“Before studying the economic system, we must answer a more fundamental question: whose choices, whose valuations and whose purposes generate it?” (Rangaraj C) Imagine a boy throwing a stick towards an apple tree, causing an apple to fall and hit Newton on the head. In a flash, Newton then developed the Law of Universal Gravitation, which he published in his book Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica in 1687. He completely ignored the boy's behavior. Austrians, on the contrary, can explain in great detail why the historical event happened and even figure out that the boy maximized the utility of his ADHD syndrome. But, due to the lack of the ability for abstraction, they will never arrive at universal gravitation, i.e., science. Analogously, everybody knows why and how to use a toothbrush, but has no clue what the Law of the Lever says. 'The Law was formally formulated and proven by the ancient Greek mathematician and engineer Archimedes (c. 287–212 BC) in his treatise On the Equilibrium of Planes.” (Google AI) In a nutshell, that's the difference between low-IQ storytelling and science.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
AXEC: New Foundations of Economics
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.
November 15, 2026
Occasional X: Economists’ eternal problem with methodology (XVIII)
Occasional X: Clueless economists / Value (III)
“Though Jevons had successfully shown that for agents a and b with respective prices p1 and p2 for goods x1 and x2 would exhibit the relationship MU1a/MU2a=-dx2/dx1=MU1b/MU2b, where dx2/dx1=p1/p2 MU1a/P1=MU2a/p2=MUb1/p1=MU2b/p2 (in other words, the exchange ratio of goods across utilities for each good and each consumer equaled the ratio of relative prices), …” (Nikolai Rostov) That utility is not such a good starting point for a serious theory of value is known since Cournot: “The abstract idea of wealth or value in exchange ... must be carefully distinguished from accessory ideas of utility, scarcity and suitability to the needs and enjoyment of mankind... These ideas are variable, and by nature indeterminate and consequently ill-suited for the foundation of a scientific theory …” (Cournot 1897) The marginal utility of one person does not matter much, because the market transforms a great number of diverse subjective valuations into one objective price for all. The first market function is the objectification of subjectivity. Austrians still fail to show how this transformation works. For the correct answer, see The Logical Interface Between Objective Macrofoundations and Subjective Valuations https://t.co/8NXaiPVsHv The question of value does not arise outside the economic system, where labor gets a wage, and the output is sold on the market. The Value Theory presupposes a monetary market economy. The subjective value has ultimately to be backed up by an objective amount of money. The subjective value of water may be high, but if the wealth-less agent can maximally spend his income and if his income is very small, the thirsty person cannot buy enough water and leaves the market to die in some dark corner. Objectivity always beats subjective wishful thinking. The market corrects subjective valuations. The survivors understand that the market is not primarily an efficient information mechanism but a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism that makes sure, with some unintelligible Invisible-Hand trick, that the rich person survives the poor person if scarcity becomes extreme. These methodological mistakes are sufficient to make the Austrian approach scientifically worthless. The methodologically correct approach is summarized in table AXEC233b ⇓. Microfoundations are methodologically false. A Paradigm Shift is necessary. Therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1, 2, 3. The sectors are later differentiated in lines 15, 16, 17. Under the initial analytical conditions of market-clearing, i.e., X=O, this yields the price P in line 9. For a start, the price is the dependent variable here. This is a starting condition that is lifted later. Under the additional condition of budget-balancing, i.e., Ec=Yw or ρE=1, the price is given in line 5. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R. The workers get the whole product O. Their real wage is equal to the objective productivity, i.e., W/P=R. General wage increases are pointless. The profit Qm for the business sector as a whole is zero in line 11. Price increases can come only from wage rate increases or from productivity decreases. The quantity of money is not a price determinant. Then, the condition of budget balancing is lifted, i.e., nominal demand is not determined by income. Accordingly, the two market-clearing prices depend on the respective expenditure ratios ρE1, ρE2 and unit wage costs W1/R1, W2/R2 in lines 18, 19. The objective expenditure ratio is a measurable expression of the consolidated multitude of unmeasurable individual subjective values. As a result, relative prices are given in line 20. They depend on the expenditure ratio, the wage rate, and inverse productivity. For the special case of budget balancing, i.e., ρE1=1, ρE2=1, and equal wage rates W1=W2=W in both production lines, the relative prices are equal to the inverse productivities. They are not proportional to labor time input. With hindsight, it is obvious that both the classical and the Austrian value theories have been proto-scientific garbage. This reveals the scientific incompetence of economists from Adam Smith onward.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (XCL)
“Hume's is–ought problem exposes a fundamental distinction: no number of statements about what is can logically generate what ought to be.” (Rangaraj C) Yes, science and politics are two different things. Austrianism is materially/formally inconsistent. With Praxeology, it misapplied the axiomatic/deductive method, and it cannot escape the final judgment that it has always been political agenda pushing in the garb of science. Austrians are not alone; other political agenda pushers have captured economics early on and ruined all scientific content. This is why economics has been proto-scientific garbage from the Enlightenment onward. Economists never had a mandate for political agenda pushing: “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.” (J. S. Mill) For over 200 years, economics has claimed to be a science, but it still isn't. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Economics has no scientific truth-value, only political use-value. Economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations. Austrianism is the smoking-gun proof. It never rose above low-IQ political blather. Their main talking points are freedom and democracy. Economics is a genuine systems science; therefore, Hume's is-ought distinction does not come up. To this day, Austrians do not understand profit, which is the discipline's defining concept, and this tells one all about their scientific level. It is non-existent.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
Occasional X: Economics and math ― they just can't get it together (XVI)
“The arrogance of mathematics becomes counterproductive when the map is mistaken for the territory. It reduces economics to what can already be quantified, discouraging exploration of what remains unknown. Pedantry is not scientific rigour, and mathematical.” (Rangaraj C) Yes, mathematics can be misused. Economics is the most obvious example in the history of failed/fake science. This is long known. Georgescu-Roegen was well aware of his fellow economists’ utter scientific incompetence: “Knight lamented that there are many members of the economics profession who are ‘mathematicians first and economists afterwards.’ The situation since Knight's time has become much worse. There are endeavors that now pass for the most desirable kind of economic contributions, although they are just plain mathematical exercises, not only without any economic substance but also without mathematical value. Their authors are not something first and something else afterwards; they are neither mathematicians nor economists.” From the fact that legacy economics has been a cargo cult science, especially with the misuse of math, it does not follow that Austrian anti-math is the correct conclusion. Far from it. Georgescu-Roegen again: “Lest this position is misinterpreted again by some casual reader, let me repeat that my point is not that arithmetization of science is undesirable. Whenever arithmetization can be worked out, its merits are above all words of praise. My point is that wholesale arithmetization is impossible, that there is valid knowledge even without arithmetization, and that mock arithmetization is dangerous if peddled as genuine.” The incompetent scientist solves nothing but keeps everything in the swamp of inconclusiveness, where 'nothing is clear, and everything is possible' (Keynes). Inconclusiveness is what Popper called an immunizing stratagem because: “Another thing I must point out is that you cannot prove a vague theory wrong.” (Feynman) Austrian anti-math is an immunizing stratagem to keep everything in the swamp of endless political blather. Von Mises never understood the foundational concept —profit— of economics. Scientifically, he was a dead man walking/talking from the beginning. His political pronouncements have no valid scientific foundations. Praxeology is a tautological joke. His 'theory' is political agenda pushing verbalized in the economics jargon. Economics has been failed/fake science since the Founding Fathers. It has defined itself as a social science and accordingly has been based on subjective/behavioral assumptions/axioms. This is the methodological ur-mistake. Among all scientifically incompetent economists, Austrians have been the dumbest. The appropriate math of economics is not constrained optimization, i.e., calculus or what Austrians call Marginalism, but the elementary algebra that underlies macroeconomic accounting. Economics is about the economic system's behavior, not about human behavior. Human behavior is the subject of psychology, sociology, history, evolutionary biology, etc., and the silly content of everyday brainless gossip.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
November 14, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXIX)
“The more I delve into my Economics studies in Madrid and the more I listen to the lectures and classes of Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto, the more convinced I am that economic freedom, private property, and entrepreneurship are fundamental pillars of a prosperous society.” (Maria Elizabeth Huber) The Austrian School is refuted on all counts. They never understood profit, and by logical consequence, how the economic system works. That is self-defeating. The economy runs on profit. The minimum requirement of a free-market economy is that macroeconomic profit Qm is greater than zero. If Qm<0, recession/depression/breakdown results. This is the main economic principle; all other explanations of how the economy works are secondary. Utility/profit maximization or free people on free markets or competition or hard work or innovation or the entrepreneur do not keep the economy above the zero-profit cutoff. Scientifically, it's rather simple: no macroeconomic profit, no economy. But economists are only look-alike scientists. Austrians have never had enough brains to understand the objective/systemic facts, i.e., the existential preconditions. This means that the Austrian premise that the unfettered free-market economy is a self-adjusting, self-stabilizing, and self-optimizing system is axiomatically false. Austrianism has always been failed/fake science. They are political storytellers for an audience that cannot spot the difference between science and political agenda pushing. I am sure that Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto does not understand the economic basics that are summarized in table AXEC226f ⇓.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 14, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXLVIII)
“The State is an institution run by gangs of murderers, plunderers and thieves, surrounded by willing executioners, propagandists, sycophants, crooks, liars, clowns, charlatans, dupes and useful idiots.” (Hans-Hermann Hoppe) Whatever this is, it is not economics. But there are similarities. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations. This converges with Hans-Hermann Hoppe's philosophical insight about the State: The representative economist in general and the Austrian School economist in particular is NOT, and never has been, a competent scientist but an agenda pusher / useful idiot / impostor / phrase monger / storyteller / troll / pseudo-psychologist / self-gloryfier / heroic good-cause fighter / media talker / hallucinatory prophet / clown in the political Circus Maximus (AXEC108o ⇓).
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 14, 2026
Occasional X: How it works (DXLIV)
“Thomas Piketty built a global reputation on a single, seductive claim: capital accumulates faster than the economy grows, causing wealth to concentrate permanently at the top, and only aggressive redistribution fixes this. … But the entire foundation is rotten. Piketty's central formula, r > g (the return on capital exceeds economic growth), relies on projecting historical capital returns forward indefinitely.” (Handre) Let's generalize: both Piketty and Handre don't understand the investment cycle. The foundational error of legacy economics consists of the fact that the representative economist does not understand profit. As a logical consequence, distribution theory, monetary theory, value theory, etc. have been false since the Founding Fathers. To this day, economics is not a science because it does not get the foundational concepts right. Macroeconomics has always been axiomatically false. It has to be rectified first. This requires a Paradigm Shift. In the following, the problem is reduced to the bare bones. The new axiom set is given in lines 1-3 as shown in the table AXEC243a ⇓ The condition of market-clearing, i.e., X=O, is introduced in line 5. The condition defines the analytical causality. The market-clearing price P is here the dependent variable and is given for the specific and the general case in lines 5, 13, and 17. With the condition of budget-balancing added, i.e., Ec=Yw, that is ρEc=1, the price P is equal to unit wage costs W/R in line 5. Macroeconomic profit Qm is zero in line 7. In the most elementary case, the market-clearing price P moves with unit wage costs W/R. The workers always get the whole product O. Their real wage is equal to the productivity, i.e., W/P=R. General wage increases are pointless. The worker's living standard depends alone on the productivity R. The profit Qm for the business sector is zero. Price increases can come only from wage rate increases or from productivity decreases. The quantity of money is not a price determinant. The elementary production-consumption economy is then split into two equal firms. Thus, microeconomics and macroeconomics are consistent. The differentiated economy is given in the general form with lines 10-13. For a start, the two firms are equal in all respects. The market-clearing price is equal for both. Now, firm 1 produces the consumption good as before. Firm 2 produces an investment good instead (line 16). The households reduce their consumption spending, i.e., they save (line 16). Instead, the business sector buys the output of firm 2 with Ei1. The amount is equal to the former consumption expenditures, i.e., Ei1=Ec0. In this special case of the synchronous investment cycle, saving equals investment. However, the saving is done by the household sector, and the investment is done by the business sector. It is assumed here that the business sector takes credit from the banking sub-sector, and the household sector deposits its saving. Thus, the banking sub-sector's balance sheet says, in the old notation I=S, in the new notation Ei1=Sm1. It seems that the saving of the household sector finances the investment expenditures of the business sector. In fact, the two amounts are independent of each other and are only equal in the limiting case of a perfectly synchronous investment cycle. The profits of both firms are zero as before. In period 2, the investment goods are used for the production of the consumption goods in both firms. Firm 2 switches back from investment goods production to consumption goods production. The input of investment goods increases the productivity of the consumption goods production, i.e., R2>R0. Accordingly, the output increases with an unchanged total labor input L, compared to period 0. The productivity effect alone lowers the market-clearing price. However, the nominal demand increases because the savers of period 1 dissave in period 2. The resulting effect on the market-clearing price depends on the relative strengths of the two effects (line 17). It is assumed for the moment that the market-clearing price remains unchanged, i.e., Pc3=Pc0. In this case, the investment cycle produces a pure time transfer of the consumption goods from period 1 to period 2. Only if the price is lower do the saver-households get more in real terms. Saving in period 1 is 'rewarded' with more consumption goods in period 2, if the productivity effect is large enough. This increase can be interpreted as a real interest rate. However, the households that have not saved also benefit from the productivity effect in the form of a lower market-clearing price (line 17). Because the household sector dissaves, the business sector now makes a profit (line 18). Because the investment goods are used up in period 2, the depreciation is equal to the monetary profit Qm, and the net profit is zero. Over the whole synchronous investment cycle, the business sector's net profit is zero. Macroeconomically, the productivity effect does not translate into a profit effect. Only if one firm can increase its productivity and the others can not, this increase its profit. This is a partial effect that cannot be generalized. It leads to the intellectual shortcut that a productivity increase always means a profit increase. This is the typical microeconomic Fallacy of Composition. What remains is the productivity effect. The household sector benefits only if the productivity effect overcomes the dissaving effect. In this case, all households are 'rewarded', not only the savers/ dissavers. For the saving/dissaving households, a real interest rate can be calculated. This interest rate has nothing to do with the interest rate for the investment credit and the interest rate for saving deposits. As a consequence, the banking credit interest rate does not follow from the productivity effect of the investment. The difference between credit interest and deposit interest is, in the elementary case, equal to the bank's wage bill. The first conclusion from the synchronous investment cycle is that the accustomed business cycle theories are conceptually defective. A growing capital stock does not increase macroeconomic profit over the complete investment cycle. Only if one firm increases its capital stock and its productivity, its profit increases. However, because the market-clearing price decreases because of the productivity effect, the loss in firm 2 increases also. If firm 2 cannot also increase its productivity, it will go bankrupt. Thus, monopolization increases. Conclusion: Economists habitually confound partial and total effects. This is the Fallacy of Composition. In a synchronous investment cycle, the sum of macroeconomic net profit is zero. 'Piketty's central formula, r > g (the return on capital exceeds economic growth)' is provably false, because macroeconomic profit is produced by private/public deficit spending, i.e., not by the growth of capital but the growth of debt.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 14, 2026