August 21, 2016

Nothing to choose between Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy

Comment on Noah Smith on ‘Heterodox macro ― a reply to some replies’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Aug 22, adapted to context, and Blog-Reference on Sep 17

All that has to be said about formalization/mathiness has already been said by the great heterodox economist Georgescu-Roegen: “Lest this position is misinterpreted again by some casual reader, let me repeat that my point is not that arithmetization of science is undesirable. Whenever arithmetization can be worked out, its merits are above all words of praise. My point is that wholesale arithmetization is impossible, that there is valid knowledge even without arithmetization, and that mock arithmetization is dangerous if peddled as genuine.” (1971, p. 15)

There are heterodox AND orthodox economists who cannot get their heads around this still-valid summary. These are the retarded folks who do not understand that there is an essential difference between science and non-science. The former is the realm where the criterion true/false applies and NOTHING else (= theoretical economics), and the latter is the vast realm of storytelling where anything goes (= political economics). So there are TWO kinds of Orthodoxy and TWO kinds of Heterodoxy which have to be kept apart. For an overview of current economics, see (2016b) plus description (2016a).

True/false in turn has TWO inseparable aspects: “Research is in fact a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.” (Klant, 1994, p. 31)

Logical consistency is methodologically secured by the axiomatic-deductive method. This method presupposes firm ground to start with or, as Aristotle put it, “When the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.”

The fact of the matter is that BOTH orthodox microfoundations and heterodox macrofoundations are false. Because of this, traditional Heterodoxy is not an acceptable replacement for Orthodoxy. The current state of economics is this: Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are materially/formally inconsistent. Economics is a failed/fake science. This calls for a Paradigm Shift.

Heterodox macro has been formalized. This is praiseworthy. The problem is that there are different versions of heterodox macro, e.g., Keynes, Kalecki, Minsky, and Keen, which are INCONSISTENT. So traditional macrofounded Heterodoxy is formal garbage (2015) (2016c) just as microfounded Orthodoxy. Because there cannot be a pluralism of false theories BOTH approaches have to be replaced with the correct macrofoundations. Nothing less will do. Inconsistency is lethal in science. Game over for Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
E.K-H (2015). Heterodoxy, too, is proto-scientific garbage. Blog post. URL
E.K-H (2016a). From Orthodoxy to Heterodoxy to Metadoxy. Blog post. URL
E.K-H (2016b). From proto-science to science. Graphic AXEC83.
E.K-H (2016c). Where advanced Heterodoxy — represented by Steve Keen — took the wrong turn. Blog post. URL
Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1971). The Entropy Law and the Economic Process. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Klant, J. J. (1994). The Nature of Economic Thought. Aldershot, Brookfield: Edward Elgar.

***

Graphic AXEC83a




***
COMMENT on Barkley Rosser on Aug 22

Georgescu-Roegen said: “What particular reality is described by a given theory can be ascertained only from that theory’s axiomatic foundation.” (1966, p. 361)

And: “In fact, the history of every science, including that of economics, teaches us that the elementary is the hotbed of the errors that count most.” (1970, p. 9)

Georgescu-Roegen was well aware that the axiomatic foundations of economics are defective. Neither Orthodoxy nor Heterodoxy has gotten this pivotal methodological point until this day.

Georgescu-Roegen was also well aware of his fellow economists’ utter scientific incompetence: “Knight lamented that there are many members of the economics profession who are ‘mathematicians first and economists afterwards.’ The situation since Knights' time has become much worse. There are endeavors that now pass for the most desirable kind of economic contributions, although they are just plain mathematical exercises, not only without any economic substance but also without mathematical value. Their authors are not something first and something else afterwards; they are neither mathematicians nor economists.” (1979, p. 317)

This is the very definition of economics as cargo cult science. The situation since Georgescu-Roegen’s time has become even worse.


References
Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1966). Analytical Economics, chapter Economic Theory and Agrarian Economics, 359–397. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1970). The Economics of Production. American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 60(2): 1–9. URL
Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1979). Methods in Economic Science. Journal of Economic Issues, 13(2): 317–328. URL

***
COMMENT on Frances Coppola on Aug 22

Your argument is entirely beside the point because Science does NOT predict the future.

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Aug 23

You write: “First of all, lots of economists, even including some fairly mainstream ones, are aware that a lot of the axioms of economics are flawed.”

Famously, Keynes was very aware of this 80 years ago. “The classical theorists resemble Euclidean geometers in a non-Euclidean world ...” (1973, p. 16). And he knew that the fault was in what today is called microfoundations: “For if orthodox economics is at fault, the error is to be found not in the superstructure, ... but ... in the premises. (1973, p. xxi)

Consequently, Keynes started the macrofoundations research program in the General Theory formally as follows: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” (1973, p. 63)

These formal foundations are conceptually and logically defective because Keynes never came to grips with profit and therefore “discarded the draft chapter dealing with it.” (Tómasson et al., 2010, p. 12).

This was how Heterodoxy started in earnest. The original task of Heterodoxy is NOT to criticize Orthodoxy and to improve it here and there, but to REPLACE indefensible scientific garbage and to become the legitimate Orthodoxy. As we know today, Heterodoxy messed up the necessary Paradigm Shift.

Keynes’ original blunder kicked off a chain reaction of errors/mistakes: (i) all I=S/IS-LM models are false since Keynes and Hicks, (ii) Keynes’ profit conundrum has not been solved by After-Keynesians, (iii) employment and monetary theory is still false.

On the other hand, Orthodoxy went on with its flawed axioms. As Krugman nicely put it, “most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.”

This is the current state of economics: the orthodox microfoundations have been flawed for 150+ years, and the heterodox macrofoundations have been flawed for 80+ years. As a consequence, all models that contain maximization-and-equilibrium or I=S/IS-LM are a priori false, and together this is roughly 90 percent of the content of peer-reviewed economic quality journals and 100 percent of textbooks. Economic policy guidance has NO sound scientific foundations but is plucked from thin air.

From this follows, firstly, that the word ‘sciences’ has to be eliminated from the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”. The general public has to be informed that the 200-year-old claim and the actual state of economics do not match. It follows, secondly, that incompetent scientists have to be expelled from economics regardless of their affiliation to either Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism, or any other failed approach. It follows, thirdly, that the pathetic cargo cult ping-pong between brain-dead Orthodoxy and silly Heterodoxy ends: “So we really ought to look into theories that don’t work, and science that isn’t science.” (Feynman)

And this is what one REALLY sees: The orthodox microfoundations are flawed. The heterodox macrofoundations are flawed. Economics is a failed science. Economists are incompetent scientists.


References
Keynes, J. M. (1973). The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Tómasson, G., and Bezemer, D. J. (2010). What is the Source of Profit and Interest? A Classical Conundrum Reconsidered. MPRA Paper, 20557: 1–34. URL

***
Graphic AXEC106n

Failed institutions

Comment on jlegge and Robert Locke on ‘Trade, Truth and Trump’

Blog-Reference

The monetary order and banking are institutions that evolved historically. Like in biological evolution, the outcome of this messy process is often sub-optimal. Institutions can and must be carefully designed and constructed. The U.S. is particularly bad at institution-building.

Mortgage financing, for example, is a very old and rather simple business. In Germany, it was institutionalized in 1900 with the Mortgage Banking Act. This law was so well-crafted that it worked with minor modifications until 2005, when deregulation became the hype of the day.

The core of the risk-minimizing regulation had been that a mortgage bank can finance at most 60 percent of the carefully assessed long-term value of a house (without imputed speculative gains). As a result, there has never been a real estate boom-bust cycle in Germany since 1900. That is quite remarkable when one considers that Japan, the U.S., the UK, Spain, and many other economies have been badly devastated by real estate busts.

Interim results: (i) financial crises are the result of bad institutional design, (ii) the U.S. is particularly untalented at institution building, (iii) in the international arena, according to a variant of Gresham’s Law, bad institutions crowd good institutions out. This is the most detrimental side effect of globalization.

What holds for banking holds for other institutions. First and foremost, for the relations between business and labor. The legal status of unions has always been precarious in the U.S.

With regard to trade, one has to keep in mind that the beneficial effects have been theoretically derived since Ricardo under the condition of equilibrium. So, the often lamented negative effects for the American workforce do not necessarily come from trade per se, but from the balance of trade deficits of the U.S.

Dean Baker concludes: “Donald Trump is a hateful bigot, but that doesn’t mean that everything he says is wrong. It would be a huge step forward if his critics could acknowledge that the recent pattern of trade has been harmful to large segments of the population.”

On closer examination, the harm to the U.S. population stems ultimately from the rather shaky micro and macro institutional setup. This, though, is alone the POLITICAL business of the American people and their future president. Politics, in turn, is NOT the proper business of economics understood as a science.

What Mr. Trump says about trade or any other economic issue is neither true nor false but simply irrelevant because we can be sure that he does not understand how the economy works. This sad fate he shares with orthodox and heterodox economists.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke

***

COMMENT on Ken Zimmerman, William Neil, Robert Locke on Aug 22

There is politics, and there is economics. If the American people elect a president who is committed to Neoliberalism, then this is their internal affair.

Economics is a science that tries to find out how the market economy works. At present, economics is a failed science. As far as Neoliberalism is based on economic theory, it has NO sound scientific foundation. This holds across the board for Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism, which are all PROVABLY inconsistent.

So the whole discussion about economic policy hangs squarely in midair. Economists simply do not know how the market economy works. #1

The failure of traditional Heterodoxy consists of never rising above the level of baseless and pointless politicizing. The proper task of Heterodoxy is to replace Orthodoxy and to make economics a science. It is NOT the task of Heterodoxy to comment on Mr. Trump’s or Mrs. Clinton’s utterances about the economy. This has been done much better by comedians.

#1 For details, see here and here.

***
REPLY to Robert Locke on Aug 23

There is politics, and there is economics. If the American people elect a president who is committed to Neoliberalism, then this is their internal affair. If the German people elect politicians who implement co-determination, then this is their internal affair. If the UK people vote for Brexit, then this is their internal affair. NO economist has to comment on this. In the political sphere, the economist can participate just like every other citizen, but NOT as an economist. Comment on Mr. Trump’s or Mrs. Clinton's policy is a political statement, but not economics.

An economist is committed to scientific standards alone, and his subject matter is the economy and nothing else. From history, we know that science and politics do NOT mix. Science has never bettered politics, but politics has always corrupted science. So both spheres have to be kept strictly apart.

All this is clear since J. S. Mill: “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.”

Political economics has not produced anything of scientific value in the last 200 years. Science has nothing to do with opinion but solely with knowledge. Scientific knowledge takes the form of a consistent theory. At the moment, neither Orthodoxy nor Heterodoxy has to offer anything in the way of a consistent theory ― only storytelling and agenda-pushing.

***
REPLY to William Neil on Aug 23

You ask: “Are you familiar with L. Randall Wray’s book, ‘Modern Monetary Theory,’ which is, in my view, an attempt to do what you say has not been done: advance a heterodox theory, internally consistent.”

Yes. I commented on Wray’s approach on several occasions. #1

You say: “... if Neoliberalism is right, then both Great Britain, at the end of the Napoleonic wars in 1815-1830, and the U.S. at the end of WWII should have been in deep economic trouble based on the size of their national debts in relation to GDP.”

These concerns are as old as economics: “Adam Smith, when he wrote his Wealth of Nations, and Burke, when he produced his famous speech on economic reform, understood by ‘political economy’ a ‘branch of the science of the statesman or legislator’, a theory of practice, the science of the prudent management of the public finances. The growth of the huge debts which weighed on the great military nations would end in proving their ruin. This was especially true of England, which had become immensely in debt through the conquest of her colonial Empire.” (Halévy, 1960, pp. 104-105)

What is not well understood since Adam Smith is the relationship between growing private/public debt and monetary profit for the economy as a whole (2014). The axiomatically correct Profit Law reads Qm≡Yd+I−Sm. Legend: Qm monetary profit, Yd distributed profit, Sm monetary saving, I investment expenditure. The profit equation gets a bit more complex when foreign trade and government are included.

Roughly speaking, what happens in the monetary economy is this: the profit of the business sector as a WHOLE does NOT depend on productivity or low wages or the greed of capitalists or the smartness of managers or the degree of monopoly but on the growth of the household sector’s (public sector’s) debt. Therefore, as long as this private (public) debt grows, employment and profit are fine. Needless to add, this implies the existence of a banking sector with the capacity of credit/money creation. Things become worrisome, though, as soon as the credit expansion stops, and nastier as soon as the household sector (public sector) as a whole pays the debt back. In this case, profit turns into loss, and the business sector breaks down (2014). Note well, this happens without any debt crisis or market failure, or wrongdoing of the banking sector. It SUFFICES that the private (public) households eventually pay back their debt as they are supposed to do. This is because a growing/shrinking household sector (public sector) debt immediately translates into profit/loss of the business sector. Economists cannot see this because the standard price and profit theory has been false since Adam Smith.

The size of the debt is of secondary importance. Of primary importance is whether (the sum of private and public sector) debt grows or shrinks ― the first derivative of debt, so to speak. The debt/GDP ratio is a misleading indicator.


References
Halévy, E. (1960). The Growth of Philosophic Radicalism. Boston: Beacon Press.
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014a). Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2375578: 1–21. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014b). The Profit Theory is False Since Adam Smith. What About the True Distribution Theory? SSRN Working Paper Series, 2511741: 1–23. URL

#1 Please go to the AXEC blogspot and enter Wray in the search field. See also the references to working papers

***
REPLY to William Neil

You say: “It was pre-credit card, although there was a growing segment of long-time purchases of consumer capital goods…but I never see that debt cited as a major contributing factor…more the speculative frenzy on stocks as the chief form of ‘indebtedness’, ...”

The outer form of debt is secondary. If the household sector as a WHOLE gets 100 monetary units per period as wage income and spends 110 units, this is dissaving -S and increases the household sector’s debt. This involves creating money out of nothing. However, whether the increase of debt takes the form of overdrafts or credit card debt, or whatever concrete historical form, is secondary. It is (-S) where the positive effect on employment comes from.

When speculators buy stocks on credit, this is an entirely DIFFERENT matter which has NO immediate effect on employment (2011).

In very rough terms, the Great Depression had three interlocking and self-reinforcing causes: (0) Trigger: stock market crash, which weakened the banking sector, (i) debt deflation as described by Koo (2016d; 2016c), (ii) shortfall of aggregate demand as described by Keynes, (iii) falling profits, FALLING wages (2016b).

The Great Depression is the empirical proof that the market economy is NOT self-adjusting (2016a). In other words, it is a REFUTATION of equilibrium theory or Orthodoxy as a WHOLE.

In a nutshell, this is what formally/materially consistent economics (= theoretical economics = science) tells you. Political economics in the incarnation of Friedman tells you that it was all the fault of the FED, and Bernanke gladly repeats it (2000).

As for every economist, your first decision is to do (a) theoretical economics (= science), or (b), political economics (= agenda-pushing). In case (b), you will forever burn in scientific hell. It is as simple as that.


References
Bernanke, B. S. (2000). Essays on the Great Depression. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
E.K-H (2016a). Could we, please, all focus on the key question of economics? Blog post. URL
E.K-H (2016b). Demystifying employment theory and policy. Blog post. URL
E.K-H (2016c). The other half plus the hitherto missing true foundations of macroeconomics. Blog post. URL
E.K-H (2016d). There is no thrift paradox, or, How economists fell over their own feet. Blog post. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Primary and Secondary Markets. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1917012: 1–26. URL

***
REPLY to Robert Locke on Aug 25

You say: “Keynes gave ONE explanation for it; others long before him gave explanations. Marx. for example, List, for another, Hobson, Lenin for two more, etc.”

In economics, almost everything and the exact opposite have already been said sometime, somewhere, by somebody.

The problem is more than 2700 years old, and Parmenides solved it: “There are always many different opinions and conventions concerning any one problem or subject-matter (such as the gods). This shows that they are not all true. For if they conflict, then at best only one of them can be true. Thus it appears that Parmenides ... was the first to distinguish clearly between truth or reality on the one hand, and convention or conventional opinion (hearsay, plausible myth) on the other ... “ (Popper, 1994)

Science is the way to figure out what is mere opinion = doxa and what is genuine knowledge = episteme. Knowledge is what is materially/formally consistent, and this has to be established by PROOF. Blah-blah and opinion count for nothing.

Keynes understood this. In the 1934 BBC radio address, he tried to answer the central question of economics: “Is the Economic System Self-Adjusting?” Obviously, this is the fundamental question for economic policy because it defines the roles of business/state.

Now, this is the situation. General equilibrium theory delivered the formal proof that an equilibrium exists. This proof is, for several reason,s not acceptable as we know by now.

What is still lacking since Keynes is the PROOF that the monetary economy is NOT self-adjusting. #1 All else is opinion, and of opinion, we have more than enough.

Heterodoxy has to become serious and move from political economics (= blah-blah, plausible myth, agenda-pushing) to theoretical economics (= science).


#1 What Keynes really meant but could not really prove

***

REPLY to Robert Locke, Ken Zimmerman, Dave Taylor, etc. on Aug 26

Cheap talk is the core problem of economics since Adam Smith: “But he had no such ambitions; in fact, he disliked whatever went beyond plain common sense. He never moved above the heads of even the dullest readers. He led them on gently, encouraging them by trivialities and homely observations, making them feel comfortable all along.” (Schumpeter, 1994)

This is how economics became the honeypot for morons, populists, incompetent scientists, and agenda pushers. In principle, there is nothing wrong with this, of course ― these folks, too, need a forum for the exchange of their ideas and an opportunity to politicize and to gossip and to hype their friends and mob their foes.

The problem arises with the claim that economics is a science that is as old as Adam Smith/Karl Marx. Because Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are PROVABLY false, this claim is either self-delusion or fraud.

For every intelligent person, it is crystal clear that economics is a failed science. The two main tasks at this critical juncture are (i) positive, i.e., to promote the necessary Paradigm Shift, and (ii) negative, i.e., to get rid of the proto-scientific garbage of the past 200 years. The latter task compares to the Fifth Labor of Heracles and is therefore called Project Augean Stable: “[Augeas] is best known for his stables, which housed the single greatest number of cattle in the country and had never been cleaned, until the time of the great hero Heracles.” #1 This is a fitting metaphor for current economics.

Project Augean Stable starts with a clear separation of political economics (= storytelling, agenda-pushing) and theoretical economics (= science). The mission of Heterodoxy is to flush the heap of proto-scientific dung out and to make economics a science. Clearly, this cannot be done by gossiping about Mr. Trump or any other freak phenomenon of Circus Maximus.

Politics is currently trumped to absolute zero. Economics is a trumped science since Adam Smith. Heterodoxy is here to change the latter but not to cheap talk about the former.

The current situation of economics is summarized in this exhibit.

The key point is that there are political economics and theoretical economics, and ALL political economics is proto-scientific dung. The distinction between Orthodoxy/Heterodoxy does NOT stand for right-wing/left-wing but for cargo-cult/science. This translates into the Augean Project: to flush the cheap talkers of ALL colors/schools. #2


#1 Wikipedia
#2 Nothing to choose between Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy and Enough! Economists, retire now!

***

REPLY to Robert Locke, Ken Zimmerman, Dave Taylor, gracchibros et al. on Aug 27

Trumpism has become a widespread nuisance. It consists of nonsense maximization = sense minimization under the constraint of 140 characters. Economists are traditionally good at this discipline, and they hold the record with zero sense for a standard peer-reviewed DSGE/I=S/IS-LM paper, but they regularly need more than 140 characters for the demonstration.

Economists in general and heterodox economists, in particular, dabble in:
― economic history (William Neil et al.)
― history of scientific thought (Asad Zaman et al.)
― psychology (Ken Zimmerman et al.)
― sociology/Frankfurt School (graccibros et al.)
― philosophy/religion/literature (Dave Taylor et al.)
― political science (gracchibros et al.)
― ethics (mariaalejandramadi et al.).

All this is very, very interesting, but OUT of economics. Isn’t it time for the Jacks-of-all-Trades to do a little economics? Theory of employment? Theory of profit? What about a consistent and comprehensive explanation of how the economic system works that beats general equilibrium theory hands down?

Please note: Heterodoxy and Trumpism do not mix. Never ever. Those who cannot answer the question about the difference between income and profit are out of economics. Recall that you are not admitted to physics if you cannot tell the difference between potential and kinetic energy. Science is hard, and this also holds for economics. But in politics, they are happy about every Trumpy. Think about it.


Related 'Turning the bananatization of economics around'

August 20, 2016

Economics: A map for the perplexed

Comment on Matias Vernengo on ‘Noah Smith on heterodox models’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Aug 21 adapted to context

Noah Smith asserts: “So heterodox economics hasn’t really produced a replacement for mainstream macro.” This is true for traditional Heterodoxy but not for constructive Heterodoxy.

The whole truth is that Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are PROVABLY false, i.e., materially and formally inconsistent. It is not just about Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy.

For a stylized map of current economics, see Graphic AXEC83. See also post ‘From Orthodoxy to Heterodoxy to Metadoxy’ and cross references Paradigm shift.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke

August 18, 2016

Scientists do NOT predict the future (II)

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘On the irrelevance of Milton Friedman’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Aug 19

The representative economist has no idea of what science is all about. First of all, science does NOT ‘predict the future’ simply because, as a genuine scientist said: “The future is unpredictable.” (Feynman, 1992)

What is called prediction in science is categorically different from the commonsensical meaning of ‘predicting the future’. The sole criterion of science is true/false and not predicting the next crash or any other extraordinary event. This is the occupation of prophets, fear mongers, astrologers, psychics, poultry entrails readers, sensationalists, half-witted journalists, etcetera. In marked contrast, science is about invariants or eternal laws.

So, scientists do not predict when the next apple will fall from the tree. What they indeed predict is position and velocity at any point in time once the apple has started to fall. The commonsenser’s view of reality is entirely DIFFERENT from the scientist’s view. The commonsenser’s view is practical, trivial, and false but utterly convincing for other commonsensers. This is why false worldviews/theories that have no immediate grave negative practical consequences can survive for an indefinite time.

Each falling apple is a unique historical event. There are an arbitrary many proximate causes for an apple to fall: a hailstorm, playing children, an exploding meteorite, material fatigue, an earthquake, and so on. In almost all cases, the singular event is uncertain and unpredictable. That is so OBVIOUS that no physicist ever lost many words about the historicity and uncertainty of falling apples. Not more can be reiterated about uncertainty than five words: “We simply do not know.” (Keynes)

A SCIENTIFIC prediction is a conditional proposition that presupposes: (i) the exact knowledge of initial conditions, (ii) the knowledge of one or more universal laws, (iii) the absence of disturbances. (Popper, 1994)

Where do we get the universal laws from? They follow from a mental construct called theory. A theory, in turn, must satisfy TWO criteria: material consistency and formal consistency (Klant, 1994). The former is established by observation/testing, the latter by the axiomatic-deductive method, which in turn only works when the axioms/premises are true, or as Aristotle said: “When the premises are certain, true, and primary and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.” #1

Now it is pretty obvious that the behavioral premises/axioms of economics (agents individually optimize subject to constraints; agents have full relevant knowledge, etc.) are NOT certain, true, and primary. And this means that the whole analytical superstructure of orthodox economics is false, even if each intermediate logical step is correct.

Neither Friedman nor Samuelson nor the rest of the scientifically incompetent orthodox and heterodox crowd got this elementary methodological point. And this is why Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are provably false. The common underlying error of these approaches consists of the naive commonsensical belief that economics is a social science. This quite naturally leads to the acceptance of silly assumptions about human nature/behavior/action as premises/axioms.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 For more details, see the exhibit on Graphic. AXEC77.

Related 'Economics is NOT a social science' and 'How to get rid of an obsolete theory' and 'Prediction/Forecasting' and 'Scientists do not predict' and 'Behavioral economics ― forever stuck at the proto-scientific level' and 'True macrofoundations: the reset of economics'

***
COMMENT on Thornton Hall on Aug 19

You quote Hume: “... but when the road ends at a coal-pit, he [the traveler] doesn’t need much judgment to know that he has gone wrong, and perhaps to find out what has led him astray.” And conclude: “Syll, et al, choose to debate the size, scope, and shape of the coal pit.”

This, though, misses the crucial point: “There is no evidence to suggest that economists abandon degenerating programs in the absence of a progressive alternative.” (Weintraub, 1985, p. 148)

Economists know quite well that they are in the coal pit. The point is that they have no clue how to get out. So Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy entertain the public with the grand coal-pit-wrestling-in-the-dark sitcom.

What is needed is the “progressive alternative”, i.e., a new Paradigm. Indeed, the failure of traditional Heterodoxy consists in endlessly debating the “size, scope, and shape of the coal pit” or, as Feyerabend put it: “... we may say that the ... omnipresence of a certain point of view is not a sign of excellence or an indication that the truth or part of the truth has at last been found. It is, rather, the indication of a failure of reason to find suitable alternatives which might be used to transcend an accidental intermediate stage of our knowledge.” (2004, p. 72)

The real task, then, is to define the new foundations of a materially and formally consistent economic paradigm. This, obviously, is beyond the means of the adherents of both Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy. #1 These folks will end their wasted scientific lives in the coal pit.


References
Feyerabend, P. K. (2004). Problems of Empiricism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Weintraub, E. R. (1985). Joan Robinson’s Critique of Equilibrium: An Appraisal. American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 75(2): 146–149. URL

#1 ‘From Orthodoxy to Heterodoxy to Metadoxy’and ‘How to get rid of an obsolete theory’ and cross-references Paradigm shift and 'Prediction does not work? Try retrodiction first' and 'What is dead certain in an uncertain world: economists’ abysmal incompetence'

August 17, 2016

How to get rid of an obsolete theory

Comment on Raphaële Chappe on ‘General Equilibrium Theory: Sound and Fury, Signifying Nothing?’

Blog-Reference

Orthodoxy has failed on all counts and has no future. This is the point of departure of all new economic thinking. The ultimate reason for failure is the proven scientific incompetence of economists since Adam Smith.

The rules of conduct of the scientific community demand that the actual state of economics is at all times unambiguously communicated to the general public. This implies, as the VERY FIRST step, that the word sciences is deleted from the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”.

Because every theory is defined by its foundational premises, a.k.a. axioms, there is, as a matter of principle, no need to refute every single proposition of the elaborated theoretical superstructure; it suffices to ‘throw over’ (Keynes) the axioms. Yet, this is not enough. The negative/destructive first step must be followed by a positive/constructive second step. As Blaug put it: “The moral of the story is simply this: it takes a new theory, and not just the destructive exposure of assumptions or the collection of new facts, to beat an old theory.” (1998, p. 703)

First step: economists have to throw over the orthodox set of axioms, which is defined by these six hard-core propositions:

HC1 There exist economic agents.
HC2 Agents have preferences over outcomes.
HC3 Agents independently optimize subject to constraints.
HC4 Choices are made in interrelated markets.
HC5 Agents have full relevant knowledge.
HC6 Observable economic outcomes are coordinated, so they must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states. (Weintraub, 1985, p. 109)

The methodological blunder that suffices to make this axiom set unacceptable is that HC3 and HC5 introduce nonentities, and that HC6 is a petitio principii.

Note that we follow here Keynes’s methodological insight as laid down in the General Theory: “The classical theorists resemble Euclidean geometers in a non-Euclidean world who, discovering that in experience straight lines apparently parallel often meet, rebuke the lines for not keeping straight ― as the only remedy for the unfortunate collisions which are occurring. Yet, in truth, there is no remedy except to throw over the axiom of parallels and to work out a non-Euclidean geometry. Something similar is required to-day in economics.” (1973, p. 16)

In other words, the methodological revolution in economics consists in the switch from behavior-centered bottom-up, i.e., subjective microfoundations, to structure-centered top-down, i.e., objective macrofoundations.

Accordingly, Keynes went on to define the new set of foundational propositions: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income - consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” (1973, p. 63)

Unfortunately, at this critical juncture, an error slipped in because Keynes did not come to grips with profit: “His Collected Writings show that he wrestled to solve the Profit Puzzle up till the semi-final versions of his GT but in the end he gave up and discarded the draft chapter dealing with it.” (Tómasson et al., 2010, p. 12)

Because of this, Keynes’s two foundational macroeconomic equations (Y=C+I, S=Y−C) have to be replaced. The most elementary configuration of the economy consists of the household and the business sector, which in turn consists initially of one giant fully integrated firm and is given by these three objective structural axioms:

(A1) Yw=WL wage income Yw is equal to wage rate W times working hours L,
(A2) O=RL output O is equal to productivity R times working hours L,
(A3) C=PX consumption expenditure C is equal to price P times quantity bought/sold X.

The investment goods sector comes in at a later stage. So, what we have with (A1) to (A3) is the elementary consumption economy as the most elementary economic structure. This structure is the core of what Keynes called the monetary theory of production, and it fully replaces the silly real exchange models.

After-Keynesians either got stuck at I=S/IS-LM-models which are provably false (2011) or fell back to maximization-and-equilibrium, i.e., HC1 to HC6, or both, as in the case of the maximally confused Krugman (2014).

Human behavior, tastes, choice, or society have no durable underlying structure, but the monetary economy has, and this systemic structure is given in the most elementary case by (A1) to (A3). Economics is NOT a behavioral or social science but a systems science. A system can be unambiguously defined. This is an indispensable condition to do science. The alternative to science is storytelling. This is what Walrasians, Keynesians, Marxians, and Austrians are actually doing.

Keynes started the Paradigm Shift from micro to macro. However, he got stuck with the definition of overall profit. Not to know what profit is turns out to be fatal for every economist and every approach. This methodological deadlock is overcome with the consistent axiomatic set (A1) to (A3), which provides the formally and materially consistent economic theory. #1 Thus, Metadoxy replaces both Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy.

Raphaële Chappe concludes: “When a way of thinking limits our thinking then it’s time, with due appreciation for those who built it, to ‘throw away the ladder’.” This, though, misses the crucial point: “There is no evidence to suggest that economists abandon degenerating programs in the absence of a progressive alternative.” (Weintraub, 1985, p. 148)

The real task, then, is to define the foundations of a materially and formally consistent economic Paradigm. This is beyond the means of the adherents of both Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Blaug, M. (1998). Economic Theory in Retrospect. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 5th edition.
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). Mr. Keynes, Prof. Krugman, IS-LM, and the End of Economics as We Know It. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2392856: 1–19. URL
Keynes, J. M. (1973). The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Tómasson, G., and Bezemer, D. J. (2010). What is the Source of Profit and Interest? A Classical Conundrum Reconsidered. MPRA Paper, 20557: 1–34. URL
Weintraub, E. R. (1985a). General Equilibrium Analysis. Cambridge, London, New York, etc.: Cambridge University Press.
Weintraub, E. R. (1985b). Joan Robinson’s Critique of Equilibrium: An Appraisal. American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 75(2): 146–149. URL

#1 For details of the big picture, see cross references Paradigm Shift

Orthodoxy/Heterodoxy/Metadoxy

Comment on Noah Smith on ‘Economics Without Math Is Trendy, But It Doesn’t Add Up’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference adapted to context

Noah Smith asserts: “So heterodox economics hasn’t really produced a replacement for mainstream macro.” This is true for traditional Heterodoxy but not for Constructive Heterodoxy.

See From Orthodoxy to Heterodoxy to Metadoxy and cross references Paradigm Shift.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Related 'Heterodoxy'

August 16, 2016

Heterodoxy

Comment on Noah Smith on ‘Economics Without Math Is Trendy, But It Doesn’t Add Up’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference adapted to context

Noah Smith is only partly correct. The whole truth is that Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are PROVABLY false, i.e. materially and formally inconsistent. It is not just about Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy. The ultimate reason for the all-around failure is the scientific incompetence of economists (including Noah Smith, of course).

For more details about the actual state see The scientific self-elimination of Heterodoxy and cross references Heterodoxy.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Related 'Orthodoxy/Heterodoxy/Metadoxy'