“Private markets contain mechanisms to guide economic actors. Property rights over the means of production incentivize owners to use resources efficiently because they reap the rewards for doing so and bear the costs of failing to do so.” (Christopher Coyne & Abigail Hall) Actually, private markets contain mechanisms to systematically guide economic actors to corrupt/criminal behavior. The representative economist never understood cross-over exploitation. He never understood profit, and consequently, how the economic system works. Scientific incompetence and utter ignorance are the representative economist's normal mental states. Left/center/right does not matter. The proof is given in table AXEC221b ⇓. Microfoundations are methodologically false. First, a Paradigm Shift is required. Therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1, 4, 7. Under the initial analytical conditions of market-clearing and budget-balancing, this yields the price P in line 16. The price is the dependent variable here. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R. The workers get the whole product O. The profit Qm for the business sector is zero. Then, the business sector is split. The axioms are differentiated in lines 1-2, 4-5, 7-8 Now, the wage rate W in firm 1 is lowered arbitrarily; otherwise, both firms are identical in every respect. As a result, the market price P decreases in line 12. The profit of firm 1 increases in line 19; firm 2 makes a loss in line 20. Total profit remains zero. The household sector as a whole still gets the whole product O, but the workers of firm 1 can buy less with their lower wage income; the workers of firm 2 can buy more with their unchanged wage rate W and a lower price P. The Invisible Hand redistributes. The firm that somehow manages to pay less for the same labor input increases profit Qm. Firm 2 makes a loss and will go bankrupt if it does not also make a wage cut. As a result, firm 1 wins the race to the bottom. The workers of firm 1 cannot evade the wage cut and move to firm 2 because it no longer hires or doesn't exist any longer. This process of cross-over exploitation is inherent to Capitalism and inevitably leads to higher concentration. Cross-over exploitation means that one firm gains at the cost of the others, and that one group of workers gains at the cost of the others. That means that there are no classes with a common interest. Politically, intra-sectoral competition incentivizes 'class treason'. Both the economic and the political sphere favor the corrupt persons in a State, if unchecked. As a rule of thumb, the evolutionary outlook of free-market economies is not socially progressive but inherently degenerative. If profit is positive in the initial state, firm 1 increases profit, and firm 2 decreases it. If a firm can undercut minimum wage regulations, it can be said that the criminal firm wins and the honest firm loses. What remains in the long run is a degenerated/corrupted free-market economy. Other incentives work in the same direction. A firm can increase its productivity and profits with the adoption of an invention. This is the first half of the chain of interrelations. The other firms then make a loss and are pushed to the brink of bankruptcy. The first firm has an incentive to keep the invention secret, because if the other firm can adapt, the profit lead vanishes again. The systemic incentive is to restrict the spread of innovation. The Schumpeter effect only appears if knowledge is public. On closer inspection, economics is revealed as intra-sectoral cross-over exploitation among firms and among households. Ultimately, the market is not primarily an allocation mechanism but a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism that increases the survival chances of the corrupt entrepreneur and decreases them for the honest.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 9, 2026
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.
November 9, 2026
Occasional X: How it works (DXXXIX)
November 1, 2026
Occasional X: How it works (DXXXI)
“If only 4% of gains went to innovators and we got so much innovation, what if property rights were tightened? What if they could appropriate 5% instead? How much more innovation would we get?” (Vincent Geloso) Innovators and creative geniuses are the most exploited group in the free-market system. Business has captured the real wealth creators. As a rule of thumb, not those who create and ultimately enhance the productivity of the economic system get wealthy, but those who employ or sponsor them — or simply steal their ideas. Of course, the group/generations of innovators and creative geniuses deserve 100 percent of the gains. How could they appropriate it? For details, see How it works (DXXX) https://t.co/ibUuwn8flm
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 1, 2026
Occasional X: How it works (DXXX)
“Generations of students learned economics through the Samuelson and Nordhaus textbook. But my favorite article of his is another one: 'Schumpeterian Profits in the American Economy: Theory and Measurement,' from 2004. For every 100 euros of value that an innovator creates, they keep just a little over 2. We get the other 98. … It's worth remembering this whenever someone proposes heavily taxing the fortunes of entrepreneurs, as if they were a burden on society. The innovator already keeps a minimal slice of the value they create. Taxing that slice yields little and puts everything else at risk.” (Pedro Santa Clara) The obvious swindle is to verbally equate innovators and entrepreneurs. They are as different as can be. Innovators and creative geniuses are the most exploited group in the free-market system. Business has captured the real wealth creators. As a rule of thumb, not those who create and ultimately enhance the productivity of the economic system get eventually wealthy, but those who employ or sponsor them — or simply steal their ideas. The real creative genius Tesla died poor, with a charity from the firm he helped to create and prosper.‡ In the end, the royalties go elsewhere. “Nordhaus wanted to know how much of the value created by innovation stays with the innovator. … The answer: about 2.2%. The rest went to society, especially to consumers, in the form of lower prices and better products.” (Pedro Santa Clara) Innovators and creative geniuses cannot be presented as the heroes of the free-market system. They enhance the productivity of a firm, but the enhanced profits are taken by the firm's owners. That scientists/inventors work for firms is a historical accident and in NO way intrinsic to science. To the contrary. Genuine scientists, for example, are fed up with working under the direction of a management with entirely different incentives or constantly begging for funding from the oligarchy. Seen from the perspectives of merit and the freedom of science, this is as perverse as it gets — in any case for basic research. Time for a new business model ⇒ A rough business plan for science https://t.co/fvOOBCrRgV Toward the New Academy https://t.co/4lOOZdZkox ‡ Sources “In early 1891, George Westinghouse explained his financial difficulties to Tesla in stark terms, saying that, if he did not meet the demands of his lenders, he would no longer be in control of Westinghouse Electric and Tesla would have to 'deal with the bankers' to try to collect future royalties. The advantages of having Westinghouse continue to champion the motor probably seemed obvious to Tesla and he agreed to release the company from the royalty payment clause in the contract. Six years later Westinghouse purchased Tesla's patent for a lump sum payment of $216,000 as part of a patent-sharing agreement signed with General Electric ….” (Wikipedia) “At this time, Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Company began paying him $125 (equivalent to $3,010 in 2025) per month in addition to paying his rent. Accounts of how this came about vary. Several sources claim that Westinghouse was concerned, or possibly warned, about potential bad publicity arising from the impoverished conditions in which their former star inventor was living. The payment has been described as being couched as a 'consulting fee' to get around Tesla's aversion to accepting charity.” (Wikipedia) “J.P. Morgan stopped funding Nikola Tesla … around 1903–1904 because Tesla's project lacked a viable business model for making money.” (Google AI)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 1, 2026
October 31, 2026
Occasional X: The foul spirit of political economics (CDXX)
“Innovators and creative geniuses cannot be reared in schools. They are precisely the men who defy what the school has taught them.” (Ludwig von Mises) Innovators and creative geniuses are the most exploited group in the free-market system. Business has captured the real wealth creators. As a rule of thumb, not those who create and ultimately enhance the productivity of the economic system get eventually wealthy, but those who employ or sponsor them — or simply steal their ideas. The real creative genius Tesla died poor, with a charity from the firm he helped to create and prosper. In the end, the royalties go elsewhere. ‡ Innovators and creative geniuses cannot be presented as the heroes of the free-market system. They enhance the productivity of a firm, but the enhanced profits are taken by the firm's owners. That scientists/inventors work for firms is a historical accident and in NO way intrinsic to science. To the contrary. Genuine scientists, for example, are fed up with working under the direction of a management with entirely different incentives or constantly begging for funding from the oligarchy. Seen from the perspectives of merit and the freedom of science, this is as perverse as it gets — in any case for basic research. Time for a new business model ⇒ A rough business plan for science https://t.co/fvOOBCrRgV Toward the New Academy https://t.co/4lOOZdZkox ‡ Sources “In early 1891, George Westinghouse explained his financial difficulties to Tesla in stark terms, saying that, if he did not meet the demands of his lenders, he would no longer be in control of Westinghouse Electric and Tesla would have to 'deal with the bankers' to try to collect future royalties. The advantages of having Westinghouse continue to champion the motor probably seemed obvious to Tesla and he agreed to release the company from the royalty payment clause in the contract. Six years later Westinghouse purchased Tesla's patent for a lump sum payment of $216,000 as part of a patent-sharing agreement signed with General Electric ….” (Wikipedia) “At this time, Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Company began paying him $125 (equivalent to $3,010 in 2025) per month in addition to paying his rent. Accounts of how this came about vary. Several sources claim that Westinghouse was concerned, or possibly warned, about potential bad publicity arising from the impoverished conditions in which their former star inventor was living. The payment has been described as being couched as a 'consulting fee' to get around Tesla's aversion to accepting charity.” (Wikipedia) “J.P. Morgan stopped funding Nikola Tesla … around 1903–1904 because Tesla's project lacked a viable business model for making money.” (Google AI)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) October 31, 2026
August 17, 2026
Occasional X: How it works (DIII)
“Marx explained the basic contradiction over 150 years ago. Competition compels each capitalist to raise productivity and cheapen commodities because doing so increases relative surplus-value and gives them an advantage over competitors.” (Dohaciel Ygzgzot)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) August 17, 2026
This is the problem… pic.twitter.com/pRePIrVMRd
June 30, 2026
Occasional X: Clueless economists / Entrepreneur (III)
“Six thousand years ago, someone invented the plow, and we all got wealthier. A gentle reminder that all civilizational wealth is driven by invention.” (Jeff Bezos)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) June 30, 2026
Jeff Bezos does not understand the difference between productivity and financial wealth. Productivity comes from…
April 22, 2026
Occasional X: Clueless economists / Profit (CXLII)
“… competition is a process of discovering opportunities for profit, and then adjusting market conditions so that these opportunities tend to be exploited.” (Dominick Armentano)
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) April 22, 2026
It is called competition when the so-called entrepreneur discovers an opportunity to reduce wage…
July 1, 2025
Occasional X: How it works (CCCLXXI)
#Economics#AllYouNeedToKnow
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) July 1, 2025
“Billionaires are not bad if they become rich by innovating and creating. Rent-seeking billionaires are, on the other hand, bad. ” (Vincent Geloso)
What exactly is it that helps to create billionaires? Econ profs still have not figured that out.…