curious coexistence of provably false economic theories
► Marxism is one of four instances of proto-scientific garbage
► Who is really a scientist?
► The Law of Economists’ Increasing Stupidity
► Good news for the one-percenters
► The end of political economics (I)
► The end of political economics (II)
► Ricardo and the invention of class war
► Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism
► No future for Socialism and Capitalism
► Economists simply don’t get it
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
Related 'Econogenics in action' and 'As Napoleon said: don’t listen to economists' and 'There is NO such thing as “smart, honest, honorable economists”'.
July 8, 2019
MMTers are false Progressives and false Friends-of-the-People
Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference
Economists are known to have dabbled in virtually every discipline: psychology, sociology, political sciences, geopolitics, law, history, anthropology, social philosophy, philosophy, theology, pedagogic, biology/evolution, art, literature, and whatnot. This somewhat perverse habit has been called Economics Imperialism.#1, #2, #3 The perversity consists of the fact that economists have utterly failed in their own discipline. Since Adam Smith, economics has not risen above the proto-scientific level.#4 Economists do not know to this day how the monetary economy works.
The greatest scientific losers cannot hold their mouths when genuine scientists are solving real-world problems. This is something economists have never done; just the opposite. As Napoleon summarized: “… he had always believed that if an empire were made of granite the ideas of economists if listened to, would suffice to reduce it to dust.” (Viner)#5
History seems to repeat itself. Bill Mitchell quotes an article in the latest edition of Science#6: “The authors note at the outset that: Photosynthetic carbon capture by trees is likely to be among our most effective strategies to limit the rise of CO2 concentrations across the globe.” and “The restoration of trees remains among the most effective strategies for climate change mitigation.” and “We could restore 1tn trees for $300bn”.
Now, Bill Mitchell chimes in with good advice: “Clearly tree planting is not rocket science and the skills necessary to undertake these reafforestation projects would be within the reach of most workers. A progressive editor or commentator should never be questioning how we can pay for a tree planting project. They should be lobbying at every chance governments to end their ‘sound finance’ mindsets.”
A progressive editor would simply propose to shift the government’s budget from military spending to reforestation. The problem is NOT budget-balancing a.k.a. sound finance but budget allocation which is long-known in economics under the old slogan guns vs butter. The USA can very easily save the environment and improve social conditions by reallocating the given budget.#7, #8 This, however, is NOT what “progressive” MMTers propose. Instead, they propose to increase deficit-spending/money-creation.
Accordingly, Bill Mitchell does not talk about reallocation of a given budget but prophylactically mows down all budget balancers: “The neoliberals continually drown the populace in a swathe of austerity myths:
- The government has run out of money.
- Deficits will drive up interest rates.
- Deficits will cause hyperinflation.
- Deficits will rack up unsustainable debts on our grandchildren.
- Bond markets will punish governments who run continuous deficits.
- Deficits undermine growth because the private sector thwarts its intent by increasing saving to pay for higher implied taxes in the future.
- Direct job creation creates unreal jobs that are worthless.
- A Job Guarantee would undermine the capacity of private employers to attract labor and drive down productivity.
- ETC, the list goes on.
Bill Mitchell never talks about the profit effect of deficit-spending/money-creation. The macroeconomic Profit Law, i.e. Q≡Yd+(I−S)+(G−T)+(X−M), tells everyone that Public Deficit = Private Profit and that MMT is a free-lunch program for the Oligarchy and that private financial wealth and public debt grow in lockstep and that fabulous financial wealth in the USA is roughly equal to humongous public debt (22 trillion and counting).#9, #10
MMT is NOT a scientific theory but a dishonest political farce. MMTers are not Friends-of-the-People but the useful idiots of Wall Street.
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
#1 “Economics imperialism in contemporary economics is the economic analysis of seemingly non-economic aspects of life, such as crime, law, the family, prejudice, tastes, irrational behavior, politics, sociology, culture, religion, war, science, and research.” (Wikipedia)
#2 Economists: Jacks-of-all-trades ― except economics
#3 Overreach: Economists have their fingers in every pie except real economics
#4 Economics: The greatest scientific hoax in modern times
#5 Econogenics in action
#6 Science: The global tree restoration potential
#7 MMT and the Green New Deal: Where is the snag? (II)
#8 MMT and the Green New Deal: Where is the snag? (I)
#9 Is MMT good for WeThePeople or for the Oligarchy?
10 What comes first: eco-self-destruction or oeco-self-destruction?
Related 'Schizonomics' and 'Why the MMT benefactors of humanity never talk about profit' and 'How to spot economics trolls' and 'MMT: A new myth for WeThePeople' and 'MMT’s true program' and 'No MMT illusions! YOU are going to pay for it' and 'Links on Austerity' and 'Deficit-spending/money-creation is ALWAYS a bad deal for WeThePeople' and 'How counterfeiters save America with an extra profit and make WeThePeople pay for it' and 'Just one more day: How deficit-spending postpones the breakdown of Capitalism'.
November 15, 2016
Economists: Jacks-of-all-trades ― except economics
Blog-Reference
The state of economics is this: there is political economics and theoretical economics. The founding fathers called themselves political economists; that is, they left no doubt that their main business was agenda-pushing. Economists never got out of political economics. In other words, theoretical economics (= science) ultimately could not emancipate itself from political economics (= agenda-pushing). And this is how economics became a failed science.
What is entirely missing among economists is an understanding of what science is all about. More specifically, economists miss their very subject matter. #1, #2 It is NOT the task of the economist to dabble in psychology, sociology, political sciences, geopolitics, law, history, anthropology, social philosophy, philosophy, pedagogics, biology/Darwinism, homeopathy, sport, art, etcetera. And it is NOT their task to dabble in climatology or epidemiology. Whether there is global warming in the short/long run and whether it is anthropogenic or not is a question that falls outside the scientific competence of economists. The main reason is that economists have NO scientific competence at all.
The proof is in the current state of economics. Economics is a failed science. More specifically, political economists have produced not much, if anything, of scientific value in the last 200+ years.
“In order to tell the politicians and practitioners something about causes and best means, the economist needs the true theory or else he has not much more to offer than educated common sense or his personal opinion.” (Stigum)
There is no such thing as a true economic theory. The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, etc. ― are mutually contradictory and axiomatically false, that is, beyond repair. These failed approaches are in a zombie state ― dead but not buried ― waiting to be replaced by a superior paradigm.
What economists have produced so far is proto-scientific garbage: much political opinion but NO scientific knowledge, which comes in the form of a materially and formally consistent theory about how the actual economy works.
Both Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy are lost for science. Economists cannot be taken seriously ― not when they speak about the economy and still less when they talk about global warming or culture or history or politics or homeopathy.
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
#1 Economists’ three-layered scientific incompetence
#2 Mental messies and loose losers
Related 'There is NO such thing as an economic expert' and 'Economists cannot do the simple math of profit — better keep them out of politics' and 'Economics: The greatest scientific fraud in modern times' and 'There is NO such thing as “smart, honest, honorable economists”' and 'Economists’ foundational conceptual blunder' and 'The dumb economist ― a jack of all trades' and 'The GDP-death-blow for the economics profession'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references Incompetence and Political Economics/Stupidity/Corruption.
April 10, 2016
From microfoundations to macrofoundations
Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Apr 12
• Economics is a failed science. It consists actually of political and theoretical economics. Political economics is scientifically worthless.
• Psychology, sociology, behaviorism, political science, geopolitics, history, anthropology, evolutionary theory/Darwinism, institutionalism, law, ethics, criminology, or philosophy are NOT economics. The valid results of these independent disciplines are taken into economics by way of multidisciplinary cooperation if needed.
• Economics is NOT about human nature/behavior/action but about the evolution of the economic system as a whole.
• Partial analysis is of extremely limited value and in most cases runs directly into the Fallacy of Composition. Microfoundations have therefore to be replaced with macrofoundations.
• Macrofounded economics determines first of all the objective Profit Law because it is the key to all of economics. Those who do not understand what profit is, have no idea how the actual economy works. Objective economic laws are free of NONENTITIES and enable conclusive testing.
• Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT — the major approaches got profit wrong. All these approaches are scientifically worthless.
• Economics has nothing to offer to other disciplines — in particular not to sociology and political science — because it has produced not much, if anything, of scientific value since Adam Smith. The representative economist cannot even tell the essential difference between income and profit.
• The ongoing Paradigm Shift consists in the replacement of the subjective-behavioral axioms of methodological individualism with objective-structural axioms, i.e. by macrofoundations.#1
• People who have not realized in old age that maximization-and-equilibrium is scientific garbage will not be admitted to the new age because of proven scientific incompetence.
• Scientific imperialism will put an end to economics as cargo cult science: “So we really ought to look into theories that don’t work, and science that isn’t science.” (Feynman)
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
#1 Objective Principles of Economics and Major Defects of the Market Economy.
Related 'Toward the true economic axioms' and 'Finalizing the Keynesian Revolution' and 'The monstrous utility-supply-demand-equilibrium failure' and 'From Orthodoxy, to Heterodoxy, to Metadoxy'
The macrofoundations axiom set that fully replaces the obsolete microfoundations is defined on the AXEC Project website.
April 9, 2016
Scientific imperialism ― new age economics in 10 bullet points
Blog-Reference
• Economics is a failed science. It consists actually of political and theoretical economics. Political economics is scientifically worthless.
• Psychology, sociology, behaviorism, political science, geopolitics, history, anthropology, evolutionary theory, institutionalism, law, ethics, and philosophy are NOT economics. The valid results of these independent disciplines are taken into economics by way of multidisciplinary cooperation if needed.
• Economics is NOT about Human Nature/behavior/action but about the evolution of the economic system as a whole.
• Partial analysis is of extremely limited value and, in most cases, runs directly into the Fallacy of Composition. Microfoundation will therefore be replaced by macrofoundations.
• Systemic (= new) economics determines first of all the objective Profit Law because it is pivotal to all of economics. Those who do not understand what profit is have no idea how the actual economy works.
• Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism — all four got profit wrong. These approaches are scientifically worthless.
• Economics has nothing to offer to other disciplines because it has produced not much, if anything, of scientific value since Adam Smith. The representative economist cannot even tell the essential difference between income and profit.
• The ongoing Paradigm Shift consists methodologically of the move from the behavioral axiomatic foundations of the four failed approaches to structural axiomatic foundations.
• People who have not realized in the old age that maximization-and-equilibrium is proto-scientific garbage will not be admitted to the new age because of proven scientific incompetence.
• Scientific imperialism will put an end to economics as cargo cult science.
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
Related 'From mathiness to empiriness: forget it!'
April 8, 2016
From mathiness to empiriness: forget it!
Blog-Reference
Since Adam Smith, economists are too incompetent for science but smart enough to borrow manners and tools from successful disciplines. The result comes as no surprise: “Suffice it to say that, in my opinion, what we presently possess by way of so-called pure economic theory is objectively indistinguishable from what the physicist Richard Feynman, in an unflattering sketch of nonsense ‘science,’ called ‘cargo cult science’.” (Clower, 1994, p. 809)
Pure economic theory in all variants from General Equilibrium to RBC and DSGE, and from Keynes to post-Keynesianism, is a failure. Yet, science consists of TWO elements: “Research is in fact a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant, 1994, p. 31)
Eureka! there seems to be a way out of the impasse: fact-free model bricolage has not worked, so let us try the theory-free application of sophisticated statistical tools. True to form, economists mess it up again because the ONLY way to get out of a failed approach is a Paradigm Shift.
But, the fact of the matter is: “A new idea is extremely difficult to think of. It takes a fantastic imagination.” (Feynman, 1992, p. 172) Economists have lacked scientific imagination since Adam Smith, but they are just smart enough to use tools that have been developed elsewhere.
Economists have no clue at all about what the new Paradigm could look like: “There is another alternative: to formulate a completely new research program and conceptual approach. As we have seen, this is often spoken of, but there is still no indication of what it might mean.” (Ingrao et al., 1990, p. 362)
To apply the latest powerful statistics package on the latest powerful hardware is NOT a Paradigm Shift. It is just another dog and pony show for the general public, signaling ‘we are at the forefront of research’. This is tried and tested crisis communication since the gold makers: Yes, sadly, the last big idea exploded into our face like all the others before, but NOW the breakthrough is just around the corner.
For everybody who is aware of economists’ track record of consistent failure, Noah Smith’s hallucination of future triumph is an empty promise/threat that can merely serve as pep-talk for disoriented losers.
The economics Paradigm Shift will not come from scientifically retarded people who reveal themselves with “most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point” (Krugman).
Dear sociologists, you have nothing to fear. Economists cannot tell until this day how the economy works and you can beat them on their own turf before they even get their new-age pants on (2015).
Egmont Kakarot-Handtke
References
Clower, R. W. (1994). Economics as an Inductive Science. Southern Economic Journal, 60(4): 805–814.
Feynman, R. P. (1992). The Character of Physical Law. London: Penguin.
Ingrao, B., and Israel, G. (1990). The Invisible Hand. Economic Equilibrium in the History of Science. Cambridge, London: MIT Press.
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). How the Intelligent Non-Economist Can Refute Every Economist Hands Down. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2705395: 1–6. URL
Klant, J. J. (1994). The Nature of Economic Thought. Aldershot, Brookfield: Edward Elgar.
Related 'Scientific imperialism ― new age economics in 10 bullet points'.






