July 12, 2020

MMT ― a Wall Street myth

Comment on Chris Dillow on ‘The Deficit Myth: A Review’

Blog-Review and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

Chris Dillow’s main point of critique is “For me, Kelton is ― albeit very lucidly ― reinventing the wheel.”

This is, in fact, a spurious compliment because MMT is proto-scientific garbage and Stephanie Kelton is academic fraud. #1

MMT’s macroeconomics is provably false since Keynes, Kalecki, Lerner, etc. So, MMT policy guidance has no sound scientific foundations.

The macroeconomic Profit Law implies Public Deficit = Private Profit. This means that the greater part of the profit in the United States is actually produced by the state. The US economy has been hanging for a long time already on the state ventilator for its survival.

Among all that academic garbage, MMT has the right message for Wall Street. Who is MMT’s first apostle? Right, Warren Mossler, ex-Wall Street. But Stephanie Kelton is, without doubt, the more attractive salesperson. Economics has become part of the entertainment industry long ago, and the casting is done in Hollywood, where they know best what sells.

The rest is marketing/PR routine. Interviews, book, media hype, No. 1 on the best-seller list, and then, of course, trolling on social media. This is where Chris Dillow comes in: “Dr Kelton explains these ideas wonderfully clearly, so I recommend this book to all non-economists interested in government finances.”

MMT is itself a myth. MMT policy is NOT for the benefit of WeThePeople. MMT is the issuance of counterfeit currency in the form of deficit spending/money creation for the benefit of the one-percenters. Because PublicDeficit = PrivateProfit, MMT is the biggest redistribution program ever. MMT is a political fraud.

“Chris Dillow is a Marxian economist,” says Tom Hickey at Mike Norman Economics. There are historians who claim that Marx was already on the payroll of the financial Oligarchy.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 More details

Related 'Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?' and 'Your economics is refuted on all counts: here is the real thing' and 'Dear idiots, MMTers are Wall Street’s agenda pushers' and 'How MMT enlightens Washington' and 'Very busy these days: Wall Street’s agents' and 'Hype does not help: MMT is toast' and 'Mr. Wray goes to Washington' and '#PublicDeficitIsPrivateProfit #MMT #JustAnotherFraud' and 'Links on Liza N. Burby‘s ‘Cutting-Edge Economist Stephanie Kelton Delivers Presidential Lecture’' and 'MMT, Warren Mosler, and the little helpers from Wall Street and Academia' and 'Stephanie Kelton: MMT’s public farce' and 'Occasional Tweets No 201215: The mental collapse of MMT'.

***
COMMENT on aragon on Jul 14

You say, “Every unit of currency gets a vote in economics, resulting in efficiency of the transfer of wealth to the top 0.01%.”

And how does this happen practically? This is due to the macroeconomic Profit Law, which implies Public Deficit = Private Profit.#1 As a logical consequence, the public debt of WeThePeople is roughly equal to the financial assets of the one-percenters.

You are an economist, and this happens right before your eyes! And you don't see that the MMT policy of deficit spending/money creation is the biggest financial hoax of all time ($3.7 trillion)? And you do not wonder that the “Marxian economist” Chris Dillow applauds the Wall Street agenda pusher Stephanie Kelton? And all you can think of is this Anatole France kitsch?


#1 Profit

***
REPLY to aragon on Jul 15

You quote approvingly, “It will be a very long time before the process of creative destruction unleashes fresh growth.”

It is pretty obvious that you have NO idea of how the monetary economy works.

The underlying problem is that the monetary economy (capitalism or communism does not matter) is NOT a self-optimizing equilibrium system but will eventually break down. #1

The Profit Law#3 Qm≡I−Sm tells one that macroeconomic profit is positive in a growing economy as long as the business sector’s investment is greater than the household sector’s saving. If this fails, macroeconomic profit turns into a loss, and the economy breaks down. This must eventually happen; what is unknown is the exact date. #2

However, there is a way to postpone the breakdown. The Profit Law #3, including the state sector, reads Qm≡(I−Sm)+(G−T), that is, the second component of macroeconomic profit is the state sector’s deficit.  It holds Public Deficit = Private Profit.

This tells one that the greater part of profit in the United States is actually produced by the state. The US economy has been hanging for a long time already on the state ventilator for its survival.

The MMT policy of deficit spending/money creation is ultimately a means of postponing the breakdown of the US economy. From a political standpoint, the COVID pandemic provides a good rationale to mute the budget-balancers (Kelton ukase on Twitter: Learn MMT ― shout down the critics) and to blow the deficit up to hitherto unknown proportions.

The volume of the deficit and the popularity of MMT #4 are good metrics for the acceleration of the breakdown. #5 This breakdown has nothing at all to do with creative destruction; it is destructive destruction. And it is very improbable that it “unleashes fresh growth” somewhere in the future.

If you intend to learn economics, I recommend the new textbook Sovereign Economics.#6


#1 Major Defects of the Market Economy
#2 Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism
#3 AXEC143f
#4 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump, etc. and exploding profit
#5 Criminals and the monetary order
#6 Amazon.de or BoD

July 10, 2020

What Is MMT? (II) ― Short Version

Comment on Brian Romanchuk on ‘What Is MMT? (Short Version)’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Sep 23 and Blog-Reference Sep 24

  • MMT is the issuance of counterfeit currency in the form of deficit spending/ money creation for the benefit of the one-percenters.
  • Genuine currency and counterfeit currency are indistinguishable because they originate from the same source: the Fed. It all depends on whether additional fiat money is injected on the supply or the demand side.
  • MMTers are not scientists but political agenda pushers. MMT policy is to the disadvantage of the ninety-nine-percenters. The counterfeiter steals from the rest of society via the anonymous price mechanism.
  • It is the ninety-nine-percenters who owes the public debt. And it is the one-percenters who own the corresponding financial assets. Interest on public debt works like a regressive tax as long as the debt is rolled over.
  • Because #PublicDeficitIsPrivateProfit, MMT is the biggest redistribution program ever.
  • MMT is a political fraud.#1

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 More details

Related 'What is MMT?' and 'Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump, etc. and exploding profit' and 'MMT Basics' and 'Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?' and 'From the debt economy to the gift economy: how America is brainwashed to love budget deficits'. For the full-spectrum refutation, see cross-references MMT.

***
AXEC165b


***

REPLY to Asad Zaman

You say: “One of the key insights of MMT is that NOBODY ‘owes’ the public debt.”

This is not a key insight but a key deception of MMTers in order to sell the deficit-spending/money-creation program to a naive public.

Note that

• The macroeconomic Profit Law implies Public Deficit = Private Profit.#1 MMT policy is a free lunch for the Oligarchy.

• Public debt grows in lockstep with deficit-spending/money-creation. It holds that WeThePeople owe the debt, and the Oligarchy owns the corresponding financial assets. The state manages the public debt on behalf of WeThePeople.

• The Oligarchy appreciates this very much because the taxman collects interest from WeThePeople in the form of taxes and hands the full amount in time over to the Oligarchy. The state is considered the best debtor because of its unlimited taxing power.

• Taxing power replaces the bone-breaking of private debt collection, which the Oligarchy considers as inefficient/expensive.

• Thus, the debt-slavery of WeThePeople is established by pretending that nobody owes the debt and nobody pays interest. As Lerner's Lie goes: We owe the debt to ourselves and pay interest to ourselves. The lie is the fake collective We.

MMTers are the academic agenda-pushers of Wall Street. They deceive WeThePeople. Asad Zaman and the rest of the self-styled Progressives are complicit in the greatest financial fraud in history.#3



***
REPLY to Yoshinori Shiozawa on Sep 28

The lethal defect of the MMT policy of deficit-spending/money-creation is on distribution, not on inflation. The observable distribution of income and financial wealth between the 1% and the 99% is the outcome of MMT policy.#1

The inflation discussion is a smokescreen.#2

The macroeconomic price formula states for the elementary case P=ρW/R. ρ>1 represents private/public deficit-spending/money-creation, and this implies that a period deficit produces a one-off price hike and NOT inflation.#3


#2 Gosh! The One Percent have gotten $21 trillion richer Links on Distribution

***
REPLY to Asad Zaman on Sep 29

The MMT textbook gets the foundational macroeconomics sectoral balances equation wrong. For details, see Refuting MMT’s Macroeconomics Textbook.

Because of this, the analytical superstructure (inflation, employment, etc.) is provably false.

July 7, 2020

MMT Basics

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘MMT basics’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Jul 8

  • The counterfeiter never runs out of money.
  • The counterfeiter never stops stealing stuff from the rest of society.
  • The counterfeiter increases the profit of the business sector with his additional demand.
  • The counterfeiter says that he is good for the economy and employment.
  • When the economy breaks down, the counterfeiter increases deficit spending/ money creation.
  • The counterfeiter 'solves' any problem from unemployment to pandemics to global warming with deficit spending/money creation.
  • The counterfeiter continuously increases the public debt but says that it does not matter.
  • The counterfeiter is a criminal but never gets caught because he games the fiat money system from within.#1, #2, #3
  • The counterfeiter gets valuable PR support from academia, in particular from the MMT fake science trolls.#4

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Criminals and the monetary order
#2 MMT sucks
#3 Cross-references MMT
#4 The sectoral balances obfuscation: stupidity or corruption?

***
AXEC152

July 4, 2020

Economists: at the end of the wrong track

Comment on Barkley Rosser on ‘July 24 Society For Chaos Theory In Psychology And Life Sciences Conference’

Blog-Reference

As usual, Barkley Rosser promotes cargo cult stuff. Cargo cult was the name that Feynman gave the ‘social sciences’, in order to clearly distinguish them from genuine science. Here are some programmatic highlights from the ongoing aberration:

• "Applications of prisoner's dilemma modeling in search of a more socially just dominant strategy: Overcoming anxiety associated with group oppression: Lessons from a single case study"
• "Stability swtiching in Cournot duopoly games with three delays"
• "Covid-19 and the nonlinear dynamics of everyday life"

All this fits perfectly with Feynman's definition: “They’re doing everything right. The form is perfect. ... But it doesn’t work. ... So I call these things cargo cult science because they follow all the apparent precepts and forms of scientific investigation, but they’re missing something essential.”

The essential insight that economists are missing is that they are for 200+ years now on the wrong track, i.e., in the wrong Paradigm. Economics is not a 'social science' but a systems science.#1, #2

For Barkley Rosser, it is too late, but for those who are fed up with 200+ years of proto-scientific garbage and want to know what the Paradigm Shift looks like, there is now the first scientifically valid economics textbook available.#3

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
#2 Your economics is refuted on all counts: here is the real thing
#3 Sovereign Economics

Related 'Dilettantes at the end of the coal-pit' and 'Modern macro moronism' and 'Economics: 200+ years of scientific incompetence and fraud'.

***
REPLY to Fred C. Dobbs on Jul 5

You say, “Kanye West tweets he’s running for president this year.”

That’s a nice try to distract from the fact that Barkley Rosser is promoting the agenda of the Society for Chaos Theory in Psychology And Life Sciences. The title reminds one immediately of a $30 bill.

Note that economists do not know to this very day what profit is. They are simply too stupid for the elementary algebra that underlies macroeconomics. Just check the proof. #1 What do you think one can learn from failed economists about psychology or any other topic?

Nothing. Right.

By the way, if Caligula made his horse a Roman consul, Kanye West can be made president. What goes on in contemporary politics is old hat in academia. After all, Barkley Rosser has been made an economics professor. And he is not as smart as a horse.

#1 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
Section Provably false

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 6

Name-dropping again ... the world's leading blablahblah ... cited many tens of thousands of times ... Princeton ... RAND ... John von Neumann ... And almost all are best buddies of the academic busybody Barkley Rosser.

Yes, Barkley Rosser, you know a lot of people from the academic entertainment industry, too bad that you have no idea how the economy works.

You say, “It is true that economists have used game theory a lot, but they did not invent it, and people from many other disciplines have used it.” Did it ever occur to you that game theory is zero-sum and that the market economy is not zero-sum? For 200+ years now, macroeconomic profit is obviously greater than zero. So, to begin with, game theory does NOT apply to economics. Von Neumann’s Theory of Games and Economic Behavior is plain methodological BS because it gets the pivotal economic concept of profit wrong.

And you hang around in academia and all these pointless conferences and have not realized that something is deeply wrong with economics. Guess what, it has nothing to do with animal behavior or the nonlinear dynamics of armed groups in Yemen and Pakistan.

Learn economics, Barkley Rosser. The canonical textbook Sovereign Economics#1 is your last chance.


#1 Amazon or BoD

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 7

You say, “Wow, I have not seen you fall so spectacularly on your face practically ever. I do not know where you went to econ grad school, but apparently they did not teach you even the most elementary game theory.” and “Sorry, Egmont, but no, it is not in general zero sum. Indeed, the classic example of it not being zero sum is that most famous of cases you poked at: the prisoner's dilemma.”

Take notice first, Barkley Rosser, that the term game theory covers TWO different approaches, that of von Neumann and that of Nash. The prisoner's dilemma belongs to Nash. Von Neumann had only utter contempt for the Nash approach (see Mirowski, who has extensively dealt with the issue).

Here is the summary: “Finally, algorithmic rationality infected game theory itself, changing von Neumann’s original project considerably. The Nash Equilibrium, for Mirowski the paradigm case of the ‘rationality of the paranoid’ (p. 343), stands for him in marked contrast to von Neumann and Morgenstern’s earlier work. Mirowski points to various sources that report von Neumann’s rejection of the equilibrium concept; further, he finds in Nash’s work all of the ingredients that had beset the Cowles Commission: ‘hyper-individualism, non-accessible utility functions, constrained maximization, and cognition as a species of statistical inference’ (p. 348). The Nash equilibrium, Mirowski concludes, is to be seen as a ‘logical extension of the Walrasian general equilibrium tradition into the Cold War context’ (p. 339), but not as a continuation of von Neumann’s project.”#1

Obviously, it is you who is not familiar with the most elementary facts about game theory. No surprises here.

The term zero-sum game relates to the von Neumann approach and has nothing to do with the prisoner's dilemma.

Von Neumann was well aware that there are non-zero-sum n-person games, but he transformed them into zero-sum games with the introduction of the n+1th player.

Take notice, second, that von Neumann had no idea of what macroeconomic profit is. There are three references to profit in the index and they tell you that von Neumann did not understand the essence of economics. He simply redefined utility as profit for the entrepreneur, see footnote 2 on p. 33 ToG.

No way leads from game theory in any version to macroeconomic profit.#2 Game theory is essentially a new version of the old angels-on-a-pinpoint blather that is so beloved in scientifically incompetent academic circles, of which you are a card-carrying member.

Economics is a fake science, and you are living proof.


#1 Economica Till Gruene
#2 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 8

The lethal defect of game theory is that neither von Neumann nor Nash got the foundational economic concept of profit right. This defect they share with the representative economist to this very day.

So, this whole set-theoretical fireworks with Brower's and Kakutani's fixpoint theorems is scientifically beside the point and serves only to train mentally retarded economists to dance around false-hero memorials.

Von Neumann got his math from Hilbert in Göttingen. There, he was one of many talented mathematicians. He learned soon that he could sell his talent at a premium in the United States. In an environment that runs on the principles of show business, he hyped himself or was hyped to the status of mathematical demi-good (Mirowski, Machine Dreams).

Von Neumann was on the payroll of the military and he died as an alcoholic in the Institute for Advanced Salaries as he himself called it. In sum, von Neumann was instrumental in weaponizing mathematics and swapping the principles of science for the dictates of show business. In the history of science, von Neumann will feature as one of the corruptors of mathematics.

The sickest joke in the sick story of game theory is that the foundational blunder of economics lies on the level of elementary algebra.#1 So much for the achievements of mathematical economics. It is proto-scientific garbage, just like the rest of economics.

Here is the three-step program for the New Paradigm
1. Defund economics.
2. Fire economists.
3. Scrap the lot and start again. (J. Robinson)


#1 Your economics is refuted on all counts: here is the real thing

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 8

You say: “What? Joan Robinson accepted your wacko profit theory, Egmont? I never knew.”

Of course, you know nothing because you are not only stupid but also lazy. Go to the library and get Robinson, J. (1956). The Accumulation of Capital. London: Macmillan. See pp. 400-402.

“… an excess of investment over saving is an undistributed profit to the firm, …” (p. 402), and this corresponds formally to equation (32) in my 2011 working paper Keynes’s Missing Axioms.

Do you need more proof of your utter scientific incompetence, wacko Barkley?

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 9

You say, “I have never said that your theory is wrong, but rather that it is a vcuous tautology. Everybody knows about retained earnings, and it is a matter of no importance except slightly in determining investment.”

No, you did not say that my profit theory is wrong, you said that it is wacko.

You try to suggest that for me “… thinking about retained earnings is the most important thing in economics, …”.

No, the most important thing in economics is to get the foundational concept of profit right. And the fact of the matter is that economics is provably false on this all-decisive score for 200+ years.#1

Economics is NOT a science, economists are NOT scientists but clowns and useful idiots in the political Circus Maximus. The representative economist is stupid or corrupt or both. The economics Nobel is a fraud.


#1 Your economics is refuted on all counts: here is the real thing

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 10

You say, “The wacko part is that you think it is important. It is utterly trivial. It is rather like somebody deciding that the fundamental key to understanding all of mathematics is to realize that 7 + 2 = 9. This is certainly true, and it is also something that anybody who knows even basic arithmetic knows.”

By trying to trivialize the absolutely devastating proof that economists got profit wrong for 200+ years, you shoot yourself in the head.

Ultimately, the Profit Law for the investment economy, i.e., Qm≡I−Sm, is indeed trivial. It is elementary algebra. The point is that economists are too stupid for elementary algebra.#1 And because of this, they get profit for the elementary production-consumption economy, i.e. Qm≡−Sm, wrong, and then the more complex investment economy with profit distribution, i.e. Qm≡Yd+I−Sm, and so on. By consequence: because economists are too stupid for the elementary algebra of macroeconomic profit determination, the whole analytical superstructure of economics is provably false. As a consequence, economic policy guidance has never had sound scientific foundations.

This proven scientific incompetence does not only apply to Barkley Rosser, it applies also to his faculty. More, it applies to ALL economics faculties in the United States, and it applies to the American Economic Association and the peer-reviewers of its journals. ALL these folks get the trivial algebra of profit wrong.


#1 See section ‘Provably false’ in Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Jul 11

You say “Weil, Egmont, my evolutionary game theorist friend, Bill Sandhlm may have just blown his brains out, at least he did himself in somehow or other. Perhaps he read your recent writings and took them too cloaely to heart. Heck, he might even have come to believe that 2=7=10. ”

The University of Wisconsin–Madison says “Colleagues knew Bill as “a genuine scientist; detail-oriented, open-minded, and uncompromising in the pursuit of truth,” “a humble scholar with an enormous love for research,” “an exceptional human being, generous with his time,” “kind and supportive to all, and a cherished mentor.” and “After years of struggling with depression, Bill ended his life earlier this week.”

July 2, 2020

The value of money and the worthlessness of economics

Comment on David Glasner on ‘What’s Right and not so Right with Modern Monetary Theory’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

David Glasner sets the frame: “In writing the paper, it occurred to me that it might be worthwhile to include a comment on Modern Monetary Theory inasmuch as the proposition that the value of fiat money is derived from the acceptability of fiat money for discharging the tax liabilities imposed by the governments issuing those fiat moneys, which is a proposition that Modern Monetary Theorists have adopted from the chartalist school of thought associated with the work of G. F. Knapp.”

Of course, other economists have said other things, and in the end, nobody has any idea what the value of money is. Economic reality is complex, you know, and economics ends always in the swamp where “nothing is clear and everything is possible.” (Keynes)

Walrasian microfoundations and Keynesian macrofoundations are provably false. Because economics is a failed science, it has to be reconstructed from scratch. This has already been done elsewhere #1, #2, #3, so here is the bare-bones version.

The elementary production-consumption economy is defined with this set of macroeconomic axioms: (A0) The objectively given and most elementary configuration of the economy consists of the household sector and the business sector, which in turn consists initially of one giant fully integrated firm. (A1) Yw=WL wage income Yw is equal to wage rate W times working hours. L, (A2) O=RL output O is equal to productivity R times working hours L, (A3) C=PX consumption expenditure C is equal to price P times quantity bought/sold X.

Under the conditions of market-clearing X=O and budget-balancing C=Yw in each period, the price is given by P=W/R (1), i.e., the market-clearing price is equal to unit wage costs. This is the most elementary form of the macroeconomic Law of Supply and Demand. For the graphical representation, see AXEC31a. #4

The price is determined by the wage rate, which takes the role of the nominal numéraire, and productivity. The quantity of money is NOT among the price determinants. This puts the commonplace quantity theory to rest.

The real value of money is ultimately given by productivity. From (1) follows W/P=R, i.e., real wage = productivity. The value of money has nothing at all to do with the taxing power of the state.

Transaction money is zero at the beginning and the end of the period under consideration, see Graphic AXEC98. #5 All transactions are handled by the central bank, which continuously creates and destroys fiat money (= deposits and overdrafts) on its balance sheet. There is NO such thing as a fixed quantity of money. The central bank plays an ACCOMMODATIVE role and simply supports the AUTONOMOUS market transactions between the household and the business sector. The economy never runs out of money. Money comes into the economy on the supply side.

Monetary profit for the economy as a whole is defined as Qm≡C−Yw, and monetary saving as Sm≡Yw−C. It always holds Qm≡−Sm, in other words, the business sector’s surplus = profit (deficit = loss) equals the household sector’s deficit = dissaving (surplus = saving). This is the most elementary form of the macroeconomic Profit Law.

The problem with MMT is that it is bad theory #6 and bad policy #7, more specifically: MMT is a plain political fraud. #8

The Profit Law for the 3-sector case (household, business, state sector) reads Qm≡(G−T)−Sm, which says that the business sector's profit/loss is given by the state sector's budget deficit/surplus and the household sector's dissaving/saving. For Sm=0, this boils down to (G−T)=Qm, i.e., public deficit equals private profit. The profit of the monetary economy is, in this analytical limiting case, produced entirely by the state sector. In other words, deficit-spending/money-creation is a free lunch for the Oligarchy. Financial wealth grows in lockstep with public debt.

MMT is not a scientifically valid monetary theory but brain-dead propaganda for the benefit of Wall Street. The question is whether David Glasner does not understand how the monetary economy works or whether he is complicit in the fraud.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 The creation and value of money and near-monies
#2 The objective value of money
#3 Sovereign Economics, Sec. 1.3, 4.6
#4 Graphic AXEC31a  Elementary production-consumption economy
#5 Graphic AXEC98 Idealized transaction pattern, household sector, balanced budget
#6 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
#7 MMT, money printing, stealth taxation, and redistribution
#8 Deficit-spending/money-creation is ALWAYS a bad deal for WeThePeople

Related 'MMT, money, value, and transcendental Capitalism' and 'The value of money and the worthlessness of economics' and 'The Dark-Matter Theory of Fiat Money {78a}'.

***
REPLY to Matt Franko on Jul 3

I said, “The quantity of money is NOT among the price determinants. This puts the commonplace quantity theory to rest.”

You say “LOL! not for the Monetarists it’s not... Just had Bill Dudley in Bloomberg op-ed saying “banks will lend out the Reserves!” last week... QT is certainly not put to rest... it’s being used right now by policy people.”

Right, but this proves only what everybody knows by now, i.e., that policy people are IQ-wise well below room temperature. The fact that there are still flat-earthers around does not prove anything against heliocentrism. Get it, the quantity theory and monetarism are scientifically dead.

What Bill Dudley or Bloomberg or any other clown in the political Circus Maximus says is just irrelevant.

If you still take these folks seriously, better loosen the straps on your facemask. Your last brain cell is dying for lack of oxygen.

***
REPLY to Matt Franko on Jul 5

You say “I submit that there are max 1,000 of us on planet earth that understand this.,. Out of 7.5 billion people.”

You are in the wrong reference frame. In science, the opinions and votes and clicks and likes of 7.5 billion people count exactly for zero.

MMT is provably false; that is what counts in science.

***

REPLY to LAL, Frank Restly, Henry Rech, ralph47 on Jul 5

You constantly argue: MMTers say this and MMTers say that. It is a matter of indifference to what MMTers say because MMT is provably false. MMTers are too stupid for the elementary algebra that underlies macroeconomics. For proof, see the section 'Scientific blunder from Keynes to MMT' in #1

So, there is no need at all to listen to what MMTers say, except for the political fact that MMTers betray the general populace.

Because of the macroeconomic Profit Law, it holds that Public Deficit = Private Profit. Therefore, public deficit spending is a free lunch for the ten percenters and amounts in real terms to stealth taxation of the ninety percenters.

This, though, is only the beginning. The business sector distributes profit to the ten-percenters. The ten percenters, in turn, buy the bonds that are issued in order to consolidate the short-term liabilities of the government sector.

Then, the ninety percenters are taxed in order to pay the interest on government bonds that are in the possession of the ten percenters. This goes as long as the public debt is rolled over. This is fine for the ten-percenters as long as the central bank keeps the interest rate above zero.

All in all, public deficit spending/money creation amounts to a fourfold fraud for the benefit of the ten percenters and the detriment of the ninety percenters.

MMT is the biggest redistribution program in the history of humankind. Private financial wealth is roughly equal to public debt. MMTers are currently the worst disgrace of academic economics, which has run for 200+ years now on a very high level of scientific incompetence, stupidity, and corruption.

Your comments are beside the point and absolutely irrelevant.


#1 Profit
***

REPLY to Frank Restly, Henry Rech on Jul 8

You still do not get the crucial point of monetary policy. Roughly speaking, when fiat money is brought into the economy in order to pay a growing wage bill, it is a good thing; when fiat money is brought into the economy for deficit spending, it is a criminal thing because it amounts to counterfeiting. This puts the MMT talking points into a new perspective.
  • The counterfeiter never runs out of money.
  • The counterfeiter never stops stealing stuff from the rest of society.
  • The counterfeiter increases the profit of the business sector with his additional demand.
  • The counterfeiter says that he is good for the economy and employment.
  • When the economy breaks down, the counterfeiter increases deficit spending/ money creation.
  • The counterfeiter 'solves' any problem from unemployment to pandemics to global warming with deficit spending/money creation.
  • The counterfeiter continuously increases the public debt but says that it does not matter.
  • The counterfeiter is a criminal, but never gets caught because he games the fiat money system from within.
  • The counterfeiter gets valuable PR support from academia, in particular from the MMT fake science trolls.
With your ignorance and scientific incompetence, you are practically — intentionally or unintentionally does not matter — part of a gigantic political fraud.

***
REPLY to Frank Restly on Jul 9

You are in the wrong reference frame. Economics is about how the monetary economy works and NOT what the Constitution says. Economics is, according to its explicit self-definition #1, a science, and the Constitution is politics. It is the foundational principle of science that both spheres must be kept apart. It is a well-known fact that politics corrupts everything it touches. It is the story of Midas, but instead of turning everything into gold, politics turns everything into shit. So, the principle of the strict separation of science and politics is constitutional for science.

The macroeconomic profit law implies Public Deficit = Private Profit. So, the MMT policy of deficit spending/money creation is clearly a free lunch for the one-percenters. #2 MMT claims that MMT policy benefits the ninety-nine percenters, while the exact opposite is true. So MMT is a political fraud. It is academics like Stephanie Kelton who promote the greatest redistribution of income and financial wealth in history. #3 The current distribution is, in the main, the result of the growth of public debt over the last 200+ years. Make no mistake, it is WeThePeople who owes the debt. And it is the one-percenters who own the financial assets.

By blowing smoke about the Constitution, you are covering the political fraud of MMT. This may be okay according to the Constitution, but it is not okay according to the principles of science.

The scientific fact of the matter is that MMT goes down the scientific toilet and you with it.


#1 “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”.
#2 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump, etc. and exploding profit
#3 MMT: For the record

***
REPLY on Jul 10

What Is MMT? (Short Version)

MMT is the issuance of counterfeit currency in the form of deficit spending/money creation for the benefit of the one-percenters.

Genuine currency and counterfeit currency are indistinguishable because they originate from the same source: the FED. It all depends on whether additional fiat money is injected on the supply or the demand side.

MMTers are not scientists but political agenda pushers. MMT policy is to the disadvantage of the ninety-nine percenters. The counterfeiter steals from the rest of society via the anonymous price mechanism.

It is the ninety-nine percenters who owe the public debt. And it is the one-percenters who own the corresponding financial assets. Interest on public debt works like a regressive tax as long as the debt is rolled over.

Because #PublicDeficitIsPrivateProfit, MMT is the biggest redistribution program ever.

MMT is a political fraud.

***
CROSS-POSTING on Jul 12

MMT – a Wall Street myth
Comment on Chris Dillow on ‘The Deficit Myth: A Review’

Chris Dillow’s main point of critique is “For me, Kelton is – albeit very lucidly – reinventing the wheel.”

This is, in fact, a compliment because MMT is proto-scientific garbage and Kelton is academic fraud. #1

MMT’s macroeconomics is provably false since Keynes, Kalecki, Lerner, etc. So, MMT policy guidance has no sound scientific foundations.

The macroeconomic Profit Law implies Public Deficit = Private Profit. This means that the greater part of the profit in the United States is actually produced by the state. The US economy has been hanging for a long time already on the state ventilator for its survival.

Among all that academic crap, MMT has the right message for Wall Street. Who is MMT’s first apostle? Right, Warren Mossler, ex-Wall Street. But Stephanie Kelton is, without a doubt, the more attractive salesperson. Economics has become part of the entertainment industry long ago, and the casting is done in Hollywood, where they know best what sells.

The rest is marketing/PR routine. Interviews, book, media hype, No. 1 on the best-seller list, and then, of course, trolling on social media. This is where Chris Dillow comes in: “Dr Kelton explain these ideas wonderfully clearly, so I recommend this book to all non-economists interested in government finances.”

MMT is itself a myth. MMT policy is NOT for the benefit of WeThePeople. MMT is the issuance of counterfeit currency in the form of deficit spending/money creation for the benefit of the one-percenters. Because PublicDeficit = PrivateProfit, MMT is the biggest redistribution program ever. MMT is a political fraud.

“Chris Dillow is a Marxian economist,” says Tom Hickey at Mike Norman Economics. There are historians who claim that Marx was already on the payroll of the financial Oligarchy.


#1 More details

***

REPLY to David Glasner, Frank Restly, Henry Rech on Jul 15

It is pretty obvious that you have NO idea of how the monetary economy works. Because of this, you cannot properly assess MMT.

The underlying problem is that the monetary economy (capitalism or communism does not matter) is NOT a self-optimizing equilibrium system but eventually breaks down. #1

The Profit Law No 3 Qm≡I−Sm tells one that macroeconomic profit is positive in a growing economy as long as the business sector’s investment is greater than the household sector’s saving. If this fails, macroeconomic profit turns into a loss, and the economy breaks down. This must eventually happen; what is unknown is the exact date. #2

However, there is a way to postpone the breakdown. The Profit Law, including the state sector, reads Qm≡(I−Sm)+(G−T), that is, the second component of macroeconomic profit is the state sector’s deficit. It holds Public Deficit = Private Profit. #3

The MMT policy of deficit spending/money creation is ultimately a means of postponing the breakdown of the US economy. From a political standpoint, the COVID pandemic provides a good rationale to mute the budget balancers and to blow the deficit up to hitherto unknown proportions.

The volume of the deficit and the popularity of MMT #4 are good metrics for the acceleration of the breakdown.

If you intend to learn economics, I recommend the new textbook Sovereign Economics. #5


#1 Major Defects of the Market Economy
#2 Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism
#3 Graphic AXEC143d
#4 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump and exploding profit
#5 Amazon or BoD

***
#PointOfProof
before Jul 16
after Jul 16

***


Failed economics and the losers’ closed circle of mutual promotion

Comment on Barkley Rosser on ‘Econospeak And Angry Bear Still On List Of Top Economics Blogs, Now For 2020’

Blog-Reference

“Intelligent Economist has again put out its annual list of the top 100 economics blogs, with some new ones and some gone, although two of those were due to retirements, especially the much-missed Economists View of Mark Thoma.”

A few points to note
  • ‘Intelligent Economist’ is an oxymoron, there is no such thing as an intelligent economist. The proof is in the so-called history of economic thought.#1
  • Economics is a failed science due to the utter incompetence of economists. For details see Chapter 13 ‘The indelible scientific disgrace of economics’ in the canonical textbook Sovereign Economics.#2
  • All Top Ten/Hundred lists are worn-out marketing/PR gimmicks since Hollywood invented the Oscar for self-promotion and political agenda-pushing.
  • Economics is not a science but has always been a part of Circus Maximus.

EconoSpeak has been shown to suppress comments, to be scientifically worthless, to push a political agenda, to erect false-hero memorials, and to look the other way when academic colleagues like MMTers deceive the general public.#3

What economics needs is a list of the most corrupt economics blogs.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?
#2 Sovereign Economics
#3 Cross-references MMT

Related 'Needed: The Worst of the Worst of economics blogs' and 'Needed: the Top 10 of substandard economics blogs' and What the Top 20 heterodox economists say and 'Econblogosphere: The flawed Top 101'

July 1, 2020

That’s econ2020

Comment on Tom Hickey on ‘An economist explains the biggest myths about the national deficit — and how we can save the economy — Cody Fenwick’.

Blog-Reference

Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, MMT, and Pluralism are materially/ formally inconsistent and therefore scientifically worthless.

Stephanie Kelton, MMT’s emotional anchorwomen, tells the ninety-percenters that public deficit spending is good for them, while the opposite is the case.#1, #2

MMT is provably false because MMTers are too stupid for elementary algebra.#3, #4, #5

And the philosopher Tom Hickey has not realized anything but happily promotes proto-scientific garbage.

These scientifically incompetent deranged folks claim to save the economy. As the saying goes, You cannot make this stuff up.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Stephanie Kelton’s legendary Plain-Sight-Ink-Trick
#2 Down with idiocy!
#3 The sectoral balances obfuscation: stupidity or corruption?
#4 MMT sucks
#5 Your economics is refuted on all counts: here is the real thing