August 13, 2016

A heap of proto-scientific garbage

Comment on J. W. Mason on ‘There Isn’t Really a ‘Mainstream’ at All’

Blog-Reference

Since Smith and Marx, economics claims to be a science. And this claim is officially enshrined in the title: “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”.

In fact, Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are provably false, i.e. materially/formally inconsistent. When this is pointed out economics simply turns into an optical illusion: “Economics is not the study of the economy. Economics is just what economists do.” (See intro)

Economists know that what they do is NOT science: “Economics is a strange sort of discipline. The booby traps I mentioned often make it sound as it is all just a matter of opinion. That is not so. Economics is not a Science with a capital S. It lacks the experimental method as a way of testing hypotheses. . . . There are always differences of opinion at the cutting edge of a science, . . . . But they last longer in economics . . . and there are reasons for that. As already mentioned, rival theories cannot be put to an experimental test. All there is to observe is history, and history does not conduct experiments: too many things are always happening at once. . . . Excuses, excuses. But the point is not to provide excuses.” (Solow, 1998, pp. x-xi)

Note well, that none of these arguments holds water, except for “Economics is not a Science with a capital S” which translates into the correct short variant “Economics is not a science” which in turn contradicts all claims from Adam Smith onward.

More than 2300 years ago science had been defined as episteme = knowledge in contradistinction to doxa = opinion and it was well-understood that opinion is worthless: “In order to tell the politicians and practitioners something about causes and best means, the economist needs the true theory or else he has not much more to offer than educated common sense or his personal opinion. (Stigum, 1991, p. 30)

Economists do not have the true theory. Their economic policy advice never has had sound scientific foundations. Worse, economists feel quite comfortable behind their heap of scientific rubbish: “I think there is a mix of common-sense opinions, political prejudices, conventional business practice, and pragmatic rules of thumb, supported in an ad hoc, opportunistic way by bits and pieces of economic theory. It’s not possible to knock over the whole tottering pile by pulling out a few foundational texts.”

This, though, is a gross error. All variants of Orthodoxy are built upon this set of hardcore propositions, a.k.a. axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub, 1985, p. 147)

Methodologically, this axiom set is false, and therefore the whole analytical superstructure is false, yet the representative economist has always swallowed this garbage with a straight face. It should be obvious that economics cannot be built upon green cheese behavioral assumptions and NONENTITIES like constrained optimization and equilibrium. All models that contain these concepts are a priori false.

The failure of the microfoundations approach is indisputable. Keynes’ macrofoundations approach suffers from other inconsistencies. The same holds for Marxianism and Austrianism.

After more than 200 years there is proof enough that economists are incompetent scientists. From Smith, Ricardo, Marx, Keynes, Hayek, Samuelson to the present economists have not figured out how the monetary economy works. We know this for sure because the profit theory is provably false until this day, and without the correct profit theory, the economist has no clue of how the market economy works (2014).

Economics is a failed science or, in Mason’s words: there isn’t really a ‘mainstream’. What we have instead is a heap of proto-scientific garbage and a bunch of scientifically retarded blatherers.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). The Profit Theory is False Since Adam Smith. What About the True Distribution Theory? SSRN Working Paper Series, 2511741: 1–23. URL
Solow, R. M. (1998). Foreword, volume William Breit and Roger L. Ranson: The Academic Scribblers. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 3rd edition.
Stigum, B. P. (1991). Toward a Formal Science of Economics: The Axiomatic Method in Economics and Econometrics. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Weintraub, E. R. (1985). Joan Robinson’s Critique of Equilibrium: An Appraisal. American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 75(2): 146–149. URL

Related 'Failed economics: The losers’ long list of lame excuses' and 'Economics and Project Augean Stable' and 'Economists’ full-scale retreat' and  'Economics: The chief demerit is inconsistency' and 'Feeble minds, shaky assumptions, and the inevitable failure of economics' and 'Enough! Economists, retire now!' and 'New Economic Thinking: the 10 crucial points'. For details of the big picture see cross-references Failed/Fake Scientists and cross-references The Representative Economist.

August 12, 2016

Eclecticism, anything goes, and the pluralism of false theories

Comment on Simon Wren-Lewis on ‘Blanchard on DSGE’

Blog-Reference

After more than 200 years it is now obvious that economics is a failed science. Orthodox economics in general and DSGE, in particular, is directly comparable to Geo-centrism in physics. The only difference is that Geo-centrism is dead AND buried for about 500 years while orthodox economics is dead but the majority of economists have not realized it. Those who are vaguely aware that economics is scientifically indefensible, though, do not abandon it but switch into damage control mode. Blanchard is a case in point.

Wren-Lewis, too, is a case in point. His fallback position is this: “What is at issue is not the existence of DSGE models, but their hegemony.” (See intro)

False! DSGE always has been indefensible scientific garbage. Wren-Lewis’s damage control consists of shifting the blame on the journals: “Top journal editors’ preference for the latter [general equilibrium models] means that the former [partial equilibrium] is less highly valued.”

This is ridiculous because the hegemony of Orthodoxy is not an editorial accident but the inevitable result of every half-witted economist doing exactly what he is supposed to do: “It is a touchstone of accepted economics that all explanations must run in terms of the actions and reactions of individuals. Our behavior in judging economic research, in peer review of papers and research, and in promotions, includes the criterion that in principle the behavior we explain and the policies we propose are explicable in terms of individuals, not of other social categories.” (Arrow, 1994)

Since Adam Smith economics claims to be a science but has never risen above the level of what Feynman called cargo cult science. Science is about formal and material consistency (Klant, 1994). The outstanding characteristic of economists is that they never got this pivotal point of methodology. And these are the results.

(i) There is Orthodoxy with microfoundations and it has been nicely defined by Krugman: “... most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.”#1

(ii) Methodologically, these premises never have been and never will be acceptable.#2

(iii) When the premises/axioms/foundational propositions are false or contain nonentities the WHOLE theory/model/superstructure is false.

(iv) Because of this, orthodox policy proposals never had sound theoretical foundations.

(v) Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism is materially/formally inconsistent.

(vi) Keynes started the macrofoundations research program in the General Theory formally as follows: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income - consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” These formal foundations are conceptually and logically defective because Keynes never came to grips with profit.#2

(vii) Because of this, the macrofoundations approach (including After-Keynesianism, Post Keynesianism, New Keynesianism, and all I=S/IS-LM models) has already been dead in the cradle 80 years ago.

Review of the Troops. Provably false
• profit theory, for 200+ years,
• microfoundations, for 150+ years,
• macrofoundations, for 80+ years.

ALL models that contain maximization-and-equilibrium or I=S/IS-LM are a priori false and this is more than 90 percent of the content of peer-reviewed economic quality journals and 100 percent of textbooks of renowned authors since 1948.

No more proof of scientific incompetence is needed. Remains only one question for the scientific community: how to get rid of the ‘throng of superfluous economists’ (J. Robinson)? Or, as Wren-Lewis put it: ... there is no way that all these academics are going to suddenly decide this research programme is a waste of time.” Of course, they cannot decide it for themselves, somebody has to expel them ― including Blanchard and Wren-Lewis ― from the scientific community. Eclecticism, anything goes, and the pluralism of false theories is NOT an option.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 More detailed, the starting point is given with these axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to  equilibrium states.” (Weintraub, 1985). Accepting these microfoundations is a reliable indicator of utter scientific incompetence.
#2 For details and proofs see blog and working papers.

***

Twitter Feb 13, 2023 All you need to know about peer review

August 6, 2016

Economics is NOT a social science

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘On the persistence of science-fiction economics’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Aug 9

To explain social behavior is the task of psychology, sociology, political science, and other so-called social sciences.

Explaining how the actual economy works is the task of economics. Economists have failed at this task. To be more specific, orthodox AND heterodox economists have failed. After more than 200 years, economists have not even figured out what profit is; that is, they do not understand the foundational phenomenon of their subject matter. As a consequence, economic policy guidance has NEVER had sound scientific foundations.

The scientific incompetence of economists consists in the fact that it is beyond their means to realize that NO way leads from the understanding of Human Nature/motives/behavior/ action to the understanding of how the economic system works. What makes things worse is that there is NO scientifically valid knowledge of Human Nature/motives/behavior/ action, to begin with.

The failure of economics had been programmed by the founding fathers with the definition of the subject matter as a social science: “The fundamental problem, therefore, of the social science, is to find the laws according to which any state of society produces the state which succeeds it and takes its place.” (Mill, 2006, p. 912)

• “What is now commonly understood by the term ‘Political Economy’ is not the science of speculative politics, but a branch of that science. It does not treat of the whole of man’s nature as modified by the social state, nor of the whole conduct of man in society. It is concerned with him solely as a being who desires to possess wealth, and who is capable of judging the comparative efficacy of means for obtaining that end. It predicts only such of the phenomena of the social state as take place in consequence of the pursuit of wealth.” (Mill, 1874, V.38)

• “The laws of economics are to be compared with the laws of the tides, rather than with the simple and exact law of gravitation. For the actions of men are so various and uncertain, that the best statement of tendencies, which we can make in a science of human conduct, must needs be inexact and faulty. This might be urged as a reason against making any statements at all on the subject; ...” (Marshall, 1920, I.III.10)

• “The foundation of political economy and, in general, of every social science, is evidently psychology. A day will come when we shall be able to deduce the laws of social science from the principles of psychology ...” (Pareto, 2014, p. 20)

• “Economics is the science which studies human behavior as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.” (Robbins, 1935, p. 16)

What economists do not realize is that to study human behavior ― which is essentially the second-guessing/interpretation of motives/actions of individuals/groups one knows in most cases only from hearsay ― may be interesting and revealing and satisfying but is ultimately pointless, more precisely, scientifically pointless: “Alexander Rosenberg lays great emphasis on the role of intentionality in the social sciences, for in his view this role explains the nomological failures of the social sciences and supports the view that the social sciences (in anything like their current form) can never succeed in formulating real laws of human behavior.” (Hausman, 1992, p. 326)

The social sciences cannot, for deeper methodological reasons, rise above the level of storytelling. And this is exactly what Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are. Neither approach satisfies the non-negotiable criteria of science, i.e., material and formal consistency.

Economists face this option: either to be expelled from the sciences or to restart economics as a systems science. This means, in concrete terms, to move from unacceptable behavioral microfoundations and dilettantish Keynesian macrofoundations to objective/ structural/behavior-free macrofoundations.

Economists have, to this day, not understood how science works: “When the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.” (Aristotle). This means that science cannot be built upon behavioral assumptions because there is no such thing as a ‘certain, true, and primary’ behavioral assumption. This is the ultimate reason for the failure of both orthodox and heterodox economics and the persistence of science-fiction economics.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Hausman, D. M. (1992). The Inexact and Separate Science of Economics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Marshall, A. (1920). Principles of Economics. Library of Economics and Liberty. URL
Mill, J. S. (1874). Essays on Some Unsettled Questions of Political Economy. On the Definition of Political Economy; and on the Method of Investigation Proper To It. Library of Economics and Liberty. URL
Mill, J. S. (2006). A System of Logic Ratiocinative and Inductive. Being a Connected View of the Principles of Evidence and the Methods of Scientific Investigation, Vol. 8 of Collected Works of John Stuart Mill. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Pareto, V. (2014). Manual of Political Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press. URL
Robbins, L. (1935). An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science. London, Bombay, etc.: Macmillan, 2nd edition.

Related 'Objective Principles' and 'Economics and the social science delusion' and 'The happy end of the social science delusion' and 'The Science-of-Man fallacy' and 'How to get rid of the silly Queen' and 'Economics as fool’s paradise' and 'Disoriented and lost in folk psychology' and 'Economics between cargo cult, farce, and fraud' and 'The stupidity of Heterodoxy is the life insurance of Orthodoxy' and 'Economics is not a science, not a religion, but proto-scientific garbage' and 'A social science is NOT a science but a sitcom' and 'Overreach: Economists have their fingers in every pie except real economics' and 'Did economics fail? No! Yes, and everybody knows it!' and 'Why is economics a total scientific failure?' and 'PsySoc — the scourge of economics' and 'Economics as storytelling and entertainment for the masses' and 'Do first your macroeconomic homework!' and 'What’s the use of economists?' and 'Beware of the moralizing economist' and 'The canonical macroeconomic model'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references Not a Science of Behavior and cross-references Failed/Fake Scientists.

***
Graphic AXEC121g

August 5, 2016

Economists’ full-scale retreat

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘How true is Friedman’s permanent income hypothesis?’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference adapted to context

Economics started as Political Economy. Political Economy is agenda pushing, and economists from Smith, Ricardo, Marx, Keynes, Hayek, Friedman, to the present were agenda pushers first and scientists second. As a matter of fact, they were incompetent scientists because they never figured out how the actual monetary economy works. How do we know this? We know this for sure because the profit theory is provably false (Desai, 2008), and without the correct profit theory, the economist is lost in the woods and only babbles incoherent nonsense. This happened to Friedman. He was a lifetime political economists and ALL political economics from Smith and Marx onward is scientifically worthless.

That the permanent income hypothesis is utter scientific dilettantism ― or what Feynman famously called cargo cult science ― could and should have been obvious from the beginning around 1960. The real question is why it took economists more than 50 years to realize that: “Unfortunately, there’s just one small problem ― it’s almost certainly wrong.”#1 Unfortunately, there is a second small problem: “PIH is so dominant that almost all modern macroeconomic theories are based on it. They enshrine the idea with a formula called a ‘consumption Euler equation,’ which has appeared in the vast majority of academic macro models during the past few decades.” #1 In other words, the economics of the past 50 years have been pure scientific garbage.

The fact that economists are in the process of abandoning one core piece of modern macroeconomic theory after another is a sign of worse things to come. As long as the economy has a reasonably good run, economists are mainly occupied with praising themselves and their relentless championship of markets. Now they distance themselves even from “the great Milton Friedman”#1, renounce mathiness, and readily degrade themselves from upper case Science to lower case science. The greater the economic problems become, the smaller economists make themselves.

But economists have never admitted failure without offering betterment for the future: “Kocherlakota thinks macroeconomists should set aside their big, complex formal models of the economy, since these elaborate constructions are built on a foundation that probably doesn’t describe reality all that well. He recommends that economists go back to the drawing board, and look around for new, more accurate kernels of insight with which to build the theories of tomorrow.”#1

Yes, indeed, Kocherlakota is spot on. The Walrasian microfoundations have been unacceptable for more than 150 years, and the Keynesian macrofoundations have been false for more than 80 years. Kocherlakota should have even gone one step further and explicitly recommend the correct macrofoundations “with which to build the theories of tomorrow”. See for a start:
► Confused Confusers: How to Stop Thinking Like an Economist and Start Thinking Like a Scientist
► Economics for Economists

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Reference
Desai, M. (2008). Profit and Profit Theory. In S. N. Durlauf, and L. E. Blume (Eds.), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics Online, 1–11. Palgrave Macmillan, 2nd edition. URL

#1 See ‘Economists Give Up on Milton Friedman’s Biggest Idea’ on BloombergView

August 4, 2016

Heterodoxy’s scientific self-burial

Comment on Paul Spicker on ‘On economics as a science’

Blog-Reference

Since Adam Smith and Karl Marx, economics claims to be a science. And this claim is officially enshrined in the title: “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”.

Now Paul Spicker tells us that economics is not a science as everybody thought until now but practical wisdom, an exercise in what Aristotle called phronesis: “It is all about judgment ― reading the situation, identifying patterns, applying conflicting principles, anticipating problems, spying opportunities. There are no certainties; there are tendencies, warnings, prescriptions and the recognition of trends or patterns, all subject to many reservations.”#1 This sounds sensible but, obviously, phronesis is very different from what Aristotle called episteme=knowledge=science.

The fact of the matter is that economics is a failed science and after more than 200 years there is proof enough that both orthodox AND heterodox economists are incompetent scientists (2013). Science is well-defined by formal and material consistency: “Research is, in fact, a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant, 1994, p. 31). Clearly, economics does NOT satisfy the criteria of formal and material consistency. Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism are mutually contradictory and each one is provably false. Strictly speaking, there is no economics only a heap of scientific garbage. The question is how to proceed from this incontrovertible fact? Phronesis has always been an attractive option and an easy way out of the calamity for the representative economist, but let us look at the bigger picture.

(i) First of all, the word sciences has to be eliminated from the title “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”. The general public has to be promptly informed of the actual state of economics. Actually, economics is a failed science.

(ii) All attempts to redefine science and to soften the criteria so that a proto-science like economics fits in have to stop immediately. Science is well-defined and one is either in or out. There is nothing to negotiate, neither for economics in particular nor for the so-called social sciences in general.

(iii) There is no point in explaining again and again why economics is not and cannot be a science. Here is, once and for all, the exhaustive tick-box list of excuses: “Economics is a strange sort of discipline. The booby traps I mentioned often make it sound as it is all just a matter of opinion. That is not so. Economics is not a Science with a capital S. It lacks the experimental method as a way of testing hypotheses. . . . There are always differences of opinion at the cutting edge of a science, . . . . But they last longer in economics . . . and there are reasons for that. As already mentioned, rival theories cannot be put to an experimental test. All there is to observe is history, and history does not conduct experiments: too many things are always happening at once. The inferences that can be made from history are always uncertain, always disputable, . . . You can’t even count on a long and undisturbed run of history, because the ‘laws’ of behavior change and evolve. Excuses, excuses. But the point is not to provide excuses.” (Solow, 1998, pp. x-xi). Note well, that NONE of these arguments holds water, except for “Economics is not a Science with a capital S” which translates into the correct short variant “Economics is not a Science” which in turn contradicts all claims from Adam Smith onward.

(iv) With regard to the future, economists have to make up their minds whether they intend to comply with the immutable standards of science. If so they have to put forward an idea of how to perform the necessary Paradigm Shift. Otherwise, voluntary/involuntary retirement from academia/science is inevitable. What has been produced so far is scientifically forever unacceptable.

(v) All those who know at their hearts that they will never rise above the level of agenda-pushing and storytelling have only the option to follow the lead of Paul Spicker and to busy themselves with space/time specific practical problems without any understanding of the big picture. Their proper business is phronesis or what nowadays is called consultancy. Peirce nicely defined the difference between the scientist and the consultant: “True science is distinctively the study of useless things. For the useful things will get studied without the aid of scientific men.” (1931, 1.76)

The spirit of science is very different from the utilitarianism of the commonsensical and practical man. In a nutshell, the following anecdote highlights the clash of cultures: “At one point in that 100 years, Lord Ernest Rutherford was visited by a minister of the Queen. He proudly and busily demonstrated what he had learned about radio. The minister said, that’s all very good, but what is it good for. Lord Rutherford replied that he did not know, but he guaranteed that at some point the government would tax it.”#2

Accordingly, the task of the economist as a scientist is to figure out how the monetary economy works. Not more, not less. It is not his task to figure out how people behave (Hudík, 2011). This, indeed, is the subject matter of psychology, sociology, political science, and other so-called social sciences. Economics is NOT a social science but a systems science. A system is subject to objective systemic laws while human nature/behavior/action is contingent. Strictly speaking, for deeper methodological reasons there is no such thing as ― what Hume called ― a Science of Man.

Economics started as Political Economy and what economists never understood is that NO way leads from the understanding of human nature/behavior/action to the understanding of how the economic system works. The feeble thinkers and strong blatherers that call themselves economists have to this day not figured out how the monetary economy works, more specifically, how the price and profit mechanism works. This is not to say, of course, that economists know nothing. In fact, they know some easy to grasp practical, institutional, or historical details. This, though, is phronesis, as Aristotle made clear, but NOT episteme/science.

Political Economy is agenda pushing and economists from Smith, Ricardo, Marx, Keynes, Hayek, Friedman to the present were agenda pushers first and scientists second. As a matter of fact, they were lousy scientists because they never figured out how the monetary economy works. How do we know this? We know this for sure because the Profit Theory is provably false and without the correct profit theory, the economist cannot rise above the level of storytelling.

Economics is a failed science. The very task of Heterodoxy is to make economics a science. To this day, Heterodoxy did not succeed. What is needed is a Paradigm Shift, that is, a full replacement of the ridiculous behavioral axioms of standard economics. Phronesis, as proposed by Paul Spicker, is not a Paradigm Shift but scientific suicide and self-burial.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Hudík, M. (2011). Why Economics is Not a Science of Behaviour. Journal of Economic Methodology, 18(2): 147–162.
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2013). Confused Confusers: How to Stop Thinking Like an Economist and Start Thinking Like a Scientist. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2207598: 1–16. URL
Klant, J. J. (1994). The Nature of Economic Thought. Aldershot, Brookfield: Edward Elgar.
Peirce, C. S. (1931). Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, volume I. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. URL
Solow, R. M. (1998). Foreword, volume William Breit and Roger L. Ranson: The Academic Scribblers. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 3rd edition.

#1 See his RWER paper.
#2 Source PSW.

August 3, 2016

Voluntary full employment and involuntary full stupidity

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘AD/AS models and the ‘disappearance’ of involuntary unemployment’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Aug 7

Walrasian, Keynesian, Marxian, and Austrian economists are groping in the dark with regard to the two most important features of the market economy: the price mechanism and the profit mechanism. The fault lies in the fact that economists argue from false premises, that is, Walrasianism in all shapes and forms (DSGE, RBC, AD/AS, etc.) argues from unacceptable microfoundations, and Keynesianism in all shapes and forms argues from false macrofoundations (2011).

To get out of failed economics requires nothing less than a paradigm shift from the accustomed amateurish nonsense to entirely new axiomatic foundations.

In the following, a sketch* of the formally and empirically correct employment theory is given. A rather elementary version of the objective structural macroeconomic Employment Law (2012) is shown on Graphic AXEC62


From this equation follows:
(i) An increase in the expenditure ratio ρE leads to higher employment (the Greek letter ρ stands for ratio). An expenditure ratio ρE greater than 1 indicates credit expansion, a ratio ρE less than 1 indicates credit contraction. The expenditure ratio fully replaces the concept of a consumption function.
(ii) Increasing investment expenditures I exert a positive influence on employment; a slowdown of growth does the opposite.
(iii) An increase in the factor cost ratio ρF≡W/PR leads to higher employment.

The complete AND testable Employment Law is a bit longer and contains in addition profit distribution, public deficit spending, and import/export. It contains NO behavioral assumptions of any sort.

Items (i) and (ii) cover Keynes’ arguments about aggregate demand, which have been commonsensically right but formally defective. More precisely, Keynes’s multiplier is provably false (see 2012). The factor cost ratio ρF as defined in (iii) embodies the price mechanism which works very differently from what the representative economist falsely assumes. As a matter of fact, overall employment INCREASES if the average wage rate W INCREASES relative to the average price P and productivity R.

For the relationship between real wage, productivity, profit, and real shares, see (2015, Sec. 10).

So, in simple terms, full employment (in any definition) can be achieved by increasing overall demand (expenditure ratio, investment expenditures, etc.) or by INCREASING the average wage rate or by a combination of the two.

Keynes’ approach is macrofounded but incomplete because he had no deeper understanding of the price and profit mechanism. Both the Walrasian and Keynesian approaches have produced misleading policy advice. To propose a reduction of the average wage rate in a recession/depression, as orthodox economists did repeatedly, is a manifestation/proof of utter scientific incompetence. The AD/AS model is one of the most ridiculous attempts to formalize fundamental economic relationships. For the correct approach, see (2015).

The structural Employment Law contains nothing but measurable variables and is therefore readily testable. So, there is NO need for prolonged waffling about Walrasian or Keynesian models or voluntary/involuntary unemployment. As always in science, a test decides the matter. What is beyond any doubt is that both orthodox and heterodox economics have been OUTSIDE of science since its inception.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2012). Keynes’s Employment Function and the Gratuitous Phillips Curve Disaster. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2130421: 1–19. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). Major Defects of the Market Economy. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2624350: 1–40. URL

* Students are referred to the working papers for more details.

August 1, 2016

Post Keynesianism, science, and universal idiocy

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘What is Post Keynesian Economics?’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Nov 10 and Blog-Reference on May 30, 2017

There are science and non-science. The former is the realm where the criterion true/false is applied and nothing else, the latter is the vast realm of what J. S. Mill called universal idiocy (1879, p. 26).

True/false in turn has two inseparable aspects: “Research is in fact a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant, 1994, p. 31)

Logical consistency is methodologically secured by the axiomatic-deductive method. This method presupposes firm ground to start with or, as Aristotle put it: “When the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.” Without a firm ground, logic runs amok and thus contributes to universal idiocy. As Keynes aptly remarked: “... a remorseless logician can end up in Bedlam.” (Moggridge, 1976, p. 36). This, clearly, is NOT an argument against logic but against logic that lacks firm ground. Logical consistency is indispensable.

Refutation of a theory/model consists of proof that it is either logically inconsistent or empirically inconsistent. Theories/models that take nonentities into the premises (angels, unicorns, Santa Claus, utility, equilibrium, etcetera) are a priori OUTSIDE of science. However, sometimes it is not immediately obvious whether a word denotes a nonentity or not, e.g. ether or phlogiston or extraterrestrials. Nonentities are the conversation topic of universal idiocy, entities are the subject matter of science.

Keynes was very clear about the all-decisive importance of sound premises: “For if orthodox economics is at fault, the error is to be found not in the superstructure, which has been erected with great care for logical consistency, but in a lack of clearness and of generality in the premises.” (1973, p. xxi)

Keynes left not the slightest doubt that Orthodoxy’s premises are false. Consequently, he left them behind and formulated the foundational syllogism of the General Theory as follows: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” (1973, p. 63)

This elementary syllogism, though, is conceptually and logically defective because Keynes did not come to grips with profit and therefore “discarded the draft chapter dealing with it.” (Tómasson et al., 2010, p. 12). As a result, the whole Post Keynesian theoretical superstructure is false (2011).

Because Keynes did not get the macrofoundations right the Keynesian Revolution ultimately failed. Just like his predecessors, Keynes had no idea of the fundamental concepts of economics, viz. profit and income. Yet, neither Keynesians nor Post Keynesians nor New Keynesians nor Anti-Keynesians ever spotted the logical inconsistency in Keynes’ macrofoundations. Not very profound thinkers these Walrasian, Keynesian, Marxian, Austrian folks.

As a result, model bricolage, discussion, and debate drifted away into the realm of economic nonentities like general equilibrium, ergodicity, rational expectations, or the vacuous pseudo-realism of uncertainty, animal spirits, or folk psychology/sociology/ politics.

The axiomatic foundations of economics are provably false for more than 150 years in the case of Walrasianism and for more than 80 years in the case of Post Keynesianism. Because of this, the economic policy advice of BOTH Walrasians AND Keynesians has NO sound scientific foundation (2015). Like Walrasianism, Post Keynesianism is NOT an instantiation of science but an instantiation of universal idiocy.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). Major Defects of the Market Economy. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2624350: 1–40. URL
Keynes, J. M. (1973). The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Klant, J. J. (1994). The Nature of Economic Thought. Aldershot, Brookfield: Edward Elgar.
Mill, J. S. (1879). Utilitarianism. URL
Moggridge, D. E. (1976). Keynes. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Tómasson, G., and Bezemer, D. J. (2010). What is the Source of Profit and Interest? A Classical Conundrum Reconsidered. MPRA Paper, 20557: 1–34. URL

Related 'Post Keynesianism, too, is proto-scientific garbage' and 'Keynesianism ― the economists’ senile dementia' and  'Economists: just too stupid for counting' and 'Keynes’ intellectual nonexistence' and Profit. For details of the big picture see cross-references Political Economics/Stupidity/Corruption and cross-references Keynesianism.