July 29, 2020

Economics is a disgrace

Comment on Claudia Sahm on ‘Economics is a disgrace’*


Economics is an institution and a science. Claudia Sahm gives a personal summary of the toxic institutional culture: “We hurt economists from undergraduate classrooms to offices at the White House. We drive away talent; we mistreat those who stay; and we tolerate bad behavior.” So, economics is a failed institution, “Burn it down”.

Not being a part of this institution, I am not entitled to comment on it.

The all-decisive point about economics is not human failure but scientific failure. Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT, and Pluralism are materially/ formally inconsistent and therefore scientifically worthless. #1

The blunder is, with regard to the subject matter, at the axiomatic level, and concerning formal consistency at the level of elementary algebra.

Microfoundations are false since 150+ years. Macrofoundations are false since Keynes. Economists have not spotted Keynes's foundational blunder to this day.

THIS is the indelible disgrace of economics. #2 The mistreatment of students/colleagues is bad, the mistreatment of science is worse. Institutional failure is bad, scientific failure is worse.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Section Exemplary proof of the inconsistency of economics in Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
#2 See Ch. 13, The indelible scientific disgrace of economics, in Sovereign Economics, BoD

***
AXEC106k

July 27, 2020

That’s wrong with a fiscal deficit

Comment on Prabhat Patnaik on ‘What could be wrong with a fiscal deficit? ’

Blog-Reference

Prabhat Patnaik resumes, “And here, the real point to note is the following. The claims that capitalists hold against the government because of the fiscal deficit have been put into their hands by the fiscal deficit itself.”

Yes, that’s exactly what the macroeconomic Profit Law implies, i.e., Public Deficit = Private Profit.#1-#3 Consequently, the Financial Wealth of the Oligarchy ≈ Public Debt of WeThePeople. The sign ≈ indicates that some other factors play a role that can be left out of the picture here.

This, however, is only the first move in the distribution game. The Oligarchy gets interests on the public debt, which is taxed from WeThePeople as long as the debt is rolled over. The taxman has made sure, since time immemorial, that interests are paid on time.

The policy of deficit-spending/money-creation is the mechanism for the perpetual and progressive self-alimentation of the Oligarchy. Financial wealth grows in lockstep with public debt. Mr. Trump’s current policy will blow up macroeconomic profit to hitherto unimaginable proportions, no matter whether unemployment falls or rises. This, after all, is why the Oligarchy put him into office in the first place.

MMTers sell the biggest Ponzi scheme of all time as a good deed for the benefit of WeThePeople. Academic economists are already for a long time part of the scam.#4

That’s wrong with a fiscal deficit: it is a political and scientific fraud. Economists will go to the scientific equivalent of hell for this. Except for Prabhat Patnaik, of course.#5

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Profit
#2 Cross-references Profit
#3 The Profit Law, Graphic AXEC143d
#4 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump, Biden, and exploding profit
#5 Your economics is refuted on all counts: here is the real thing

Related 'Why MMTers permanently explode 'myths of public deficits'' and 'Q: How are you going to pay for it? MMT: By stealth taxation!' and 'Criminals and the monetary order' and 'The decisive reason to worry about government debt' and 'No MMT illusions! YOU are going to pay for it' and 'How to pay for the war and to be bamboozled by economists'.

The U.S. economy hangs on the State ventilator for its survival

Comment on Nathan Tankus on ‘Where do profits come from?’* and Barkley Rosser on ‘Donald Trump's Only Chance’

Blog-Reference

Macroeconomic profit is not made from a longer labor time, not from higher productivity, not from innovation/creative destruction, not from a lower wage rate, not from more greed, not from exploitation, not from monopoly power, not from risk-taking, not from rent-seeking, not from profit maximization or any other subjective factor, but in the most elementary case of the production-consumption economy from the dissaving/deficit spending of the household sector, i.e. Qm≡−Sm. Starting with a balanced-budget economy, macroeconomic profit presupposes credit/money creation by the banking sector (central bank and commercial banks). Macroeconomic profit has nothing to do with property rights. The Profit Law holds for capitalism and communism.

Accordingly, microeconomic profit is the result of the continuous redistribution of macroeconomic profit between the firms that constitute the business sector. If macroeconomic profit is zero, i.e., if the household sector's budget is balanced, then the sum of microeconomic profits is equal to the sum of microeconomic losses.

In the elementary production-consumption economy with a state sector, macroeconomic profit comes ultimately from the household and state sector’s deficit spending/money creation, i.e., Qm≡(G−T)−Sm.#1-#6

This means that the greater part of the profit in the United States is actually produced by the state. The U.S. economy has been hanging on the state ventilator for survival for a long time already. The outstanding amount of public debt is a rough metric for the dysfunctionality of the system.

The policy of deficit-spending/money-creation is ultimately a means of postponing the breakdown of the U.S. economy. Deficit-spending/money-creation is a free lunch for the Oligarchy. Financial wealth grows in lockstep with public debt. Mr. Trump’s current policy will blow up macroeconomic profit to hitherto unimaginable proportions. This, after all, is why the Oligarchy put him into office in the first place.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


* Notes on the Crises
#1 Profit
#2 The Levy/Kalecki Profit Equation is false
#3 Truth by definition? The Profit Theory has been axiomatically false for 200+ years
#4 The profit theory is false since Adam Smith
#5 Cross-references Profit
#6 Graphic AXEC143d The Profit Law with growing complexity

July 26, 2020

The question economists could not answer for 200+ years

Comment on Tom Hickey on “Where do profits come from? — Nathan Tankus”

Blog-Reference

Where do profits ultimately come from? Macroeconomic profit is not made from a longer labor time, not from higher productivity, not from innovation/creative destruction, not from a lower wage rate, not from more greed, not from exploitation, not from monopoly power, not from risk-taking, not from rent-seeking, not from wishful thinking or any other subjective factor, but in the most elementary case of the production-consumption economy from the dissaving/deficit spending of the household sector, i.e., Qm≡−Sm. Starting with a balanced-budget economy, macroeconomic profit presupposes credit/money creation by the banking sector (central bank and commercial banks). Macroeconomic profit has nothing to do with property rights. The Profit Law holds for capitalism and communism.

Accordingly, microeconomic profit is the result of the continuous redistribution of macroeconomic profit between the firms that constitute the business sector. If macroeconomic profit is zero, i.e., if the household sector's budget is balanced, then the sum of microeconomic profits is equal to the sum of microeconomic losses.

Macroeconomic profit comes ultimately from the household and state sector’s deficit spending/money creation. #1-#6

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Profit
#2 The Levy/Kalecki Profit Equation is false
#3 Truth by definition? The Profit Theory has been axiomatically false for 200+ years
#4 The profit theory is false since Adam Smith
#5 Cross-references Profit
#6 The Profit Law, Graphic AXEC143d


***
REPLY to NeilW on Jul 27

You ask: “Anybody spotted where Apple's cash pile sits in all this? There's a section for household saving, but none for dead net saving by corporations.”

It's there for all who can read and think.

The distributed profit of the business sector is given by Yd. #1 The difference between profit Qm and distributed profit Yd is retained profit Qre, and this is the cash pile the corporations sit on if they don't buy government bonds or other financial assets or reinvest.

Learn economics. I recommend the textbook Sovereign Economics. #2


#1 The Profit Law, Grafik AXEC143d
#2 Amazon or BoD


***
Graphic AXEC109i

July 24, 2020

MMT ― now official doctrine

Comment on Tom Hickey on ‘A Job Guarantee Costs Far Less Than Unemployment, Pavlina Tcherneva’

Blog-Reference

It has always been clear that MMT is NOT a scientifically valid economic theory but political propaganda for the benefit of the one-percenters.#1 However, MMTers always claimed that their heroic fight was for the benefit of WeThePeople. Tom Hickey, the MMT philosopher, made it quite clear that his mental grandfather was Karl Marx. Same for Bill Mitchell, the MMT chief ideologist.

MMTers placed themselves firmly in the Progressive camp and demonstratively gathered behind the signboard of the Job Guarantee. That’s pro-labor and anti-capitalist, right? Yes, but only for people who have been trained since childhood to believe any crap.

Tom Hickey is very happy to announce that MMT colleague Pavlina Tcherneva is now on Foreign Affairs: “MMT is making it to the top of the list after having been marginalized for decades. Is the elite getting concerned? This is a superb article, and it is addressed to the ruling elite, which is the audience of this venue.”

What is Foreign Affairs? Tom Hickey cites Wikipedia: “Foreign Affairs is an American magazine of international relations and U.S. foreign policy published by the Council on Foreign Relations, a nonprofit, nonpartisan, membership organization and think tank specializing in U.S. foreign policy and international affairs.”

In other words, Foreign Affairs tells the Oligarchy's underlings all over the world what the grand policy outline is. The new strategy in order to save the system is deficit-spending/ money-creation. And this is why MMT and its apostles are currently hyped across all media. Stephanie Kelton is No. 1 on the NYT bestseller list, and Pavlina Tcherneva is in Foreign Affairs. And the Marx pupil Tom Hickey applauds until he runs out of oxygen behind his mask.

Gentle reminder: the MMT policy of deficit-spending/money-creation is NOT and NEVER has been for the benefit of WeThePeople. MMT is the issuance of counterfeit currency in the form of deficit spending/money creation for the benefit of the one-percenters. Because PublicDeficit = PrivateProfit, MMT is the biggest redistribution program ever.#2 MMT is and always has been a political fraud.

That MMT is now promoted by Foreign Affairs is proof of it.


***

REPLY to Matt Franko on Jul 24

Economics is not an ordinary science but sciences: “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel.”

Or, the classical definition: “Economics is the science which studies human behavior as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.” (Robbins)

Because the science claim is provably false, #1 economists are, in fact, fraudsters.


#1 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?

***
REPLY to Tom Hickey on Jul 24

When the folks of the social sciences cannot do real science for some spurious methodological reasons #1, that’s no problem. They can do talk shows or polit-marketing or comedy, or social media trolling. What they cannot do is to claim that whatever they do is science and to award themselves Nobel prizes. They can award themselves Oscars for the funniest financial hoax and such things.

There are some minimum requirements for science. One is to realize in seconds, not in years, that 2+2=5 is false. Or, for that matter, that the Keynesian I=S is false. #2 MMTers do not satisfy these requirements. They still don’t get the macroeconomic balances right. #3 That is, they fail at elementary algebra. There is NO methodological excuse for that, ever.

There are also some ethical requirements for science. The first and foremost is not to lie and not to cheat. Another is not to manipulate the communication. MMTers are big-time #EconBlocker, and that is the unassailable proof that they are not scientists but political crooks.

MMT is hyped at the moment because the biggest Ponzi scheme of all time has to be sold as an employment program and academically blessed.

People trust science. What they don’t know is that economics in general and MMT, in particular, is fake science. #4


#1 How incompetent are economic methodologists? Very!
#2 Cross-references Refutation of I=S
#3 Profit
#4 Trust in science? Yes, but economics is NOT a science


***
REPLY to Tom Hickey on Jul 25

You say “Arguing over what "science" is or what counts as "scientific" is philosophy of science and there is no general agreement on criteria for this terms.”

Yes, but there is a general agreement that 2+2=5 is false. And more agreement is not needed.

The foundational MMT sectoral balances equation is algebraically false. #1 And this settles the matter already. Because the foundational economic concept of profit is false, the whole theoretical superstructure is false. Because of this, MMT policy guidance has no sound scientific foundations. The only open question is whether MMTers are too stupid for science or whether they abuse the prestige of science for political agenda pushing.

This question is answered by the appearance of MMT’s Pavlina Tcherneva on Foreign Affairs. Roughly speaking, Foreign Affairs is for the Capitalist Party what Pravda has been for the Communist Party. Foreign Affairs is the mouthpiece of the CFR. And everybody knows since Carroll Quigley’s Tragedy and Hope that the CFR and its forerunners had the interests of the Oligarchy on their mind and not so much the interests of WeThePeople.

The appearance of Pavlina Tcherneva on Foreign Affairs is a message from the Central Committee of Capitalism to economists worldwide to make up their minds and to support the current policy of deficit spending/money creation, which is the last instrument to mitigate the accelerated breakdown of the system.

Of course, MMTers are free to fight for the survival of Capitalism, but it is utter corruption to pretend that this is science.


#1 Profit

***
REPLY to Tom Hickey on Jul 25

You say: “The foundational MMT sectoral balances equation is an accounting identity. Are you disputing that?”

Not at all. The crucial point is that I have given the unassailable proof that MMTers have messed up the foundational macroeconomic accounting identity. See
Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
Section ‘Exemplary proof of the inconsistency of economics’ and Sub-sections ‘Provably false Keynes/MMT’.

Everyone with basic mathematical skills can immediately check the proof.

So, MMT is disproved at the elementary level. Meaning, MMT is scientifically worthless. Meaning, MMT is brain-dead political agenda pushing to the advantage of the Oligarchy and to the disadvantage of WeThePeople.

And this is exactly why MMT is promoted by Foreign Affairs.

Pretty straightforward, indeed.

***

Twitter Jul 25

Source Twitter

***
Twitter Aug 4



Twitter Jan 18, 2021 It is called a relief package, but it is a free lunch for the Oligarchy.




Twitter Jan 19


Twitter Apr 12



Longtermtrends Apr 12



Twitter Apr 13


Twitter Apr 19



Twitter Apr 24


Twitter Apr 24



Bill Mitchell's Blog May 4 The macroeconomic narrative continues to evolve; the game is not yet over.


Bill Mitchell's Blog Mai 25 MMT is the new doctrine, but there are some folks who still maintain that public deficit/debt is bad for WeThePeople

"Don’t say its over until its over ― MMT is not close to dominating the narrative

 
Don’t say its over until its over. There has been progress in the macroeconomics narrative since the GFC, which accelerated during the pandemic. Governments have certainly expanded fiscal deficits and taken on more debt, and the usual hysteria, which many of those same governments helped to ferment in the public debate, has fallen away. Obviously, for political reasons, a government that has previously been terrorising the population about the dangers of deficits and rising debt as a cover for ideologically-driven austerity programs, has no incentive in continuing those narratives while they have been dragged into maintaining capitalism on life support."

Note that the words profit or distribution do NOT appear once in the whole article.

For more about the Profit Law, see AXECquery.
For more about Austerity, see Links.


Twitter 29 May The new doctrine at work




Twitter Jun 18 Senator John Yarmuth declares the policy switch from austerity to deficit overdrive





E-PAMPHLETS,  August 2021, Randall Wray What Is MMT’s State of Play in Washington?

July 19, 2020

#HallOfScientificShame

Reference Twitter Thread

See also the hashtags #Economics #DebunkingEconomics #FailedScience #FakeScience #CargoCultScience #ScientificIncompetence #Economists #StupidOrCorruptOrBoth #EconBlocker #OrthodoxEconomics #HeterodoxEconomics #Pluralism #NoFalseHeroMemorials #AgendaPusher #DrainTheScientificSwamp #DeleteEconomics #DefundEconomics #FireEconomists #ScrapTheLot #ParadigmShift #NewParadigm #Science #MacroFoundations #ProfitTheory #SovereignEconomics


Reference Profit

*** 
***
AXEC109i


For details of the big picture see cross-references Profit

July 15, 2020

The counterfeit currency printers

Comment on The Baffler/Dave Denison on ‘The Money Printers’*

Blog-Reference

Dave Denison has NO idea how the monetary economy works. Because of this, he cannot properly assess MMT.

The underlying problem is that the monetary economy (capitalism or communism does not matter) is NOT a self-optimizing equilibrium system but eventually breaks down.#1

The 2-sector Profit Law#3 Qm≡I−Sm tells one that macroeconomic profit is positive in a growing economy as long as the business sector’s investment is greater than the household sector’s saving. If this fails, macroeconomic profit turns into a loss, and the economy breaks down. This must eventually happen; what is unknown is the exact date.#2

However, there is a way to postpone the breakdown. The Profit Law, including the state sector, reads Qm≡(I−Sm)+(G−T), that is, the second component of macroeconomic profit is the state sector’s deficit. It holds Public Deficit = Private Profit.

This means that the greater part of the profit in the United States is actually produced by the state. The US economy has been hanging for a long time already on the state ventilator for its survival.

The MMT policy of deficit-spending/money-creation is ultimately a means of postponing the breakdown of the US economy. From a political standpoint, the COVID pandemic provides a good rationale to mute the budget balancers and to blow the deficit up to hitherto unknown proportions.

The volume of the deficit and the popularity of MMT#4 is a good metric for the acceleration of the breakdown.#5

If MMTers intend to learn economics, I recommend the new textbook Sovereign Economics.#6

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


* The Baffler
#1 Major Defects of the Market Economy
#2 Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism
#3 AXEC143f
#4 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump, Biden, and exploding profit
#5 Criminals and the Monetary Order
#6 Amazon or BoD

***
REPLY to Peter Pan on Jul 16

Predicting the future is not for scientists but for prophets and other sociopaths.#1 Today it is mainly used by the media for the psychological conditioning of a mass audience.


#1 Scientists do not predict

***
REPLY to Peter Pan on Jul 17

I say “Scientists do not predict the future.”

You ask, “What are climate scientists doing?”

Same thing. Genuine scientists try to figure out how the climate works. Political agenda pushers like Al Gore then grab some preliminary research findings, blow the big political tuba, and buy the stocks of the companies that are the most probable climate change winners.

Future-tellers or warners have been political/psychological frauds since time immemorial. Read the so-called holy books if you want to know how the prophecy business works.

***
REPLY to Tom Hickey on Jul 17

Of course, scientists who have a true theory can make a conditional prediction, i.e., if a, b, and c, the outcome will be y.

Economics is a failed science, and economists do not have the true theory. So, all debates about what the future will bring are vacuous prophecies, i.e., attempts to brainwash the public.

Go to Zerohedge or YouTube, and you can have as many economic prophesies as you like. None of it is a scientifically acceptable prediction because economists have no true theory. Economics has never been anything else than political agenda-pushing, MMT included.

***
REPLY to Tom Hickey on Jul 18‡

You say, “There is not even a framework in terms of which scientific theories could be generated and evaluated in social science, including economics, that provide a general explanation of data in the field in any way comparable to natural science. This owing to the subject matter not being ergodic and also being historically relative and complex, for example.”

Yes, one still hears these silly excuses. I have collected them all.#1 And obviously, you have not realized to this day that they are thoroughly refuted.

You say, “A lot of very smart people have been working on formalizating a general explanation in social science for a long time — economists, mathematicians, biologists and physicists included.” How do you know that these people were very smart? Because you have been told. And you are a herd creature. Being a dumb person yourself, you cannot possibly identify a very smart person. So you have to rely on hearsay and end up believing that Stephanie Kelton is the “Smartest Economist In America”#2, while she is a plain political fraud.

The provable fact is that the representative economist is a methodological swampie#3, #4, and too stupid for the elementary algebra of macroeconomics.#5, #6, and that settles the matter for good. Because the axiomatic foundations of economics are false to this day, the whole analytical superstructure is false. Because of this, economic policy has no sound scientific foundations. Because of this, economics is iatrogenic.#7 Which means that scientifically incompetent economists are the root cause of economic crises and the social devastation they bring with them.

Your methodological argumentation is the usual post-modern blather, which amounts to anything-goes and ensures that all remains in the swamp of inconclusiveness where “nothing is clear and everything is possible”. (Keynes)#8 The swamp is the preferred habitat of fake scientists, i.e., political agenda pushers.

Economists are stupid/corrupt, and a scientific disgrace. This is a proven fact.#9 They even admit that the so-called social sciences are not quite up to scientific standards, but then award themselves the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences …” The insane plural gives the fraud away.

At the Flat-Earth Cemetery, they have already dug the graves for orthodox economists, heterodox economists, MMTers, and you and your troll buddies.#10 About time to shut up and go.


#1 Failed economics: The losers’ long list of lame excuses
#2 Down with idiocy!
#3 Economics, methodology, morals ― a creepy freak-show
#4 How incompetent are economic methodologists? Very!
#5 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
#6 Economists: at the end of the wrong track
#7 Iatrogenic economics
#8 Economic recommendations out of the swamp between true and false
#9 Ch. 13, The indelible scientific disgrace of economics, in Sovereign Economics
#10 They can be found easily by searching for #EconBlocker

***
‡
#PointOfProof
Jul 18
Post 11 missing



AXEC200