October 20, 2017

Economists understand neither Capitalism nor Socialism

Comment on Michael Hudson on ‘Socialism, Land and Banking: 2017 Compared to 1917’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

Michael Hudson tells economic history from early Western Capitalism to Russian Socialism to modern China. This account suffers from the fact that he does not know what profit is. In his ignorance, he is not alone. The profit theory is false since Adam Smith. The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent, and all got the foundational economic concept of profit wrong.

Smith treated profit as the income of the factor capital. This was the original blunder. #1 It was followed by Ricardo’s theory of rent #2, Marx’s theory of profit #3, and Keynes’s messed-up macro. #4 As the Palgrave Dictionary summarizes: “A satisfactory theory of profits is still elusive.” (Desai, 2008)
 
Because Michael Hudson does not understand profit, he does not understand how the monetary economy works. The fact is that profit for the economy as a whole does not at all depend on who owns the means of production. In other words, the Profit Law holds always and everywhere: in capitalist America, in former communist Russia, and in the mixed economy of China. Michael Hudson’s historical account remains on the surface of political economics. Political economics has produced nothing of scientific value in the last 200+ years.

For the proof, macroeconomic profit is here determined for the most elementary case. The pure production-consumption economy is defined with this set of macroeconomic axioms: (A0) The objectively given and most elementary configuration of the economy consists of the household and the business sector, which in turn consists initially of one giant fully integrated firm. (A1) Yw=WL wage income Yw is equal to wage rate W times working hours. L, (A2) O=RL output O is equal to productivity R times working hours L, (A3) C=PX consumption expenditure C is equal to price P times quantity bought/sold X.

Under the conditions of market-clearing X=O and budget-balancing C=Yw the price is given by P=C/X or P=W/R (1), i.e., the market-clearing price is equal to unit wage costs. This is the most elementary form of the macroeconomic Law of Supply and Demand.#5

From (1) follows that the real wage is equal to productivity, i.e., W/P=R (2). The wage income receivers get the whole product.

Monetary profit for the economy as a whole is defined as Qm≡C−Yw, and monetary saving as Sm≡Yw−C. It always holds Qm≡−Sm, in other words, the business sector’s surplus = profit equals the household sector’s deficit = dissaving, and vice versa,  the business sector’s deficit = loss equals the household sector’s surplus = saving. This is the most elementary form of the macroeconomic Profit Law. Under the condition of budget balancing, the total monetary profit is zero. The Profit Law holds for every monetary economy, no matter how it characterizes itself politically.

Overall profit depends solely on deficit spending, that is, the change of private or public debt. It does NOT depend on labor time, or productivity, or monopoly power, or greedy landlords, or rent-seeking bankers. These factors are only relevant to the distribution of overall profit between the firms. Traditional profit theory has been nothing more than a Fallacy of Composition, that is, an illegitimate generalization of what can be observed on the microeconomic level. Economists are failed/fake scientists, and Michael Hudson is no exception.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 The Profit Theory is False Since Adam Smith
#2 When Ricardo Saw Profit, He Called It Rent: On the Vice of Parochial Realism
#3 Profit for Marxists
#4 How Keynes got macro wrong and Allais got it right
#5 For the graphical representation, see Graphic AXEC31

October 19, 2017

This is New Economic Thinking? Give me a break!

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Twenty years ago’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Oct 27

Science is about the true theory. The true theory is the humanly best mental representation of reality. The rest of social communication is storytelling, agenda-pushing, exchange of superficial opinions/beliefs, blather, gossip, unintended comedy, disinformation, and white noise.

The characteristic of science is the insistence on material and formal consistency: “Research is, in fact, a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant)

Economics pretends to be a science but is only what Feynman called a cargo cult science. As everywhere in life, there is a genuine thing and a look-alike. The general public cannot spontaneously tell the difference and this provides a comfortable ecological niche for the look-alikes in all walks of life from the marriage-impostor, to the snake-oil seller, to the Ponzi schemer, to the fake scientist. Unsurprisingly, there are also two economixes: political economics and theoretical economics. The main differences are: (i) The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda, the goal of theoretical economics is to successfully explain how the actual economy works. (ii) In political economics anything goes; in theoretical economics, the scientific standards of material and formal consistency are observed.

What the general public is presented with is political economics. The public has no idea of the underlying theory and cannot assess its scientific worth. Fact is that political economics (= agenda-pushing) has virtually extinguished theoretical economics (= science).#1 The loudspeakers of economics ― right-wing or left-wing does not matter ― are without exception incompetent scientists.#2 Political economics has had no sound scientific foundations for 200+ years. Economic policy discussion has no scientifically valid content, it is just opinion and rhetoric.

“In order to tell the politicians and practitioners something about causes and best means, the economist needs the true theory or else he has not much more to offer than educated common sense or his personal opinion.” (Stigum) Economists do not have the true theory but dwell in the scientific no man's land where, in Keynes’ words, ‘nothing is clear and everything is possible’.

Political economics cannot be improved but only abandoned. What is needed is a Paradigm Shift. The problem with economists is that they have no clue what this is: “There is another alternative: to formulate a completely new research program and conceptual approach. As we have seen, this is often spoken of, but there is still no indication of what it might mean.” (Ingrao et al.)

The goal of science is the true theory. Economics is a failed science. The four main approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent and all got the foundational economic concept of profit wrong.#3

So, genuine New Economic Thinking is about the Paradigm Shift and nothing else. Given the history of economic thought, this is, of course, NOT what happens. Alleged New Thinking is a dilettantish proto-scientific dog and pony show, not much different in substance from what came before. It’s all a bit more user-friendly: no mathiness, no stress with true/false but peaceful coexistence of provably false theories, no offensive neoliberal hardcore ideology but an emotionally satisfying narrative, and a demonstrative commitment to a brighter future for humanity and the planet or at least to one’s own national society. All this is political marketing. Scientifically, it is essentially the old Walrasian/Keynesian/ Marxian/Austrian garbage in a new package. The foundational concept of profit is still not understood and this means that there is no analytical progress whatsoever.

The methodologically correct action to overcome scientific failure is the Paradigm Shift. This requires a redefinition of the whole subject matter. Economics is not about individual or social behavior but about the behavior of the economy. Economics is a systems science and the functioning of the economic system has to be explained without recourse to folk psychology and folk sociology.#4

Economics is a scientific failure and the ultimate cause is the utter incompetence of both orthodox and heterodox economists. The old thinking has been rather insufficient and the new thinking is not any better. These agenda-pushing folks simply cannot rise above the proto-scientific level.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 For details of the big picture see cross-references New Economic Thinking
#2 For details of the big picture see cross-references Failed/Fake Scientists
#3 Why economists don’t know what profit is
#4 First Lecture in New Economic Thinking

Related 'Joan Robinson and the early death of Behavioral Economics' and 'Confused Confusers: How to Stop Thinking Like an Economist and Start Thinking Like a Scientist' and 'The real problem with the economics Nobel' and 'Economists understand neither Capitalism nor Socialism' and 'New Economic Thinking, or, let’s put lipstick on the dead pig' and 'CORE: more lipstick on the dead economics pig' and 'Dilettantes at the end of the coal-pit' and 'Economics between cargo cult, farce, and fraud' and 'What is the fuss with New Economic Thinking all about?' and 'New Economic Thinking: The 10 crucial points'. For details of the big picture see cross-references Not a Science of Behavior and cross-references Scientific Incompetence.

***

NOTE on INET conferencing beyond disappointment on Oct 24

Frances Coppola summarizes: “This is not ‘new thinking’, it is the same old elite economists’ voodoo in different clothes.”

True, orthodox ‘New Economic Thinking’ is bad but heterodox ‘New Economic Thinking’ is even worse. For details see This is New Economic Thinking? Give me a break!.

***

NOTE on INET conferencing beyond disappointment on Oct 25

Frances Coppola summarizes: “This is not ‘new thinking’, it is the same old elite economists’ voodoo in different clothes.”

True, orthodox ‘New Economic Thinking’ is a bad joke but heterodox ‘New Economic Thinking’ is even worse. For details see This is New Economic Thinking? Give me a break! and Everything you know about MMT is wrong.

***

AXEC106i

October 18, 2017

Joan Robinson and the early death of Behavioral Economics

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Joan Robinson and the inadequacies of revealed preference theory’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Oct 22

“In order to tell the politicians and practitioners something about causes and best means, the economist needs the true theory or else he has not much more to offer than educated common sense or his personal opinion.” (Stigum)

How do scientists eventually arrive at the true theory? “Research is, in fact, a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant)

Neither orthodox nor heterodox economists have developed anything that remotely resembles the true (= materially/formally consistent) theory.

Samuelson, to his credit, at least realized that utility is a NONENTITY and that, by consequence, marginalism had no sound scientific foundations: “The very raison d’être for developing revealed preference theory in the 1930s and 1940s was to be able to ascertain people’s preferences by observation of their actual behaviour on markets and not having to make unobservable psychological assumptions or rely on any utility concepts.” (Lars Syll, Intro)

What Samuelson did realize was that economics cannot be based on a behavioral axiom like constrained optimization, but he did not realize that it cannot, as a matter of principle, be based on any other behavioral assumption whatsoever. The economy is a system, and economics must be based on objective-systemic macrofoundations rather than subjective-behavioral microfoundations.

The significance of the failure of revealed preference theory lies in the fact that economics is not a science of behavior and that microfoundations are the methodologically wrong approach. #1

It was Joan Robinson who drew the correct conclusion: “Scrap the lot and start again.”

However, Keynes’s attempt to move from microfoundations to macrofoundations failed. #2 Thus, the propagation of silly orthodox and heterodox economics goes on and on. The scrapping of the false micro-behavioral paradigm did not happen. What indeed happened was the pseudo-progress from the entirely vacuous behavioral assumption of utility maximization to more ‘realistic’ assumptions under the label of Behavioral Economics.

For Behavioral Economics, though, it holds what held already for the microfoundations of Jevons, Walras, and Menger: Scrap the lot and start again. In other words, if it isn’t macroaxiomatized, it isn’t economics.

Awarding the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel” for Behavioral Economics in 2017 is the point at which the abysmal scientific incompetence of orthodox and heterodox economists over 150 years turns into a deception of the general public. Economics is not a science but what Feynman called a cargo cult science.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 A social science is NOT a science but a sitcom
#2 From false micro to true macro: the new economic paradigm

Related 'The father of modern economics and his imbecile kids' and 'What makes economics a failed science?' and 'Hunting down the economics body snatchers' and 'You are fired!' and 'Joan Robinson and the ‘throng of superfluous economists’' and 'Why don’t you do what Joan Robinson told you to do?' and 'Yes, economics is a bogus science' and '10 steps to leave cargo cult economics behind for good'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references Not a science of behavior and cross-references New Economic Thinking

***

Graphic AXEC121i

October 17, 2017

Note on Asad Zaman’s Supply & Demand

Blog-Reference

To criticize silly supply-demand-equilibrium again and again is itself silly. For the FULL REPLACEMENT of the proto-scientific nuisance see:
• Essentials of Constructive Heterodoxy: The Market
• The Law of Supply and Demand: Here It Is Finally
• How to Get Rid of Supply-Demand-Equilibrium

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Related 'Refutation of Asad Zaman’s heterodox methodology: all arguments you ever need' and cross-references Failure of Heterodoxy.

When non-thinkers rethink

Comment on Carola Binder on ‘Rethinking Macroeconomic Policy’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Oct 18

This is the track record of economics: provably false:
• profit theory, for 200+ years,
• Walrasian microfoundations (including equilibrium), for 150+ years,
• Keynesian macrofoundations (including I=S, IS-LM), for 80+ years.
The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent and all got the foundational concept of profit wrong.#1

Economics is a failed science or what Feynman called a cargo cult science: “They’re doing everything right. The form is perfect. ... But it doesn’t work. ... So I call these things cargo cult science because they follow all the apparent precepts and forms of scientific investigation, but they’re missing something essential.”

What is entirely missing among economists is scientific competence. The familiar research programs have produced nothing but proto-scientific garbage but neither orthodox nor heterodox economists have any clue of how to get out of the mess: “There is another alternative: to formulate a completely new research program and conceptual approach. As we have seen, this is often spoken of, but there is still no indication of what it might mean.” (Ingrao et al.)

This is why rethinking-this-and-that-and-everything is all the rage.#2 It cannot produce anything worthwhile for obvious reasons. Those economists who in their Econ101 youth unthinkingly swallowed supply-demand-equilibrium, which is one the worst proto-scientific idiocies of all time, are in NO position to perform the necessary Paradigm Shift: “A new idea is extremely difficult to think of. It takes a fantastic imagination.” (Feynman)#3

Carola Binder maintains: “The fact that the conference speakers are so distinguished is both an upside and a downside. They have the greatest understanding of our current models and policies, and in many cases were central to developing them. They can rethink, because they have already thought, and moreover, they have large influence and loud platforms. But they are also quite invested in the status quo, for all they might criticize it, in a way that may prevent really radical rethinking (if it is really needed, which I’m not yet convinced of).”

Obviously, Carola Binder is still in a hallucinatory state. The only thing the Blanchard’s and Summers’ and Bernanke’s and the rest of the rethinking-macro crowd can do for the advancement of economics is to get out of the way.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Where modern macroeconomics went wrong
#2 New Economic Thinking, or, let’s put lipstick on the dead pig
#3 Fact of life: your econ prof is scientifically incompetent

Related 'This is New Economic Thinking? Give me a break!' and 'New Economic Thinking = old scientific garbage' and 'How to make economics a science'. For details of the big picture see cross-references New Economic Thinking.

October 16, 2017

Proof of the inherent instability of the market economy

Comment on Simon Wren-Lewis on ‘How Neoliberals weaponise the concept of an ideal market’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Oct 17

The foundational tenet of economics is that the interaction of free markets tends, in principle, to produce an inherently stable optimal outcome with all factors fully employed or, with regard to labor, at worst ‘naturally’ unemployed.

This tenet has NEVER been proven. General Equilibrium Theory is known to be a methodological disaster, and economics is known to be in need of a Paradigm Shift: “There is another alternative: to formulate a completely new research program and conceptual approach. As we have seen, this is often spoken of, but there is still no indication of what it might mean.” (Ingrao et al.)

As a result, economic policy guidance in ALL variants between the outer right wing and outer left wing has had no sound scientific foundations for 200+ years. It can be proved that the market economy is inherently unstable.

Economics is a systems science. Accordingly, the correct approach is not microfoundations but macrofoundations.#1 The elementary version of the objective, systemic, behavior-free, macrofounded Employment Law is shown with Graphic AXEC62


From this equation follows
(i) An increase in the expenditure ratio ρE leads to higher employment L (the Greek letter ρ stands for the ratio).
(ii) Increasing investment expenditures I exert a positive influence on employment.
(iii) An increase in the factor cost ratio ρF≡W/PR leads to higher employment.

Items (i) and (ii) cover the familiar arguments about aggregate demand. The factor cost ratio ρF, as defined in (iii), embodies the macroeconomic price mechanism. The fact is that overall employment INCREASES if the AVERAGE wage rate W INCREASES relative to the average price P and productivity R, and vice versa. This is the OPPOSITE of what microfounded economics teaches: “We economists have all learned, and many of us teach, that the remedy for excess supply in any market is a reduction in price. If this is prevented by combinations in restraint of trade or by government regulations, then those impediments to competition should be removed.” (Tobin)*

This is false: a reduction of the average wage rate W in the situation of unemployment INCREASES unemployment. In general terms, at the heart of the market economy is a positive feedback loop, i.e., the very OPPOSITE of what is required for a self-adjusting system.

The lethal methodological blunder of the microfounded market theory consists of the Fallacy of Composition, i.e., the illegitimate generalization of truths that hold for one firm/market for the economy as a whole.

The free market system is neither efficient, self-adjusting, nor stable. Neoliberalism has no sound scientific foundations.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 New Economic Thinking: the 10 crucial points

Related 'How to overcome the manifest silliness of Econ 101 and save the economy'

For more about self-adjusting, see AXECquery.

***

* Lars P. Syll blog, James Buchanan, Wall Street Journal


October 14, 2017

Why does Heterodoxy not abolish the fake Nobel?

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Thaler and behavioural economics — some critical perspectives’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Oct 15

The core message of Heterodoxy is that Orthodoxy has failed on all theoretical and empirical counts and that New Economic Thinking is required. Heterodoxy claims to be the living example of New Thinking which, however, has NOT produced the true economic theory but the pluralism of provably false theories. Worse, Heterodoxy argues that the criteria of science do not literally apply to economics as a social science and that to insist on the well-defined standards of material and formal consistency is merely physics envy.

While it is true that Orthodoxy has abysmally failed, it is important to stress that Heterodoxy, too, has achieved nothing of scientific value.#1 The simple reason is that orthodox and heterodox economists share the same mental handicap: they do not understand what science is all about. What we have underneath the conspicuous hick-hack of the diverse schools is the grand unity and solidarity of the scientifically incompetent.#2 Well knowing that economics is not a science, no economics school puts the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel” in earnest into question.

What the Bank of Sweden does, though, is either (i) a self-delusional overreach, (ii) an arrogation of scientific competence, (iii) an arrogation of legitimacy, or/and (iv), a deception of the general public.

The question is, why have heterodox economists never made a serious attempt to abolish the fake Nobel which makes the ridiculous claim that economics is science[s]. There is a blatant contradiction between reality and what the Bank of Sweden declares.

The Bank of Sweden has no legitimacy whatsoever to elevate a proto-science to the status of a science. The four major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. Economists do not even understand the foundational concept of their subject matter, that is, macroeconomic profit. Economics is not a science, and economists are not scientists.

What neither orthodox nor heterodox economists have realized until this day is that economics is NOT a science of behavior. Behavioral Economics from Adam Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiment to homo oeconomicus to bounded rationality to game theory to Richard Thaler’s nudge is not economics at all but the very subject matter of Sociology, Psychology, Anthropology, Political Science, History, etcetera. The subject matter of economics is the economic system.

Lars Syll entirely misses the point with his patronizing critique: “So — although it is good that people like Kahneman and Thaler are rewarded ‘Nobel prizes’ and that much of their research has vastly undermined the lure of axiomatic-deductive mainstream economics, there is still a long way to go before economics has become a truly empirical science.”

There is no other way to go for failed/fake scientists than to apply for immediate retirement. This, of course, includes the misdirected methodologist, confused blatherer, and clueless heterodox prophet Lars Syll.#3

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Economics: 200+ years of scientific incompetence and fraud
#2 For details of the big picture see cross-references Scientific Incompetence
#3 The stupidity of Heterodoxy is the life insurance of Orthodoxy

Related 'The real problem with the economics Nobel' and 'The economics Cargo Cult Prize' and 'A social science is NOT a science but a sitcom' and 'Schizonomics' and 'There is NO such thing as an economic expert' and 'The economist as stand-up comedian' and 'Is Lars Syll’s stupidity really infinite?' and 'Legitimacy lost'. For details of the big picture see cross-references Not a Science of Behavior and cross-references Heterodoxy and cross-references Political Economics/Stupidity/Corruption.