“10 TRUTHS ABOUT ADAM SMITH 1. From our present-day perspective, it is obvious that we do not agree with everything he said, but that does not change the fact that he is the greatest and most influential of them all.” (Diego Anguln) Adam Smith was not an original thinker, not a scientist, not an economist; he was a populist moralizer (AXEC179a ⇓). Economics has been failed/fake science since the Founding Fathers. It has defined itself as a social science and accordingly has been based on subjective/behavioral assumptions/axioms. This is the methodological ur-mistake. Economics is about how the economy works. It is a genuine systems science. Adam Smith made it a 'moral science'. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. The free-market economy runs on profit. Macroeconomic profit is given by the axiomatically correct Profit Law Qm≔(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M)+Yd. The Law implies PublicDeficit-Is-PrivateProfit Qm≔(G−T)>0, i.e., macroeconomic profit is (co-)produced by deficit-spending/money-creation, i.e., the growth of public debt. In free-market economies, public debt has increased with minor interruptions for over 200 years. Therefore, Qm≔(G−T)>0 is a critical element of the economy's survival. The minimum requirement of a free-market economy is that macroeconomic profit is greater than zero, i.e., Qm≥0. If Qm<0, recession/depression/breakdown results. This is the main economic principle; all other explanations of how the economy works are secondary. Utility/profit maximization or free people on free markets or competition or hard work or innovation or the risk-taking entrepreneur do not keep the economy above the zero-profit cutoff. Scientifically, it's rather simple: no macroeconomic profit, no economy. But economists are only look-alike scientists. They have never had enough brains to understand the objective, systemic facts, i.e., the existential preconditions. Free-market economies are temporarily saved from breakdown by the deficit-spending/money-creating duo of Treasury/Central Bank, i.e., the State. This means that Adam Smith's premise that the unfettered free-market economy is a self-adjusting, self-stabilizing, and self-optimizing system is axiomatically false. This does not prevent propagandists from applying the standard Marketing/PR tool, i.e., to produce arbitrary hit lists with their guy on top. This has always been show business with zero scientific content.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
AXEC: New Foundations of Economics
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.
November 22, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLIX)
Occasional X: Economics still lacks correct macrofoundations (XL)
“The desire of Microeconomics to resemble physics turns mainstream Macroeconomics into astrology: -There is no such thing as equilibrium in the economy -A simple sum of micro units does not equal the macro (fallacy of composition: Paradoxes of debt, liquidity, tranquility, risk, cost).” (Ilhan Dögüs) Almost right. The foundational error of legacy economics is that the representative economist does not understand profit. As a logical consequence, price theory, distribution theory, monetary theory, value theory, etc. have been false since the Founding Fathers. To this day, economics is not a science because it does not get the foundational concepts right. You think they can't all be wrong over the last 200+ years? Yes, they can. You think you can't be wrong? Yes, you are. The state of economics is this: there is political economics and scientific economics. The Founding Fathers called themselves political economists; that is, they left no doubt that their main business was agenda pushing. Economists never got out of political economics. From the beginning, economics has not been a science but silly political agenda pushing. There has not been genuine scientific progress since the Enlightenment, only changes in propaganda. Watch the sorry contemporary academic discussion. They're just turning over the proto-scientific dung heap without ever arriving at a result that satisfies the most elementary scientific principles. “Research is, in fact, a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant) Economics is materially/formally inconsistent, i.e., provably false. Economics has defined itself as a social science and accordingly has been based on subjective/behavioral assumptions/axioms. This is the methodological ur-mistake. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Economists violate foundational scientific principles: “In economics we should strive to proceed, wherever we can, exactly according to the standards of the other, more advanced, sciences, where it is not possible, once an issue has been decided, to continue to write about it as if nothing had happened.” (Morgenstern, 1941) Legacy economics is an example of the senseless repetition of brain rot and the abuse of Internet tools. Actually, economics is about how the economy works. It is a genuine systems science. To finally become a science, economics needs a Paradigm Shift from false Walrasian microfoundations and false Keynesian macrofoundations to true macrofoundations (AXEC121l ⇓).
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLVIII)
“If everyone studied the Austrian School the way I am, it would blow their minds. Doing my master’s with Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto is, without a doubt, the best investment of my life. That’s why I support JMilei, because I don’t just stick to theory; I also see how these ideas are being put into practice.” (Maria Elizabeth Huber) Maria Elizabeth Huber does not understand what science is all about. She has totally overlooked that, as a scientist, the economist has no mandate for political agenda-pushing. This has been known since the Founding Fathers. “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.” (J. S. Mill) For 200+ years, economics has claimed to be Science but still is not. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. As a consequence, economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations (AXEC141g ⇓); left/center/right does not matter. Economics has no truth-value, but only political use-value. The state of economics is this: there is political economics and scientific economics. The Founding Fathers called themselves political economists; that is, they left no doubt that their main business was agenda pushing. Economists never got out of the maelstrom of political economics. Scientific economics ultimately could not emancipate itself from political agenda-pushing. J. S. Mill was the only scientist among his low-IQ peers. He understood the difference between science and politics. After J. S. Mill, economics has been taken over by look-alike scientists. The representative economist is not, and never has been, a competent scientist, but an 1. agenda pusher 2. useful idiot 3. impostor 4. phrase monger 5. storyteller 6. troll 7. self-glorifier 8. pseudo-psychologist 9. speculative mind-reader 10. hallucinating prophet 11. media talker 12. vacuous philosopher 13. tireless reshuffler of the proto-scientific dungheap 14. clown in the political Circus Maximus. Maria Elizabeth Huber's commitment to Mr. Milei's Austrianism is a sure indicator that she has no clue what economics, understood as a science, is all about. How any economist can be proud of pushing Mr. Milei's agenda is beyond comprehension.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
Occasional X: Economists’ eternal problem with methodology (XXV)
“Schumpeter represents German Economics. The German School of Economics rejected the British hypothetico-deductive fictional equilibrium economics, adopted the scientific methodology & placed bank credit creation at the centre of analysis.” (Professor Richard A. Werner) There is a difference between the hypothetico-deductive method and equilibrium. The hypothetico-deductive method is not British but ancient Greek: “When the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.” (Aristotle, Analytica) Schumpeter understood this very well: “... the things (propositions) that we take for granted may be called indiscriminately either hypotheses or axioms or postulates or assumptions or even principles, and the things (propositions) that we think we have established by admissible procedure are called theorems.” J. S. Mill understood this very well: “What are the propositions which may reasonably be received without proof? That there must be some such propositions all are agreed, since there cannot be an infinite series of proof, a chain suspended from nothing. But to determine what these propositions are, is the opus magnum of the more recondite mental philosophy.” The method has been misunderstood/abused very much later, and this is where the idiocy of equilibrium came in: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub) The (neo-Walrasian) axiom set is as retarded as can be. It became the foundation of mainstream economics. Schumpeter was one of the few genuine scientists economics ever had, i.e., he formulated the economist's genuine task (AXEC196 ⇓). He certainly rejected the concept of equilibrium, which became central for post-war US academia. The crappyfication of the dominant school of economic thought explains why economics is a failed/fake science to this day. Monetary Theory is just one example. Professor Werner could perfect his monetary theory if he could rectify his methodological misunderstanding.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
Occasional X: Economists’ eternal problem with methodology (XXV)
“Dude, that’s just an accounting identity rearranged into a 'law.' It always adds up by math after the fact—it doesn’t cause profits or prove capitalism needs deficits to survive. Profits come from producing stuff people pay more for than it costs to make. Deficits just move money around.” (HRsteel) This is one of the popular errors: to believe that profit comes from increasing productivity. This holds only for partial productivity increases. The generalization to the economy as a whole is the Fallacy of Composition. This is beyond the micro-horizon of behavioral microeconomists. The proof is given in table AXEC235c ⇓. Microfoundations are known to be methodologically false; therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1-3. Under the initial analytical causality of line 4, and the conditions of market-clearing and budget-balancing, this yields the price P in line 5. The price is the dependent variable here. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R. The workers get the whole product O. Here, consumption good output O is the real GDP. The profit Qm for the business sector as a whole is zero in line 11. In the elementary production-consumption economy, i.e., in the evenly rotating elementary economy, the market-clearing and budget-balancing price P moves with unit wage costs W/R. The workers' real wage is equal to the productivity, i.e., W/P=R. Their living standard depends solely on the productivity R. General wage increases are pointless. Partial wage increases are not. They change the distribution among workers. Price increases can come only from wage rate increases or from productivity decreases. The quantity of money is not a price determinant. If the condition of budget balancing is lifted, the market clearing price is given by P=:ρEC*W/R in line 9. This formula replaces the silly Supply-Demand-Equilibrium cross. It is generalized in lines 15-21. In the most elementary case, the following relationships hold. If the productivity R increases, consumption good output O (undifferentiated real GDP) increases in line 2. Under the condition of market clearing, the price P falls in line 5. The nominal GDP, here Ec, stays the same under the condition of budget balancing, i.e., Ec=Yw. Profit is still zero in line 11. The price mechanism makes it so that there is NO relationship between a productivity increase and a profit increase. However, if there are two otherwise identical firms, and firm 1 increases productivity, then the common market price falls in line 18. As a result, firm 1's profit increases in line 19, and firm 2 makes a loss in line 20. Micro-brains see solely the effect in line 19 and generalize it. That's their methodological fault. From the partial effect stems the false shortcut: 'productivity increases boost profit'. Macroeconomic profit does not come from productivity increases but from deficit spending, i.e., ρE>1, in line 21. In sum, in the elementary case, a productivity increase does not show up in an increase in nominal GDP and not in an increase in macroeconomic profit Qm. Macroeconomic profit is not caused by productivity increases. The causation is expressed by the generalized Profit Law Qm≔(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M)+Yd. One of the dumbest statements in economics has always been: This is just an accounting identity. For an economist, it is self-defeating proto-scientific garbage. HRsteel is just a throwaway economist.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
Occasional X: Economists’ eternal problem with methodology (XXIV)
“What happened in our case was the other way around (as it probably often is). We built something constructive, ergodicity.” (Ole Petersen) Congratulations, you are the first commenter with a scientific mindset among the sorry bunch of incompetent economists. You introduced the concept of ergodicity. Unfortunately, that's the wrong physical concept. The underlying physical background of economics is entropy, i.e., the Second Law of Thermodynamics: “In an isolated system, total entropy never decreases. This explains why heat flows from hot objects to cold ones, ice melts, and physical processes have a preferred direction.” (Google AI) In simple general terms, the question is what is the ur-mover that animates a system? Popper put it thus: “... it is the central point of situational analysis that we need, in order to ‘animate’ it, no more than the assumption that the various persons or agents involved act adequately, or appropriately — that is to say, in accordance with the situation. ... Thus there is only one animating law involved ... It is known in the literature under the name of ‘rationality principle’, ... ” The rationality principle reappears in Walrasian economics as hardcore proposition/axiom HC2: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub) What is the common denominator of these animating laws? They are behavioral, i.e., not deep enough. What ultimately drives people is not psychology but physics, more specifically entropy. The first human task is to overcome the various forms of physical decay that work incessantly upon his body. When he fails, entropy swallows him up. The most important anti-entropy system is the economy. The economy is supposed to deliver all the material that the human body needs to temporarily overcome entropy — not only for him but for his offspring. Otherwise, the chain of life breaks. That's why Methodological Individualism is the wrong concept. Georgescu-Roegen was on the right way, Arrow on the wrong one. The animating law of the economy is not psychological, i.e., the rationality principle, or constrained optimization, or greed, or scarcity, or Praxeology, but the same law that animates the rest of the universe. Economics has defined itself as a social science and accordingly has been based on subjective/behavioral assumptions/axioms. This is the methodological ur-mistake. So, what does the most elementary economy that overcomes entropy look like? It looks like Graphic AXEC225e ⇓. Macroeconomics has always been axiomatically false. It has to be rectified first. This requires a Paradigm Shift. In the following, the problem is reduced to the bare bones. The new axiom set is given in lines 1-3. The analytical causality is defined here in line 4. The condition of market-clearing, i.e., X=O, is introduced in line 5. The market-clearing price P is here the dependent variable and is given with the condition of budget-balancing added, i.e., Ec=Yw, as P:=W/R in line 5. The most elementary version of the Profit Law states that the profit of the business sector Qm is equal to the dissaving of the household sector -Sm. Because saving/dissaving is initially zero, profit is zero here. In the most elementary case, the market-clearing price P moves with unit wage costs W/R. The workers always get the whole product O. Their real wage is equal to the productivity, i.e., W/P=R. The worker's living standard depends alone on the productivity R. General wage rate increases are pointless; partial are not. Price increases can come only from wage rate increases or from productivity decreases. The quantity of money is not a price determinant. The physical minimum condition is that natural productivity R is sufficient to overcome entropy with the maximum labor time L, i.e., O=RL, thus ensuring that a family's current generation can survive. The elementary production-consumption economy consists solely of systemic variables, not of psychological figments of the imagination, like utility maximization. Since the Founding Fathers, dilettantish psychological/ behavioral guesswork has prevented economics from becoming a science. Unfortunately, you use ergodicity as another behavioral concept.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
November 21, 2026
Occasional X: AI — boosting scientific competence in economics (XXII) / I=S
“Qm=I-Sm always holds ex-post.” (GDP Patriot) We are long through the macroeconomic blunder since Keynes's I=S. For details, see Cross-references: Refutation of I=S https://t.co/Zueuq4YUvA There is no need to endlessly repeat the refutation. AI can do this faster and put an end to brain-dead blather: 'AI dixit, causa finita'.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 21, 2026