“Dude, that’s just an accounting identity rearranged into a 'law.' It always adds up by math after the fact—it doesn’t cause profits or prove capitalism needs deficits to survive. Profits come from producing stuff people pay more for than it costs to make. Deficits just move money around.” (HRsteel) This is one of the popular errors: to believe that profit comes from increasing productivity. This holds only for partial productivity increases. The generalization to the economy as a whole is the Fallacy of Composition. This is beyond the micro-horizon of behavioral microeconomists. The proof is given in table AXEC235c ⇓. Microfoundations are known to be methodologically false; therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1-3. Under the initial analytical causality of line 4, and the conditions of market-clearing and budget-balancing, this yields the price P in line 5. The price is the dependent variable here. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R. The workers get the whole product O. Here, consumption good output O is the real GDP. The profit Qm for the business sector as a whole is zero in line 11. In the elementary production-consumption economy, i.e., in the evenly rotating elementary economy, the market-clearing and budget-balancing price P moves with unit wage costs W/R. The workers' real wage is equal to the productivity, i.e., W/P=R. Their living standard depends solely on the productivity R. General wage increases are pointless. Partial wage increases are not. They change the distribution among workers. Price increases can come only from wage rate increases or from productivity decreases. The quantity of money is not a price determinant. If the condition of budget balancing is lifted, the market clearing price is given by P=:ρEC*W/R in line 9. This formula replaces the silly Supply-Demand-Equilibrium cross. It is generalized in lines 15-21. In the most elementary case, the following relationships hold. If the productivity R increases, consumption good output O (undifferentiated real GDP) increases in line 2. Under the condition of market clearing, the price P falls in line 5. The nominal GDP, here Ec, stays the same under the condition of budget balancing, i.e., Ec=Yw. Profit is still zero in line 11. The price mechanism makes it so that there is NO relationship between a productivity increase and a profit increase. However, if there are two otherwise identical firms, and firm 1 increases productivity, then the common market price falls in line 18. As a result, firm 1's profit increases in line 19, and firm 2 makes a loss in line 20. Micro-brains see solely the effect in line 19 and generalize it. That's their methodological fault. From the partial effect stems the false shortcut: 'productivity increases boost profit'. Macroeconomic profit does not come from productivity increases but from deficit spending, i.e., ρE>1, in line 21. In sum, in the elementary case, a productivity increase does not show up in an increase in nominal GDP and not in an increase in macroeconomic profit Qm. Macroeconomic profit is not caused by productivity increases. The causation is expressed by the generalized Profit Law Qm≔(I−Sm)+(G−T)+(X−M)+Yd. One of the dumbest statements in economics has always been: This is just an accounting identity. For an economist, it is self-defeating proto-scientific garbage. HRsteel is just a throwaway economist.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 22, 2026
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.