“You call the unseen nonexistent. Bastiat's broken window demolishes that claim. The glazier's income is visible. What the shopkeeper would have bought with that money instead is unseen.” (Rangaraj C) The shopkeeper incurs a profit reduction which is seen in the profit and loss account as depreciation. If a thunderbolt hits your house, you cannot complain that you would have spent the money instead on a holiday trip. Destruction is real; it is not unseen. Bastiat had NO idea how the economy works; he was just another agenda pusher/clown in the political Circus Maximus. “… I do not hold that Bastiat was a bad theorist. I hold that he was no theorist.” (Schumpeter)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 18, 2026
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.
November 18, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLIII)
November 17, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDLI)
“This looks remarkably like an attempt to accomplish intellectually what the Soviet Union attempted politically: replace the market process with an aggregate economic construct.” (Rangaraj C) When Austrians run out of their last brain cells and cannot refute anything according to the rules of scientific methodology, they resort to their knock-out association: That's like the Soviet Union. There is a difference between refutation and denunciation. Refutation refers to science; denunciation refers to brain-dead political agenda pushing.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 17, 2026
November 16, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXLIX)
“Proverb About 'The First Is Best' (Diminishing Returns) … Russians often use: • Russian: Хорошего понемножку (Khoroshego ponemnozhku). • Literal translation: 'Good things in small amounts.' • Meaning: Too much of a good thing spoils the experience, so it is best to stop while you are still enjoying it.” (Google AI) Austrian economists think they have made a big discovery by reformulating an age-old Russian proverb and rebranding it as Marginalism. “Every good you own loses value to you the more of it you have. That single sentence is the whole of marginal utility, and once you see it, you cannot unsee it.” (Handre) From this age-old triviality does not follow how Capitalism or Socialism work. The proof is in the scientific failure of Austrianism. From accepting diminishing returns does not follow accepting low-IQ Austrian political agenda pushing.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 16, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (XCLI)
“The mathematical system does not invent the parachute. Human beings do.” (Rangaraj C) Scientists figure out the laws of aerodynamics/material science to understand how parachutes work. Economists tell one that the jumper maximises his utility. The Austrian School tells one that 'humans act with purpose'. These mental Flat-Earthers still have not figured out how the economic system works. Austrians suffer from the Fallacy of Insufficient Abstraction. The subject matter of economics is the economy, and this is an abstract entity that is NOT observable with the two natural eyes but only with the third eye of theory. Theory is a consistent axiomatic/deductive construct. The Austrian Action Axiom is proto-scientific garbage. Nothing of scientific value has ever come from it. Austrianism is refuted on all counts.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 16, 2026
November 15, 2026
Occasional X: Economists’ eternal problem with methodology (XVIII)
“Before studying the economic system, we must answer a more fundamental question: whose choices, whose valuations and whose purposes generate it?” (Rangaraj C) Imagine a boy throwing a stick towards an apple tree, causing an apple to fall and hit Newton on the head. In a flash, Newton then developed the Law of Universal Gravitation, which he published in his book Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica in 1687. He completely ignored the boy's behavior. Austrians, on the contrary, can explain in great detail why the historical event happened and even figure out that the boy maximized the utility of his ADHD syndrome. But, due to the lack of the ability for abstraction, they will never arrive at universal gravitation, i.e., science. Analogously, everybody knows why and how to use a toothbrush, but has no clue what the Law of the Lever says. 'The Law was formally formulated and proven by the ancient Greek mathematician and engineer Archimedes (c. 287–212 BC) in his treatise On the Equilibrium of Planes.” (Google AI) In a nutshell, that's the difference between low-IQ storytelling and science.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (XCL)
“Hume's is–ought problem exposes a fundamental distinction: no number of statements about what is can logically generate what ought to be.” (Rangaraj C) Yes, science and politics are two different things. Austrianism is materially/formally inconsistent. With Praxeology, it misapplied the axiomatic/deductive method, and it cannot escape the final judgment that it has always been political agenda pushing in the garb of science. Austrians are not alone; other political agenda pushers have captured economics early on and ruined all scientific content. This is why economics has been proto-scientific garbage from the Enlightenment onward. Economists never had a mandate for political agenda pushing: “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.” (J. S. Mill) For over 200 years, economics has claimed to be a science, but it still isn't. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Economics has no scientific truth-value, only political use-value. Economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations. Austrianism is the smoking-gun proof. It never rose above low-IQ political blather. Their main talking points are freedom and democracy. Economics is a genuine systems science; therefore, Hume's is-ought distinction does not come up. To this day, Austrians do not understand profit, which is the discipline's defining concept, and this tells one all about their scientific level. It is non-existent.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
November 14, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXIX)
“The more I delve into my Economics studies in Madrid and the more I listen to the lectures and classes of Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto, the more convinced I am that economic freedom, private property, and entrepreneurship are fundamental pillars of a prosperous society.” (Maria Elizabeth Huber) The Austrian School is refuted on all counts. They never understood profit, and by logical consequence, how the economic system works. That is self-defeating. The economy runs on profit. The minimum requirement of a free-market economy is that macroeconomic profit Qm is greater than zero. If Qm<0, recession/depression/breakdown results. This is the main economic principle; all other explanations of how the economy works are secondary. Utility/profit maximization or free people on free markets or competition or hard work or innovation or the entrepreneur do not keep the economy above the zero-profit cutoff. Scientifically, it's rather simple: no macroeconomic profit, no economy. But economists are only look-alike scientists. Austrians have never had enough brains to understand the objective/systemic facts, i.e., the existential preconditions. This means that the Austrian premise that the unfettered free-market economy is a self-adjusting, self-stabilizing, and self-optimizing system is axiomatically false. Austrianism has always been failed/fake science. They are political storytellers for an audience that cannot spot the difference between science and political agenda pushing. I am sure that Professor Jesús Huerta de Soto does not understand the economic basics that are summarized in table AXEC226f ⇓.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 14, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXLVIII)
“The State is an institution run by gangs of murderers, plunderers and thieves, surrounded by willing executioners, propagandists, sycophants, crooks, liars, clowns, charlatans, dupes and useful idiots.” (Hans-Hermann Hoppe) Whatever this is, it is not economics. But there are similarities. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations. This converges with Hans-Hermann Hoppe's philosophical insight about the State: The representative economist in general and the Austrian School economist in particular is NOT, and never has been, a competent scientist but an agenda pusher / useful idiot / impostor / phrase monger / storyteller / troll / pseudo-psychologist / self-gloryfier / heroic good-cause fighter / media talker / hallucinatory prophet / clown in the political Circus Maximus (AXEC108o ⇓).
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 14, 2026
November 13, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXLVII)
“Nobody can be a great economist who is only an economist.” (Friedrich Hayek) “Nobody can be a great economist who does not understand profit.” (AXEC) Because Austrians never understood profit, their implicit claim to be great economists has never been more than the self-deception of mental dwarfs.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 13, 2026
Occasional X: Economists’ eternal problem with methodology (XVII)
“That's why Ludwig von Mises believed economics requires a fundamentally different method. Praxeology, developed by Mises and refined by Murray Rothbard, begins with one undeniable axiom: human beings act purposefully to achieve ends using scarce means. From this single truth, all valid economic propositions are derived through logical deduction rather than observation or experimentation.” (Creative Deduction) Already, J. S. Mill claimed that economics is an 'inexact and separate science'. For details, see Economics is NOT a social science https://t.co/XlYPTxZ0HH Mill's escape clause never worked because there is only one science: “Research is, in fact, a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant) Austrianism is materially/formally inconsistent. It misapplied the axiomatic/deductive method‡, and it cannot escape the final judgement that it has always been political agenda pushing in the garb of science. Austrians are not alone; other political agenda pushers have captured economics early on and ruined all scientific content. This is why economics has been proto-scientific garbage from the Enlightenment onward. Reminder: Economists never had a mandate for political agenda pushing: “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.” (J. S. Mill) For over 200 years, economics has claimed to be a science, but it still isn't. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Economics has no scientific truth-value, only political use-value. Economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations. Austrianism is the smoking-gun proof except for people who have less than two brain cells. Austrians are not, and never have been, competent scientists but agenda pushers / useful idiots / impostors / phrase mongers / storytellers / trolls / pseudo-psychologists / self-gloryfier / clowns in the political Circus Maximus. ‡ “It is, therefore, natural and indispensable to separate the process of investigation into two parts; and obtain general formulæ for determining what inferences may be drawn, before the occasion arises for drawing the inferences. The work of drawing them is then that of applying the formulæ; and the rules of syllogism are a system of securities for the correctness of the application.” (J. S. Mill, 1882, A System of Logic) With Praxeology, von Mises messed up the first part.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 13, 2026
Occasional X: Paradigm Shift (CXXXIII)
“Well said except economics is not about how an economy works. It is the study of allocating scarce resources that have alternative uses.” (Ray Lauletti) Parroting Robbins's pseudo-scientific definition keeps you and your Austrian buddies in the mental trap. Accustomed behavioral definitions of economics: “It is a touchstone of accepted economics that all explanations must run in terms of the actions and reactions of individuals.” (Arrow, 1994) “Economics is the science which studies human behavior as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.” (Robbins, 1935) Axiomatically correct objective-systemic definition: “Economics is the science that studies how the economic system works.” (AXEC) Here is Robbins's methodological blunder in a nutshell: “The propositions of economic theory, like all scientific theory, are obviously deductions from a series of postulates. And the chief of these postulates are all assumptions involving in some way simple and indisputable facts of experience….’ With this methodology, axioms are certain, and logical deductions are certain, so there is no room for conflict with experience. This is exactly the same as axiomatic Greek geometry, which can never be wrong because it is based on certainties and driven by logic.” There is no such thing as 'simple and indisputable facts of experience'. Observation is theory-laden perception. From the beginning, Austrianism has suffered from the Fallacy of Insufficient Abstraction. The move from the old behavioral definition to the new systemic=behavior-free definition of economics is called a Paradigm Shift. Nothing less will do to get economics out of its proto-scientific deadlock. It's high time, after more than 200 years of proto-scientific garbage.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 13, 2026
November 10, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXVIII)
@PeterSurda @Lord_Keynes3 You overlook that Murray Rothbard defends Extreme Apriorism. Austrianism is contradictory, not only with regard to methodology. Strictly speaking, it has always been proto-scientific garbage for a low-IQ audience.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 10, 2026
November 9, 2026
Occasional X: Time to get the axioms of economics right (X)
“Keine Erfahrung kann je gemacht werden, die dem widersprechen könnte./No experience could ever contradict this.” (von Mises, Nationalökonomie, quoted by Lord Keynes answering Robert Murphy) “A theory which is not refutable by any conceivable event is non-scientific. Irrefutability is not a virtue of a theory (as people often think) but a vice.” (Karl Popper, Google AI)‡ Austrianism has been non-scientific from the very beginning. Nothing has changed in the meantime. Austrianism is still proto-scientific garbage. ‡ “If you are looking for his most famous explicit quote on the scientific invalidity of irrefutable theories, it is found in his 1963 essay collection, Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge (Chapter 1).”
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 9, 2026
November 7, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXXXVII)
“The core Keynesian error is treating consumption as the engine of wealth. Keynes fixated on aggregate demand, the total spending flowing through an economy, as the variable governments must manage. Boost it artificially, and you rescue the economy. Production precedes consumption. …Government stimulus spending doesn't create resources. It redirects them. When Washington borrows a billion dollars and injects it into infrastructure or green energy, it pulls that capital away from whatever private actors would have funded.” (Handre) Economic debate suffers from the fact that economics is a failed/fake science. Economists do not know what profit is, and consequently, how the economic system works. It's been that way ever since Adam Smith. Both Keynesianism and Austrianism is proto-scientific garbage. The free-market economy runs on profit. Macroeconomic profit Qm is given by the axiomatically correct Profit Law Qm:=(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M)+Yd. The Law implies Qm≔(I−Sm)>0 for Early Capitalism, and it implies Qm≔(G−T)>0 for Late Capitalism. Keynes observed that investment expenditures I were insufficient; therefore, the balance (I−Sm) was too low. He proposed to compensate the shortfall with a bigger balance (G−T) of public deficit spending. Handre's claim that this “pulls capital away from whatever private actors would have funded” is a hallucination because the actual problem was that there never were private actors in the wings to fund private investment I in the first place. In the monetary economy, investment is not restricted by the household sector's saving Sm. If Sm is zero, investment is fully financed by credit and retained profit. In free-market economies, public debt has increased with minor interruptions for 200+ years. So, Qm≔(G−T)>0 is a crucial ingredient of Capitalism's life elixir. Everybody understands that the overriding principle of economics is that macroeconomic profit is greater than zero; otherwise, firms start going bankrupt, and the breakdown begins. All other principles are secondary at best. Neither utility maximization nor profit maximization nor efficient resource allocation keeps the economy above the zero-profit cutoff. Currently, the free-market economy is temporarily saved from breakdown by the deficit-spending/money-creating duo of Treasury/Central Bank, i.e., the State. This means that the premise of legacy economics, i.e., that the unfettered free-market economy is a self-adjusting, self-stabilizing, and self-optimizing system, is axiomatically false. This means that economics is a failed/fake science. Ultimately, this means that the representative economist is too stupid to understand the elementary algebra that underlies macroeconomic accounting. Austrians can't get beyond their microeconomic/ behavioral horizon. Math was never their strong suit. From the fact that the free-market economy thrives on positive/increasing macroeconomic profit, which, in turn, stems mainly from the State's deficit-spending/money-creation, it follows immediately that budget-balancing/debt-reduction turns macroeconomic profit into loss, and this means that the free-market economy cannot dismount from the debt tiger. Because of deficit-spending/money-creation, i.e., of the free lunches for the Oligarchy, the distribution of income/wealth becomes progressively more extreme. As the debt grows, the number of millionaires/billionaires/zillionaires grows exponentially. Since the household sector is taxed for interest, there is an absolute upper limit for the growth of public debt, which is given by public_debt times avg_interest_rate ≦wage_income. Economic problems, though, start much earlier because of other irreducible items in the budget (military, health, etc.) and a not exactly known upper tax-to-income limit. The breakdown of the free-market economy is a systemic inevitability. The important thing is not whether it will happen, but when. The current system can only exist as a nominally growing economy. If debt growth stops, macroeconomic profit approaches zero, and the economy implodes. Austrians correctly observe the lethal weaknesses of the free-market system. Their communicative modus operandi is to simply attribute all economic misdevelopments to the State and to advertize the unchained entrepreneur as the economic savior who is eagerly waiting in the wings. The fact is, behind the wings there has never been anything.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 7, 2026
November 5, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXVII)
“Rothbard put it in italics, so Alex Pollock read it twice at the Summit: 'The natural tendency of the state is inflation.' Money is normally got by producing something. There is another way—create it, and produce nothing.” (Mises Media) The Founding Fathers defined economics as a social science, and accordingly, it has been based on subjective/behavioral assumptions/axioms. In Austrianism, it's the Praxeology Axiom. This has been the methodological ur-mistake. Actually, economics is about how the economy works. It is a systems science, and NOT a social science. The major approaches (Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, and their derivatives) are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. They all got profit wrong. When the subject's foundational concepts are inconsistent, the entire analytical superstructure is scientifically worthless. Consequently, economic policy guidance has never had valid scientific foundations. To this day, it has no scientific truth-value but only political use-value. Austrianism is a case in point. Ludwig von Mises never understood profit, and by logical consequence, how the economic system works. That's self-defeating. The free-market economy runs on profit. Macroeconomic profit is given by the axiomatically correct Profit Law Qm≔(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M)+Yd. The Law implies PublicDeficit-Is-PrivateProfit Qm≔(G−T)>0, i.e., macroeconomic profit is (co-)produced by deficit-spending/money-creation, i.e., the growth of public debt. In free-market economies, public debt has increased with minor interruptions for over 200 years. Therefore, Qm≔(G−T)>0 is a critical element of the economy's survival. The minimum requirement of a free-market economy is that macroeconomic profit is greater than zero, i.e., Qm≥0. If Qm<0, recession/depression/breakdown results. This is the main economic principle; all other explanations of how the economy works are secondary at best. Utility/profit maximization or free people on free markets or competition or hard work or innovation or the entrepreneur or optimal allocation do not keep the economy above the zero-profit cutoff. Scientifically, it's rather simple: no macroeconomic profit, no economy. But economists are only look-alike scientists. They have never had enough brains to understand the objective, systemic facts, i.e., the existential preconditions. Free-market economies are temporarily saved from breakdown by the deficit-spending/money-creating duo of Treasury/Central Bank, i.e., the State. This means that the Austrian premise that the unfettered free-market economy is a self-adjusting, self-stabilizing, and self-optimizing system is axiomatically false. Austrianism is failed/fake science. Neither von Mises nor the sorry bunch of followers ever understood what keeps the economy going. On the contrary, Austrianism claims that the State is the root of all evil. That's moral blaming, not science. Rothbard was a silly agenda pusher, not a competent scientist. Because Austrianism is axiomatically false, its Theory of Money is false. For the axiomatically correct approach, see the working paper ⇒ The Dark-Matter Theory of Fiat Money https://t.co/0QSqFFstKv
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 5, 2026
November 3, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXVI)
“Before Carl Menger published his Principles of Economics in 1871, mainstream economic thought was a muddle of half-truths, moral philosophy dressed as science, and a value theory so broken it could not explain why water costs less than diamonds. The classical school, anchored by Adam Smith and David Ricardo, gave the world the labor theory of value. Price, they believed, derived from the labor embedded in production.” (Handre) Adam Smith/David Ricardo were scientifically incompetent, and Menger was no better. The most obvious mistakes with his value theory are: (i) First of all, water and diamonds are different kinds of goods. Water is produced and consumed in one period; diamonds are forever. Menger confounded perishable consumption goods with non-financial assets, i.e., a physical store of value; i.e., he confounded non-durables and durables. Methodologically, this means getting the relationship between flows and stocks wrong. (ii) The marginal utility of one person does not matter much, because the market transforms a great number of diverse subjective valuations into one objective price for all. Menger fails to show how this transformation works. For the correct answer, see The Logical Interface Between Objective Macrofoundations and Subjective Valuations https://t.co/8NXaiPVsHv (iii) The question of value does not arise outside the economic system, where labor gets a wage, and the output is sold on the market. The Value Theory presupposes a monetary economy. The marginal utility of water for some freak guy in the desert is irrelevant to the market price of water. (iv) The subjective value has ultimately to be backed up by an objective amount of money. The subjective value of water may be high, but if the agent can maximally spend his income and if his income is very small, the thirsty person cannot buy enough water and leaves the market to die in some dark corner. The survivors understand that the market is not primarily an efficient information mechanism but a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism that makes sure, with some unintelligible Invisible-Hand trick, that the rich person survives the poor person if scarcity becomes extreme. These four methodological mistakes are sufficient to make Menger's approach scientifically worthless and all Austrian propagandists unemployed. The methodologically correct approach is summarized in table AXEC233b ⇓. Microfoundations are methodologically false; therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1, 2, 3. The business sector is later differentiated in lines 15, 16, 17. Under the initial analytical conditions of market-clearing, i.e., X=O, and budget-balancing, i.e., Ec=Yw, this yields the price P in line 5. For a start, the price is the dependent variable here. This is a starting condition that is lifted later. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R in line 5. The workers get the whole product O. The profit Qm for the business sector as a whole is zero. Now, the condition of budget balancing is lifted, i.e., nominal demand is not determined by income. Accordingly, the two market-clearing prices depend on the respective expenditure ratios ρE1, ρE2 and unit wage costs W1/R1, W2/R2 in lines 18, 19. The measurable expenditure ratio is a proxy for the consolidated multitude of unmeasurable individual subjective values. As a result, relative prices are given in line 20. For the special case of budget balancing, i.e., ρE1=1, ρE2=1, and equal wages W1, W2, in both production lines, the relative price is equal to the inverse productivities. It is not proportional to labor time input. This result can be projected back to the original Labour Theory of Value and amounts to a refutation. It reveals the scientific incompetence of Austrian economists from Menger onward.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 3, 2026
November 2, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXV)
“For decades, classical economists like Adam Smith struggled to explain why water was cheap, while diamonds, largely useless luxuries, commanded a fortune. Austrian economist Carl Menger solved the diamond-water paradox by pioneering the concept of subjective marginal utility, pointing out that economists had mistakenly concluded that 'value in use' and 'value in exchange' were entirely separate concepts driven by production costs.” (Creative Deduction) Adam Smith was scientifically incompetent, and Menger was no better. The most obvious mistakes with his value theory are: (i) First of all, water and diamonds are different kinds of goods. Water is produced and consumed in one period; diamonds are forever. Menger confounded perishable consumption goods with non-financial assets, i.e., a physical store of value; i.e., he confounded non-durables and durables. Methodologically, this means getting the relationship between flows and stocks wrong. (ii) The marginal utility of one person does not matter much, because the market transforms a great number of diverse subjective valuations into one objective price for all. Menger fails to show how this transformation works. For the correct answer, see The Logical Interface Between Objective Macrofoundations and Subjective Valuations https://t.co/8NXaiPW0x3 (iii) The question of value does not arise outside the economic system, where labor gets a wage, and the output is sold on the market. The Value Theory presupposes a monetary economy. The marginal utility of water for some freak guy in the desert is irrelevant to the market price of water. (iv) The subjective value has ultimately to be backed up by an objective amount of money. The subjective value of water may be high, but if the agent can maximally spend his income and if his income is very small, the thirsty person cannot buy enough water and leaves the market to die in some dark corner. The survivors understand that the market is not primarily an efficient information mechanism but a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism that makes sure, with some unintelligible Invisible-Hand trick, that the rich person survives the poor person if scarcity becomes extreme. These four methodological mistakes are sufficient to make Menger's approach scientifically worthless and all Austrian propagandists unemployed. The methodologically correct approach is summarized in table AXEC233b ⇓. Microfoundations are methodologically false; therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1, 2, 3. The business sector is later differentiated in lines 15, 16, 17. Under the initial analytical conditions of market-clearing, i.e., X=O, and budget-balancing, i.e., Ec=Yw, this yields the price P in line 5. For a start, the price is the dependent variable here. This is a starting condition that is lifted later. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R in line 5. The workers get the whole product O. The profit Qm for the business sector as a whole is zero. Now, the condition of budget balancing is lifted, i.e., nominal demand is not determined by income. Accordingly, the two market-clearing prices depend on the respective expenditure ratios ρE1, ρE2 and unit wage costs W1/R1, W2/R2 in lines 18, 19. The measurable expenditure ratio is a proxy for the consolidated multitude of unmeasurable individual subjective values. As a result, relative prices are given in line 20. For the special case of budget balancing, i.e., ρE1=1, ρE2=1, and equal wages W1, W2, in both production lines, the relative price is equal to the inverse productivities. It is not proportional to labor time input. This result can be projected back to the original Labour Theory of Value and amounts to a refutation. It reveals the scientific incompetence of Austrian economists from Menger onward.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 2, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXXIII)
“Hayek has taught us this lesson about pricing, over and over again. Free-market prices have an important role to play in our society, in our economy. They convey precious information.” (Walter Block) Hayek never understood profit and, by logical consequence, how the markets function. His efficiency story is a benign interpretation of what the price mechanism, i.e., the Invisible Hand of the Oligarchy, really does. The free-market system is, in the last instance, a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism, i.e., the economic analog to triage in medicine. For example, during a famine, only the rich person can pay the high price of bread and survive. In contrast, the poor person leaves the market empty-handed to die of starvation. The market's primary function is NOT efficient information-processing/resource-allocation (Hayek's hallucination) but the redistribution of the Quality-of-Life. In economically extreme situations, the Invisible Hand kills anonymously. Because the price mechanism is a powerful tool, the most important task of an economist ― who is smart enough to know on which side his bread is buttered ― is to praise its informational magic, its efficiency, or its welfare effects. This distracts from the fact of selection. The optical illusion is this: the price is co-determined by nominal demand, and demand depends on different earnings, profit distribution, and different accumulated wealth. The price structure distributes, in any period, real output/wealth to already existing financial wealth. It distributes the Quality-of-Life. The problem is that richness often does not come from merit but from fraud, exploitation, organized crime, primitive accumulation, stealing innovative ideas, or from big-style printing counterfeit money. The quasi-Darwinian free-market selection mechanism increases the survival chances of the corrupt and decreases it for the honest. For details, see How it works https://t.co/lqv0W118dK The price mechanism has not much to do with abstract optimal allocation of resources but makes sure that the Quality-of-Life is ultimately allocated to the Oligarchy. Everybody understands that macroeconomic profit must be greater than zero. Otherwise, firms go bankrupt, and the breakdown starts. Therefore, profit has existential primacy in the free-market economy, not utility/profit-maximizing free people on free-markets or optimal allocation. The axiomatically correct macroeconomic profit formula reads: Qm:=Yd+(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M). It holds for every monetary economy, independently of political ideology. Macroeconomic profit is equal in Capitalism and Socialism according to the Profit Law. The Profit Law implies Public-Deficit-is-Private-Profit Qm:=(G−T)>0, i.e., macroeconomic profit is (co-)produced by deficit-spending/money-creation, i.e., the growth of public debt. In free-market economies, public debt has increased with minor interruptions for over 200 years. Therefore, Qm:=(G−T)>0 must be considered a critical factor for Capitalism's survival. Capitalism is temporarily saved from breakdown by the deficit-spending/money-creating duo of Treasury/Central Bank, i.e., the State. The State has existential primacy, not the free-market or the price system. Capitalists and Socialists have never really understood what profit was. Friedrich Hayek never came intellectually above the microeconomic level and fell foul of the Fallacy of Composition. He was not a competent scientist but a political agenda pusher. More precisely, Hayek was a political agenda pusher for the Oligarchy in the guise of science. He added intellectual corruption to the system of financial corruption.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 2, 2026
November 1, 2026
Occasional X: How it works (DXXXII)
Why the Worst Get on Top is the title of Ch. 10 in Friedrich Hayek's book The Road to Serfdom. In the free-market economy, profit may provide a strong incentive to corruption/organized crime. According to quasi-Darwinian logic, the most corrupt survives. The proof is given in table AXEC221b ⇓. Microfoundations are methodologically false; therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1, 4, 7. The business sector is split into two identical firms in lines 1-2, 4-5, 7-8. Under the initial analytical conditions of market-clearing and budget-balancing, this yields the price P in line 16. For a start, the price is the dependent variable here. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R, and equal for both firms. The workers get the whole product O. The profit Qm for both firms and the business sector as a whole is zero. Now, the wage rate W in firm 1 is lowered arbitrarily; otherwise, both firms are identical in every respect. As a result, the market price P decreases in line 12. The profit of firm 1 increases in line 19; firm 2 makes a loss in line 20. Total profit remains zero. The household sector as a whole still gets the whole product O, but the workers of firm 1 can buy less with their lower wage income; the workers of firm 2 can buy more with their unchanged wage rate W and a lower price P. The firm that somehow manages to pay less for the same labor input increases profit Qm. Firm 2 makes a loss and will go bankrupt if it does not also make a wage cut. As a result, firm 1 wins the race to the bottom. The workers of firm 1 cannot move to firm 2 because it no longer hires or doesn't exist any longer. This process of cross-over exploitation is inherent to capitalism and inevitably leads to higher concentration. If a firm can undercut minimum wage regulations, it can be said that the criminal firm wins and the honest firm loses. What remains in the long run is a degenerated/ corrupted free-market economy. On closer inspection, economics is revealed as the story of intra-sectoral cross-over exploitation among the firms of the business sector and among the households of the household sector. Sociologically, this means there are no classes with a common interest. Ultimately, the market is not primarily an allocation mechanism but a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism that increases the survival chances of the corrupt and decreases them for the honest. This is why guilds have emerged historically. Basically, they are self-organized associations of the honest against the corrupt, with honor as the guiding behavioral principle. Honor was replaced with the freedom of licit/illicit profit maximisation, which favors the corrupt.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 1, 2026
October 30, 2026
Occasional X: The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism (CXXXIV)
“You haven’t exposed an Austrian deception. …First, Mises never claimed that markets operate like parliamentary democracies.” (Roaldcs) Already false: “The statement (“The market is a democracy. Capitalism is the consummation of the self-determination of consumers.”) is found in Ludwig von Mises's book Omnipotent Government: The Rise of the Total State and Total War (first published in 1944).” (Google AI) It is one of the tenets of Austrianism that a free-market economy and democracy are necessary complements. More precisely, the political concept of democracy is taken as the main selling proposition of an allegedly scientific theory. Logically, the free-market system should be justified as a superior economic system, not as the twin brother of freedom and democracy. Austrians have never done this. The Austrian approach has been proto-scientific garbage from the beginning. People buy the package, not the content. The package is shiny, the content is cheap crap. The Austrian package is freedom and democracy. Austrian economics is proto-scientific garbage. Austrian arguments have already been refuted one-by-one. For details, see the AXECquery The futile attempt to recycle Austrianism https://t.co/netz8fcVyf Austrians simply violate the foundational scientific principle: “In economics we should strive to proceed, wherever we can, exactly according to the standards of the other, more advanced, sciences, where it is not possible, once an issue has been decided, to continue to write about it as if nothing had happened.” (Morgenstern, 1941) Austrianism is the senseless repetition of long refuted arguments. It's a treadmill of stupidity. Their dumbest phrase is: That's only an accounting identity. Yes, accounting identities are systemic laws, and they are the logical precondition of testing. None of the behavioral hallucinations of Austrianism is testable. Austrians do not understand the difference between science and a quasi-religious Wahnsystem. Human-Nature economists in general, and Austrians in particular, are scientifically incompetent imbeciles and methodologically in the darkest woods. Economists never had a political mandate, as J. S. Mill already knew (AXEC166a ⇓).
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) October 30, 2026