“Profits drive the business cycle which means someone has to spend more than they make.” (Kyle Bear) The Levy/Kalecki Profit Equation is false https://t.co/pkoZclFwkc Reminder: For 200+ years, economics has claimed to be a science. But it still is not. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory & axiomatically false & materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. If the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. This also holds for the Levy/Kalecki profit equation.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 19, 2026
AXEC: New Foundations of Economics
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.
November 19, 2026
Occasional X: Clueless economists / Profit (CLXXIV)
Occasional X: Clueless economists / Profit (CLXXIII)
“And what exactly is your existential argument? If macroeconomic profit must be positive for capitalism to survive, have you explained how it arises, or merely declared it a necessary condition?” The most elementary version of the Profit Law says that, when the individual households in sum dissave, the firms of the business sector in sum make a profit, which is equal to the dissaving. This is the most elementary behavioral explanation of macroeconomic profit. Profit cannot be predicted ex ante, but measured exactly ex post. Macroeconomic profit is a free lunch for the business sector that does not depend on the entrepreneurs moral qualities or that they do something good for society. Actually, macroeconomic profit is distributed among firms such that the corrupt entrepreneur wins and the honest one loses. As the economy is differentiated, the Profit Law becomes more complex.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 19, 2026
November 18, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLIV)
Yes, if a thunderbolt hits you personally, you cannot buy a pair of shoes, and society has lost overall. Nothing is more real than destruction. Only Bastiat's individualistic straw men see it as an opportunity; society never did. What the broken-windows example proves is that profit creates perverse incentives in some heads. Among other things, the free-market economy makes profit of the misfortune of others.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 18, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLIII)
“You call the unseen nonexistent. Bastiat's broken window demolishes that claim. The glazier's income is visible. What the shopkeeper would have bought with that money instead is unseen.” (Rangaraj C) The shopkeeper incurs a profit reduction which is seen in the profit and loss account as depreciation. If a thunderbolt hits your house, you cannot complain that you would have spent the money instead on a holiday trip. Destruction is real; it is not unseen. Bastiat had NO idea how the economy works; he was just another agenda pusher/clown in the political Circus Maximus. “… I do not hold that Bastiat was a bad theorist. I hold that he was no theorist.” (Schumpeter)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 18, 2026
Occasional X: Clueless economists / Profit (CLXXII)
“… in economics, we call it spontaneous order. Ant colonies demonstrate how complex coordination can emerge without a central planner - proved by their survival. Human society exhibits comparable processes. These are not hallucinations. They are observable phenomena.” (Rangaraj C) Reasoning by false analogy is Austrianism's communicative modus operandi. It is scientifically worthless. Everybody understands that macroeconomic profit must be greater than zero. Otherwise, firms go bankrupt, and the breakdown starts. Therefore, profit has existential primacy in the free-market economy, not utility/profit-maximizing free people on free-markets or optimal allocation. Capitalism only survives because of macroeconomic profit. It has nothing to do with ants or central planning. Austrians never understood the system's objective/systemic existential precondition. The axiomatically correct macroeconomic Profit Law reads: Qm:=Yd+(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M). It holds for every monetary economy, independently of political ideology. Macroeconomic profit is equal in Capitalism and Socialism according to the Profit Law. Macroeconomic profit is produced by distributed profit Yd and the complementary balances of the other sectors. The formula is an observable phenomenon, measurable to two decimal places (under the obvious practical condition that macroeconomic accounting is complete). The minimum condition for the economic spontaneous order is Qm>0. In absolute contrast, von Mises's profit theory is a voodoo theory. To expect profit from correct anticipations is as good as to expect rain from the chief's rain dance.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 18, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLII)
“talking economics is usually about the unseen. If individual valuations, alternative uses of resources and foregone opportunities have to be supplied from outside your systemic equations, …” (Rangaraj C) Austrianism is essentially a pseudo-theory of the unseen: the Invisible Hand, subjective values, Hayek's almost perfectly allocating information mechanism, which is shrouded in impenetrable complexity, so that nobody can understand/use it, overlooked opportunity costs, etc. Austrians assert that we know nothing and therefore can do nothing, and better leave everything to the markets. However, if there is economic trouble, from the unseen will spring the entrepreneur and save the day, that is, if he were not strangled by red tape and paying taxes. Unfortunately, the unseen cannot be seen because it is non-existent. Austrianism has never been more than hallucination, self-deception, and political agenda pushing, abusing economic concepts. Mill had no friendly words for know-nothingers posing as scientists: “People fancied they saw the sun rise and set, the stars revolve in circles round the pole. We now know that they saw no such thing; what they really saw was a set of appearances, equally reconcileable with the theory they held and with a totally different one. It seems strange that such an instance as this, ..., should not have opened the eyes of the bigots of common sense, and inspired them with a more modest distrust of the competency of mere ignorance to judge the conclusions of cultivated thought.” For more details about Sophism in economics, see The economist as second-guesser, thought-reader, and folk psychologist https://t.co/kFabl5UT9o Sloppiness as economic methodology https://t.co/MEZDm5k6K6 Mental messies and loose losers https://t.co/jVoB7pRYj4
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 18, 2026
Occasional X: Economics and math ― they just can't get it together (XVII)
“But a rule of thumb is that the more dynamic, uncertain and ambiguous is the economic environment that you seek to model, the more you are going to have to roll up your sleeves, and learn and use some math. That's life.” (Sargent, quoted by Hevia) Of course, the Austrianian stance on math is as mentally rotten as one can get, but this does not prove that folks like Tom Sargent apply the appropriate math. Economics is cargo cult science, and this implies that they apply the wrong math. It has been made a priori in the (neo-)Walrasian hardcore propositions/axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub) HC2 introduces calculus, more precisely, constrained optimization. To axiomatize a behavioral assumption is the first methodological blunder; to formally specify it with calculus is the second blunder. However, this does not justify Austrianism's anti-math. The critique of mathiness is justified because the representative economist (i) used the false branch of math, and (ii) they committed tons of formal errors. For proof, see Barzilai and the crumbling of the unsafe citadel https://t.co/cLMQK9ieC1 Mathiness and the Ur-Blunder https://t.co/GnEHzPlV6P Profit (not mathematics) is the key https://t.co/kkkZquaGyE Cross-references: Math/Mathiness https://t.co/fDUM2CxdsP The history of economic thought is the history of scientific failure. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/ formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. When the axioms are inconsistent, mathematics cannot develop its analytical power. The move from the old behavioral axioms/math to the new systemic=behavior-free axioms is called a Paradigm Shift. Nothing less will do to get economics out of its proto-scientific deadlock. It's high time, after more than 200 years of proto-scientific garbage. Intellectually, folks like Tom Sargent will not survive the Paradigm Shift. The appropriate math of economics is the elementary algebra that underlies macroeconomic/ microeconomic accounting. One of the dumbest outcries in economics is still: That's an accounting identity.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 18, 2026