July 9, 2016

Enough! Economists, retire now!

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Krugman’s dangerous lack of methodological reflection’

Blog-Reference

(i) There is Orthodoxy with microfoundations, and it has been nicely defined by Krugman: “... most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.” #1

(ii) Methodologically, these premises are forever unacceptable. #2

(iii) When the premises/axioms/foundational propositions are false or contain NONENTITIES, the whole theory/model/superstructure is false. Because of this, there is NO need to check the theoretical superstructure or the policy conclusions of Neoclassics in great detail.

(iv) Hydra Rule: It is not only a waste of time to fight the countless heads of the beast and to decapitate them one by one, but de facto counterproductive. #3 The only effective method of refutation is to go directly to the heart of the matter, i.e., to the axioms.

(v) Neoclassical policy proposals have NO valid theoretical foundations. However, because many details/add-ons/illustrations of a longer and mixed argument are accurate, commonsensical, tautological, approximately true on a small/micro-scale, credible, or part of the unquestioned social belief system, the general public cannot see that there is a TOTAL DISCONNECT between an economic policy proposal and the underlying theory. Just as there is a total disconnect between poultry entrails and the utterances of the haruspex, which guided ancient Roman policy. #4

(vi) The Disconnect Generalization: ALL economic policy arguments of Walrasians, Keynesians, Marxians, and Austrians are hanging in midair and are scientifically unfounded.

(vii) The only general statement that can be made with certainty about human behavior is that it is target-oriented. Targets, though, are dependent on expectations. Expectations, in turn, are almost instantaneously adaptable, only loosely connected to objective reality, emotionally inflated, and subject to sudden changes that are transmitted with high speed between individuals. Because of the ONTOLOGICAL UNCERTAINTY of expectations and by implication targets, there can be NO such thing as a behavioral axiom. Axioms must be certain, or as Aristotle put it, certain, true, and primary.

(viii) Because human behavior cannot be axiomatized, the microfoundations program has already been dead in the cradle 150+ years ago.

(ix) Keynes started the macrofoundations research program in the General Theory formally as follows: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” These formal foundations are conceptually and logically defective because Keynes never came to grips with profit (2011; 2012).

(x) Because of this, the macrofoundations approach (including After-Keynesianism, Post-Keynesianism, New Keynesianism, and all I=S/IS-LM models) was already dead in the cradle 80+ years ago.

Review of the Troops. Provably false
• profit theory, for 200+ years,
• microfoundations, for 150+ years,
• macrofoundations, for 80+ years,
• application of elementary (2012) and high-powered mathematical tools, for approx. 100 years. #5

ALL models that contain maximization-and-equilibrium or I=S are a priori false, and this is more than 90 percent of the content of peer-reviewed economic quality journals and 100 percent of textbooks of renowned authors.

(xi) No more proof of scientific incompetence is needed. Remains only one question for society: how to get rid of the ‘throng of superfluous economists’. #6

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2012). The Common Error of Common Sense: An Essential Rectification of the Accounting Approach. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2124415: 1–23. URL

#1 More detailed, the starting point is given with these axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub, 1985)
#2 For details and proofs, see the blog and working papers
#3 Wikipedia Lernaean Hydra
#4 Wikipedia Haruspex
#5 For the REAL mathiness problem, see Jonathan Barzilai, Scientific Metrics, Open Letter to the President of the American Economic Association and papers
#6 Joan Robinson

Related 'Economists ― standing on the shoulders of dwarfs' and 'Hooray! The formalization issue is finally settled' and 'Economics: a science without scientists' and 'Economics: communication without content' and 'Economics: A failed/fake science for 200+ years' and 'Modern macro moronism' and 'The clock runs down on economics' and 'MMT and the canonical macroeconomic model'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references Failed/Fake Scientists.

***
COMMENT on Kingsley Lewis on Jul 11

Your positioning of Krugman’s approach is false. Krugman is NOT in the right way and at an early stage of development that will eventually lead to success. Krugman is definitely at the dead-end of the wrong way. So he is not comparable to a precursor like Tycho Brahe#1 but to Ptolemy #2, the iconic representative of geocentrism. Geocentrism was refuted by Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo, and Newton in the course of the Scientific Revolution and was fully REPLACED by heliocentrism.

So, Krugman is the representative of an approach that will vanish from the corpus of accepted scientific truths without a trace.

The actual situation and the alternative futures of economics are summarized in this chart on Graphic AXEC79.


(i) Neoclassical economics is dead but not buried (squares D and G).
(ii) Most heterodox economists are on square E (traditional Heterodoxy) and have the choice between E-C, E-F, and E-I.
(ii) I am on square B (Constructive Heterodoxy).
(iii) Some heterodox economists are on square H (nihilistic Heterodoxy), and they are going nowhere.

The two wrong ways are E-F (toward the pluralism of false/inconclusive theories) and E-I (toward the weaponizing/capturing/politicizing of economics).

Like you, I see Lars Syll in squares H/E, but you in squares G/D. In brief, Orthodoxy/ Krugman/Lewis is at the ultimate end of a cul-de-sac. Compared to this, Lars Syll’s position is progress. It all depends on where he goes from there. Krugman, in marked contrast, is locked and will not go anywhere. Your positioning of Krugman as a hopeful and modestly successful precursor of scientific truth is indefensible.


#1 See Brahe
#2 See Ptolemy

***
REPLY to Kingsley Lewis on Jul 11

If you have a serious interest in rigorous formal proofs of Krugman’s and your own scientific incompetence, I recommend
Alternatively, you can enter Krugman’s and my full name in Google, and you will get 1.910 hits in 0,38 seconds. This is much faster and more productive than typing silly questions and comments.

July 6, 2016

The economist as second-guesser, thought-reader, and folk psychologist

Comment on Asad Zaman on ‘ET1% — Economic Theory of the top 1%’

Blog-Reference

You say: “As Feynman put clearly, no matter how clever you are, and no matter how fancy your theory is, if it does not match observations, it is wrong.”

We perfectly agree. #1 Science is strictly about material (empirical) and formal (logical) consistency (Klant, 1994, p. 31); everything else is storytelling.

You also say: “Even playing along with your confinement of economics to monetary theory, there is no way to understand money without understanding human behavior.”

Please note, when I use the term monetary economy, this is the SAME thing that Keynes called the monetary theory of production. The monetary economy is the real economy. The “real” economy in the sense of Sraffa, RBC, or other money-is-a-veil approaches is NOT the real economy. The monetary economy constitutes itself through the interaction of real AND nominal variables. The monetary economy has nothing at all to do with what is known as Monetarism (2011).

You say: “For example consider the Brexit vote and the subsequent drastic drop in the value of the GBP. It is impossible to explain these phenomena without understanding human behavior.”

Seen from the business sector, the Brexit vote is an external shock. Imagine the business sector conducts a post-Brexit survey asking consumers, ‘How much will your consumption expenditures decrease/ increase YoY’ and asking firms, ‘How much will your investment expenditures decrease/increase YoY’ and so on. Let us assume the survey yields reliable numbers. This is ALL the business sector or the economist needs to know. It is absolutely irrelevant to understand why people voted as they did (frustration, economic distress, fear, hope, xenophobia, stupidity, propaganda, etc). This is an issue for sociologists or other social scientists.

The social scientists will deliver an INTERPRETATION, and here the problem is “... observed acts of behavior allow an indefinite number of interpretations regarding the plans from which they are assumed to have sprung.” (Morgenstern, 1941, p. 381)

For the understanding of how the monetary economy works, these interpretations are IRRELEVANT. What is needed are the concrete rates of change of expenditures and other economic variables. And these do certainly NOT come from highly subjective interpretations. For a businessman who goes bankrupt after Brexit, it is a matter of indifference whether this is due to racism, pessimism, the stupidity of his countrymen/ government, or the wrath of God for former sins. The why-interpretation in NO way affects his real situation.

Of course, for the political discussion and agenda-pushing and sitcom gossiping, all this PsySoc stuff is important. But politics and economics should be kept strictly separated, and politics should be left to the political scientists. The economist’s business is the economy and NOTHING else. For the economist, Brexit is simply a one-time random event, and nothing is gained by thought-reading the population after the fact. Explanations are for the birds.

You assert “... the same tactic would lead to hyperinflation in other economies. Again, there is no way to understand/explain this phenomenon without paying attention to historical and structural details which would fall outside the ambit of any axiomatic system.”

You simply do not get what axiomatization is all about. A concrete event is a combination of space-time-specific conditions and the interaction of universal laws (2014b). When a man is thrown out of the window, this is a political or criminal act, but independently of this, the Law of Falling Bodies applies. The Law is part of the general theory of motion, which in turn has been axiomatized by Newton. Clearly, the theory of motion does NOT explain why the man flew out of the window. But there are neighbors and bystanders and psychologists and journalists and paranoiacs who can readily “explain” it. These explanations are guesswork and thought-reading, storytelling, and are scientifically worthless. All this stuff can be left to the police and the historian.

Nobody needs an economist to predict that the exchange rate will plummet when a country falls apart. This is common sense stuff, and every forex trader or journalist will predict it. And that actions are guided by expectations is a triviality since the dawn of mankind. But second-guessing expectations is not science but folk psychology and vacuous speculation. Here Keynes’ dictum applies: ‘We simply do not know.’ However, people/economists like to waffle about expectations because everybody can contribute their own silly guess to entertaining human communication.

You say: “To conclude, it is IMPOSSIBLE to study economics without having a theory of human behavior.” False. Theories of human behavior are the subject matter of psychology/sociology, and economists who are confused about their subject matter. Most microeconomic studies, including your babysitter study, can and should be left to sociologists.

I say: “To conclude, it is IMPOSSIBLE to study economics without having a theory of profit.” You have NO theory of profit and therefore you cannot explain how the economy works. Your theory of babysitting does NOT help that much.

The Iron Law of Economic Methodology says: NO way leads from the understanding of human behavior to the understanding of how the monetary economy works (2014a). And this explains why the microfoundations approach has been doomed to failure from the very beginning.

You say: “Profit is also a subjective concept — as the bible says: For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?”

Well said! There is subjective reality and objective reality. Science, though, deals EXCLUSIVELY with the latter. The economist is supposed to figure out the Profit Law, and he is neither supposed nor entitled nor qualified to preach about lost souls.

It is high time that Heterodox economists make up their minds about whether they want to become a religious sect, political agenda pushers, or the future scientific mainstream.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Reconstructing the Quantity Theory (I). SSRN Working Paper Series, 1895268: 1–28. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014a). Objective Principles of Economics. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2418851: 1–19. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014b). The Synthesis of Economic Law, Evolution, and History. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2500696: 1–22. URL
Klant, J. J. (1994). The Nature of Economic Thought. Aldershot, Brookfield: Edward Elgar.
Morgenstern, O. (1941). Professor Hicks on Value and Capital. Journal of Political Economy, 49(3): 361–393. URL

#1 For the Feynman quote and the YouTube link, see There is no like/dislike button in science.

Related 'Enough! Economists, retire now!' and 'Beware of the moralizing economist' and 'The economist as moralist' and 'The moralizing economist is not a good guy but a fake scientist' and 'The ethics of science is consistency ― economics is inconsistent'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references Political Economics/Stupidity/Corruption and 'Refocusing economics'.

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jun 7

You ask: “Profit of what? Are you asking for a definition of ‘value’?”

Monetary profit is objective. You can touch it in the cash box or see it on your bank account with a precision of two decimal places. Value is a subjective concept. So economics has to deal FIRST with measurable profit and LATER with value. Economists did it the other way round, and this is like putting your boots on and then trying to get into your trousers. This has never worked and never will. It is simply a dilettantish methodological mistake. And this mistake is built into the neoclassical axiom set, which is subjective-behavioral. This is the ultimate root cause of the scientific failure of economics.

In order to get economics out of folk psychology and folk sociology, the Walrasian subjective-behavioral axioms have to be REPLACED by objective-structural axioms. #1

Iron Rule of methodology: deal first with the objective aspects of reality and then with the subjective aspects. Economics cannot be built upon green cheese behavioral assumptions and nonentities like constrained optimization and equilibrium. ALL models that contain these two concepts are a priori false, and this is more than 90 percent of the content of peer-reviewed economic journals.

You say, “I maintain that human behavior, even if its structure is not fixed, must be somehow integrated into the formal system, otherwise it is unclear to me why the system should still be representative of anything real.”

Yes, of course. It is all a matter of methodological SEQUENCE: structure comes first, behavior comes second; objectivity comes first, subjectivity comes second. This is what the inescapable Paradigm Shift is all about. For the consistent formalization of human behavior, see (2015).

Make no mistake, it is NOT either structure or behavior; it is structure first and behavior second. This is why economics has to be based on objective-structural axioms.


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). Essentials of Constructive Heterodoxy: Behavior. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2600523: 1–17. URL

#1 For how this is done, see the cross-references New Curriculum.

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jul 8

You criticize the structural axioms: “Your model, as it stands now, is obviously too simplistic.”

You obviously cannot get your head around the starting problem. #1 Every analysis starts with premises/primitive propositions/axioms. For axioms, the MINIMUM principle holds, and this has been known since antiquity as Occam’s razor. So, the first methodological task is to find the simplest set of foundational propositions. Simplest in this context means not further reducible. The first thing to notice is that the three structural axioms are not further reducible.

Among scientists, simplicity is a significant quality attribute: “Others, the inexperienced students, make guesses that are very complicated, and it sort of looks as if it is all right, but I know it is not true because the truth always turns out to be simpler than you thought.” (Feynman, 1992)

von Mises ― your methodological lamppost ― took the action axiom as the starting point. Unfortunately, he thereby fell for the same blunder that Neoclassicals fell into when they built upon subjective-behavioral axioms instead of objective-structural axioms.

Krugman is exemplary for his explicit commitment to his axiomatic starting point: “most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.” With this wrong selection of axioms, he readily debunks himself, just like von Mises. There is NO need to check the theoretical superstructure or the policy conclusions of Neoclassicals or Austrians because when the axioms are false, all the rest is worthless.

Only objective-structural axioms lead to propositions that can be confronted with reality. As you should know, the empirical test is the ULTIMATE arbiter in science. Or, as Asad Zaman put it: “... no matter how clever you are, and no matter how fancy your theory is, if it does not match observations, it is wrong.”

In brief, that you find the structural axiom set too simplistic is, in turn, too simplistic: it is the PROOF of logical and material consistency that counts in science and NOTHING else. #2

As far as one can see, there is NO serious alternative to the objective-structural axiom set.


#1 “What are the propositions which may reasonably be received without proof? That there must be some such propositions all are agreed, since there cannot be an infinite series of proof, a chain suspended from nothing. But to determine what these propositions are is the opus magnum of the more recondite mental philosophy.” (J. S. Mill)
#2 For the proof that Austrian profit theory, too, is false, see How the Intelligent Non-Economist Can Refute Every Economist Hands Down.

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jul 8

(i) The issue of this thread is that Asad Zaman not only asserts that Orthodoxy is axiomatically false ― to which all heterodox economists agree ― but that it is INTENTIONALLY false. This raises, first of all, the following question: Heterodoxy, too, is axiomatically false, #1, and now it would be interesting to learn whether this is also intentional?

(ii) If it is intentional, this opens a big can of worms, e.g., can students sue their university for false teaching? or textbook publishing houses? or textbook writers? Is there something like an educational product liability? bear economists liability for misleading policy advice that causes enormous damages (e.g. unemployment)? have they had to pay back Nobel Prize money? have they been thrown out of academia? and so on. Intentionality is a serious accusation, and I wonder whether this is the consensus among heterodox economists.

(iii) Therefore, in the given context, the structural axiom set is not at all an issue. If you think your axioms are better, simply stick to them. I have no intention to convince you of anything. For me, it suffices to REFUTE you.

(iv) If you think you have found a mistake/error in my papers, please add the reference. I cannot answer assertions like “you do not adequately account for new bank-credit” except that this is the worst nonsense imaginable. I have written two papers about the Quantity Theory and there you can study the relationship between money and credit and credit creation in extenso. In fact, ALL my papers deal exclusively with pure credit money. Your assertion is patently false, and everybody can easily check it. #2 Money and credit follow DIRECTLY from the structural axiom set! And this is as it MUST be! ALL economic phenomena must ultimately follow from the axioms.

This, exactly, is the beauty of axiomatization. “A theory is the more impressive the greater the simplicity of its premises, the more different kinds of things it relates, and the more extended is its area of applicability.” (Einstein)

Austrians in general and you in particular never got this point.


#1 The scientific self-elimination of Heterodoxy and Heterodoxy, too, is scientific junk.
#2 See working papers on SSRN

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jul 9

The section from which you have taken the quote is titled “From function to institution” (2015, Sec. 11). Accordingly, the section STARTS with a FUNCTIONAL analysis which describes how the ideal banking system operates and then continues IMMEDIATELY after your quote:

“This said, it is clear that in the concrete case the institutional design of the central bank is of utmost importance. Not many countries have been perfect in the art of institution building. The Federal Reserve System in particular has met with a lot of critique lately. Only part of it is justified. The functional analysis provides some ideas for institution building. It should be clear that successful institution building presupposes the correct theory of money. What we have analyzed above is the ideal type of the monetary economy and the central bank. This helps to identify the institutional weak spots of concrete banking systems.”

In brief: you need to know what it takes for an aircraft to fly (laws of aerodynamics, thermodynamics, material science, etc) in order to build one and in order to explain in a concrete case why it crashed (bad design, functional failure, human failure, etc). The functional analysis delivers the OBJECTIVE benchmark of a well-functioning economy (2013). Against this background, the mathematical proof can be given that the actual monetary economy MUST break down EVEN if it functions perfectly (2014). This proof refutes the central assertions of General Equilibrium Theory.

Independent of this, the fact of the matter is:
(i) You do not know what profit is, so you have no idea how the monetary economy works. This you have in common with Orthodoxy. Both heterodox and orthodox profit theory is PROVABLY false.
(ii) As collateral damage, your theory of money is provably false. This you have in common with Orthodoxy.
(iii) Either you do not understand what you read, or you do not know how to quote correctly.

The version of Heterodoxy you represent is scientifically NOT better than Orthodoxy, but worse. And Orthodoxy is already bad enough.

The common denominator of current Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy is that it is political economics and NOT scientific economics. And political economics has produced NOTHING of scientific value since Adam Smith and Karl Marx. The failure of economics is due to the scientific incompetence of BOTH orthodox and heterodox economists.

The question of whether economists are naturally incompetent or intentionally incompetent is a moot one. ALL incompetent scientists have to be thrown out of science/academia, no matter what their political color is. Science is ABOVE politics, and the ULTIMATE arbiter of science is the theory-guided observation/test. #1


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2013). The Ideal Economy: A Prototype. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2355860: 1–27. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2375578: 1–21. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). Essentials of Constructive Heterodoxy: Money, Credit, Interest. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2569663: 1–19. URL

#1 See Graphic AXEC77 and Graphic AXEC78.

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jul 11

The actual situation and the alternative futures of Heterodoxy are summarized in this Graphic chart AXEC79


(i) Most heterodox economists are at E (traditional Heterodoxy) and have the choice between E-C, E-F, and E-I.
(ii) I am at B (constructive Heterodoxy) and propose to move to C.
(iii) Some heterodox economists are at H (nihilistic Heterodoxy), and they go nowhere.

As everybody can glean from my posts #1, I argue against E-F (the pluralism of false/ inconclusive theories) and E-I (the weaponizing/capturing/politicizing of economics in the name of either the one-percenters or the ninety-nine-percenters).

I see you on E-I, that is, the Zaman way.

Science is ABOVE politics, and the ULTIMATE arbiter of science is the theory-guided observation/test. Methodological discussions are pointless in economics because the scientific criteria are given and immutable (= material and formal consistency). So, there is either sticking to the rules or leaving science (Sexit #2), but no such thing as playing tennis with the methodological net down.

Neither the one-percenters nor the ninety-nine-percenters have anything to say in science. Political economics in ANY form or color is inadmissible without exception. The separation of politics and science has often been ignored/violated in the past, mostly by the one-percenters. Heterodoxy has to make sure that this does NOT happen in the future.


#1 See Blog.
#2 Enough! Economists, retire now!

***
REPLY to robert locke on Jul 12

You say: “German business economists discussed the question of Wirtschaftlichkeit and profits in the early 1920s, and the discussion about profit hinged on definition about the purpose of the firm.”

True, but business economists, being business economists, have the horizon of a kneeling ant. And what they do is deliver an INTERPRETATION of a minuscule cutout of economic reality.

What is needed INSTEAD is the monetary profit for the (world-) economy as a whole. This is a measurable variable, whereas what the sociocultural economist regularly delivers is woolly PsySoc babble. Best of all, these interpretations are contradictory, and when generalized for the economy as a whole, the Fallacy of Composition kicks in, and this renders the whole exercise worthless. Profit for the economy as a whole does NOT AT ALL depend on PsySoc factors or what people think about it or what the purpose of the firm is. Monetary profit is given by the objective and immutable PROFIT LAW with the precision of two decimals.

You ask me: “Where have you been for the past 90 or so years?”

Most of the time in the real world, where I have collected profit definitions from Adam Smith onward #1, and guess what, it did not even take me one year to realize that they are ALL contradictory and ALL false. #2

Isn’t it curious that economists never felt the urge to clear up the mess and to meticulously define the pivotal concept of their subject matter? Obviously, in the past 90 or so years, they did not wake up from their PsySoc delirium.


#1 Profit: One way to get it right, many ways to get it wrong
#2 Profit and the collective failure of economists and also How the Intelligent Non-Economist Can Refute Every Economist Hands Down

***
REPLY to robert locke on Jul 12

As an economist, I am interested in how the monetary economy works.

I am NOT interested in how the German or the US educational system works. As far as economics is concerned, neither system has produced noteworthy scientific output, but only a lot of more or less useful sociological micro-studies that are confined to a tiny section of geographical space and historical time. This admitted, one has to realize that after more than 200 years, economists do still not know how ‘the monetary economy’, i.e., an abstract entity with unspecified space-time coordinates, works. Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism are provably false.

I am NOT interested in the economist as a person/character but in his/her research output. When I read a paper, I want to learn something about the economy and not be bothered with personal idiosyncrasies. I am focused on whether the paper is logically/empirically correct and not on whether the author is a good or bad guy and what his nationality, gender, reputation, religious/political/sexual orientation is, and who his colleagues and friends are. I do NOT study CVs, I study economics.

Of course, I agree with Asad Zaman that a meta-analysis of how the community of economists organizes itself and interacts and communicates with society/business/state, and how it allocates financial/non-financial incentives/disincentives, is very important. Excellent work has been done by Mirowski in this field (1995; 2002; 2009), BUT meta-economics deals with economists and NOT with the economy. Meta-economics, or the study of the history of economic thought are worthy subject in itself but vastly different from economics proper.

In brief, I have no qualms with what Asad Zaman says about the one-percenters or the importance of meta-economics, except that it leads AWAY from the point at issue, that is, the materially and formally correct theory of how the monetary economy works.

The actual situation and the alternative futures of economics are summarized in this chart on Graphic AXEC80


(i) Neoclassical economics is dead but not buried (squares D and G).
(ii) Most heterodox economists are on square E (traditional Heterodoxy) and have the choice between E-C, E-F, and E-I.
(ii) I am on square B (constructive Heterodoxy).
(iii) Some heterodox economists are on square H (nihilistic Heterodoxy), and they are going nowhere.

The two wrong ways for the heterodox student of economics are E-F (toward the pluralism of false/inconclusive theories and incoherent stand-alone micro-truths) and E-I (toward the weaponizing/capturing/politicizing of economics).

I think E-F roughly characterizes your way, and E-I roughly characterizes Asad Zaman’s way.

For the young students of economics, two things are certain: (i) Orthodoxy and traditional Heterodoxy have failed, and (ii), because they will not be spoon-fed the true economic theory by their teachers, they will have to figure it out for themselves. Mind you, whoever accepts utility maximization, supply-demand-equilibrium, microfoundations, I=S, well-behaved production functions, rational expectations, and all the provably false rest of Econ 101 is out of science from now to eternity, no matter what is written on his diploma.


References
Mirowski, P. (1995). More Heat than Light. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mirowski, P., and Plehwe, D. (2009). The Road From Mont Pelerin. The Making of the Neoliberal Thought Collective. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Press.
Mirowski, P., and Sent, E.-M. (2002). Science Bought and Sold, chapter Introduction, 1–66. Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press.

Ending the economic Froschmäusekrieg a.k.a. Batrachomyomachia

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Paul Krugman — nothing but a die-hard neoclassical economist’

Blog-Reference

The Battle of Frogs and Mice, a.k.a. Orthodoxy vs. Heterodoxy, has become rather stagnant, so let us shorten the agony with some clear-cut arbitral awards.

Syll: “Despite all his radical rhetoric, Krugman is — where it really counts — nothing but a die-hard neoclassical economist.”

Krugman says on his blog, “most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.”

Judgment :#1 Krugman is a neoclassical economist, always was, and always said so, and everybody got it. Stop being surprised, Lars Syll. The point at issue is NOT that Krugman is a Neoclassical but that his starting point, i.e., the neoclassical axiom set, is false.

Krugman: “... this is exactly the kind of situation in which words alone can create an illusion of logical coherence that dissipates when you try to do the math.” In other words, formalization and modeling can be helpful to clarify the issue.

Georgescu-Roegen: “Lest this position is misinterpreted again by some casual reader, let me repeat that my point is not that arithmetization of science is undesirable. Whenever arithmetization can be worked out, its merits are above all words of praise. My point is that wholesale arithmetization is impossible, that there is valid knowledge even without arithmetization, and that mock arithmetization is dangerous if peddled as genuine.”

Syll: “That’s a methodological reductionist straightjacket.”

Judgment: Krugman and Georgescu-Roegen are right. Lars Syll is wrong.

Syll: “The only economic analysis that Krugman and other mainstream economists accept is the one that takes place within the analytic-formalistic modeling strategy that makes up the core of mainstream economics.”

Krugman on several occasions: “where’s your model?” and “what’s your alternative?”

Lewis: “There is no example, not even a vague outline, of what Prof. Syll might regard as a satisfactory economic analysis of 'an open system where complex and relational structures and agents interact'. Because it is devoid of any such substance, Prof. Syll’s argument provides no understanding of how Krugman’s many errors could have been avoided.

Judgment: Lars Syll has never presented an alternative. His advice: “I would rather suggest you read Keynes, Minsky, Polanyi, Galbraith, Myrdal, Hodgson, Keen, Mirowski, Lawson, Davidson, Kalecki, Chick, Dow” is hand waving and does not count as an alternative because Keynes’, Minsky’s, Kalecki’s, Keen’s, Davidson’s and other heterodox economists’ models are also defective, i.e. provably false. Lawson, Chick, Dow are failed methodologists because they cannot even spot elementary logical blunders, which are entirely sufficient for the refutation of a theory/model.

Syll: “That isn’t pluralism.”

Judgment: Science is about clear-cut true/false and the very opposite of the pluralism of false theories. Either Orthodoxy is true, or Heterodoxy is true; then either Orthodoxy is thrown out of science or Heterodoxy. Except that both are false, then both are thrown out of science.

Syll: “Validly deducing things from patently unreal assumptions — that we all know are purely fictional — makes most of the modeling exercises pursued by mainstream economists rather pointless. It’s simply not the stuff that real understanding and explanation in science is made of.”

Aristotle: “When the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.”

Judgment: Lars Syll and Aristotle are right. Economics is currently based on false axioms. Both Walrasian and Keynesian axioms have to be fully replaced in order to produce scientific knowledge of the economy. After more than 200 years of producing scientific garbage, this task has top priority. Concrete proposals are urgently needed. Lars Syll has none.

Hickey: “There is nothing wrong with using a simple IS-LM approach in some cases as a gadget.”

Judgment: IS-LM has already died in the cradle (2014a). You are way behind the curve.

Pontus: “Banks are only intermediary in a certain sense: Any loan that is granted implies that someone’s spending exceeds his or her income. That does necessarily imply that someone else’s spending must fall short of his or her income.”

Judgment: You are way behind the curve (2014b).

Wilder: “National income accounting identifies a category it calls 'saving' that it opposes in its double‑entry scheme to 'investment'. Honestly, I have to say it does not make a lot of sense: while investment is spending and transactional, saving is not.”

Judgment: This matter has already been settled (2012). You are way behind the curve.

Nanikore: “Samuelson’s project has ultimately reached its inevitable end — but the subject which has invested so much in it is finding reality hard to swallow. I don’t know what it is going to take to finally kill the beast.”

Judgment: Yes, you are in dire straits. But could you now stop repeating it over and over again and proceed to the inescapable Paradigm Shift?

Mellechman: “True, setting out such a model would imply accepting the core assumptions of what you call the ur-model.”

Judgment: Nonsense of the worst sort. Nobody is obliged to accept the core assumptions, a.k.a. neoclassical axioms. Just the opposite, as Keynes told his fellow economists long ago: “The classical theorists resemble Euclidean geometers in a non-Euclidean world who, discovering that in experience straight lines apparently parallel often meet, rebuke the lines for not keeping straight — as the only remedy for the unfortunate collisions which are occurring. Yet, in truth, there is no remedy except to throw over the axiom of parallels and to work out a non-Euclidean geometry. Something similar is required to-day in economics.”

So, let us end the Froschmäusekrieg and start doing real science.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2012). The Common Error of Common Sense: An Essential Rectification of the Accounting Approach. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2124415: 1–23. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014a). Loanable Funds vs. Endogenous Money: Krugman is Wrong, Keen is Right. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2389341: 1–17. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014b). Mr. Keynes, Prof. Krugman, IS-LM, and the End of Economics as We Know It. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2392856: 1–19. URL

#1 All judgments are backed in greater detail, see blog or working papers before jumping to silly conclusions.

For the details about the definitive resolution of the I=S/IS-LM issue, see cross-references.

July 5, 2016

The actual distribution is unacceptable? Do NOT seek economic advice!

Comment on David Ruccio on ‘Globalization, inequality, and imperialism’

Blog-Reference

Assume somebody argues as follows:
(i) We have reliable numbers about income and wealth distribution in our country and worldwide. They show extreme inequality.
(ii) I have come to the conclusion that this inequality is unacceptable for several reasons (economic, social, political, ethical, historical ...)
(iii) It turned out that there is a vast majority of fellow citizens who have come to the same conclusion.
(iv) We have decided in a referendum to take political action X in the immediate future that will lead to a more equal distribution in our country. There will be some negative effects but we believe the positive effects will be far greater.
(v) It is to be expected that other counties will act in like manner. So, we will have a more equal distribution worldwide soon.

Nobody should have any qualms with this argument and action plan. The point is that it belongs ENTIRELY to the political sphere. It contains not much economics and needs not much economics.

The qualms begin when economics comes in. Economists cannot explain how the monetary economy works, what profit is, how profit relates to exploitation, which built-in feedback loops stabilize and increase inequality, and how the distribution of income/wealth develops over time. What we know for sure is that the standard marginal productivity theory of distribution is false.

Unfortunately, other distribution theories are also false. Marx was, like the classics, a political economist and mainly concerned with society and the underlying laws/trends of societal evolution. As a matter of fact, he was rather good at descriptive sociology but failed as an economist. Like Smith, Ricardo, and other classical economists he got profit theory wrong (2014a). And this fate the Marxian school shares with the other schools until this very day: “A satisfactory theory of profits is still elusive.” (Desai, 2008, p. 10)

So we have Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism and all got profit theory wrong. Economics has NOTHING to say about the ultimate driving forces that have produced the observed inequality. And economics has NOTHING to offer in the way of effective measures that equalize the distribution without much collateral damage. Economists can describe the phenomenon of increasing inequality and talk much about it but they do not understand it. The profit and distribution theories are provably false since Adam Smith (2014b).

When Keynesian economists come one day to understand the relationship between income, profit, distributed profit, investment, saving, and deficit spending they will realize with horror that nothing has deteriorated the income distribution more than well-meant Keynesian deficit spending.#1 What economists lament today is an unintended consequence of their own policy advice and ultimately due to theory failure.

So, for a society that politically decides to change the income distribution, it would be a waste of time to seek the expertise of economists. Neither those who support the decision nor those who oppose it have a scientifically valid theory of how the actual monetary economy works.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Desai, M. (2008). Profit and Profit Theory. In S. N. Durlauf, and L. E. Blume (Eds.), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics Online, 1–11. Palgrave Macmillan, 2nd edition. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014a). Profit for Marxists. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2414301: 1–25. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014b). The Profit Theory is False Since Adam Smith. What About the True Distribution Theory? SSRN Working Paper Series, 2511741: 1–23. URL

#1 Profit and the collective failure of economists and Keynesianism as ultimate profit machine

July 4, 2016

Refocusing economics

Comment on Asad Zaman on ‘ET1% — Economic Theory of the top 1%’

Blog-Reference

All heterodox economists agree that orthodox economics is false — but for wildly different reasons. Roughly speaking, we have two categories of critique: scientific and political. When politics is taken out of the picture for a moment, then the situation is as depicted on the left panel of the chart Graphic AXEC78.

At the moment, we have no true economic theory, i.e., a theory of how the monetary economy works, which satisfies the well-defined scientific criteria of formal and material consistency. All other aspects of the situation put aside, the task of Heterodoxy is to move straightforwardly from false to true as indicated by the arrow A. This is called a Paradigm Shift.

However, if we add the political dimension, we complicate the situation and, in effect, make it INSOLUBLE. Simply put, when we combine the scientific binary true/false with the political binary good/bad and the three main political positions, then the matrix of issues explodes as shown in the right panel. By not keeping the scientific and the political sphere properly apart, economic discussion got lost in cross-talk, as indicated by the cloud B.

All heterodox economists agree that Orthodoxy is false. Now, it is obvious from the history of science that scientists have produced theories that have later turned out to be false or only partially true. Among scientists, this has always been regarded as a regrettable lack of serendipity: "A new idea is extremely difficult to think of. It takes a fantastic imagination." (Feynman) “But it is all a matter of chance: in order to solve a difficult problem, one needs not only understanding but also luck.” (Popper)

With his claim that orthodox economists INTENTIONALLY produce false theories, Asad Zaman leaves the scientific discourse, distracts from the point at issue, confuses the discussion, and in effect prevents problem-solving. As Schumpeter put it: “Remember: occasionally, it may be an interesting question to ask why a man says what he says; but whatever the answer, it does not tell us anything about whether what he says is true or false.”

Every heterodox student needs to be fully aware that economics has always been a mixture of political and theoretical economics. Economists have, on average, been more committed to political agenda pushing than to proper scientific research, and this is why economics has not produced much, if anything, of real scientific value in more than 200 years. This applies to BOTH orthodox and heterodox economists.

What is needed is the strict separation of science and politics. There is NO other way out of the proto-scientific cul-de-sac of economics: “It is only our inability to divorce research from politics, or our suspicion, all too often justified, that the other fellow cannot analyze with single-minded devotion to truth, which makes problems and party issues out of decisions that do not excite anyone in more fortunate fields of research.” (Schumpeter)

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Related 'Politics, storytelling, and science.' and 'The economist as second-guesser, mind reader, and folk psychologist'

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jul 4

You say: “The moment one defines what the term ‘scientific’ entails, and what are the ‘conditions’ of scientific truth, one is already in the realm of the social, and therefore of the political also.”

This is the Science-of-Man fallacy, and it has been made explicit by Hume: “It is evident, that all the sciences have a relation, greater or less, to human nature: and that however wide any of them may seem to run from it, they still return back by one passage or another. Even. Mathematics, Natural Philosophy, and Natural Religion are in some measure dependent on the science of MAN; since they lie under the cognizance of men, and are judged of by their powers and faculties.” (Hume, 2012, Introduction)

The Science-of-Man fallacy is the methodological foundation of the so-called social sciences, which Feynman aptly characterized as cargo cult sciences. Therefore, it is no accident that it is propagated by social philosophers like Polanyi, McLuhan, Lyotard etcetera. Genuine scientists are well aware of the subjective/social element and, because it is a well-known scientific nuisance, they try to minimize it: “Like Planck, Einstein viewed the human element of any physical theory as essentially arbitrary, something that should be purged on realization of the final true theory.” (Mirowski, 2004, p. 159)

Science is (starting with the ancient Greeks) well-defined by material and formal consistency, and scientists judge and are judged according to these criteria. These criteria are OBJECTIVE to the highest humanly possible degree. Genuine scientists have NO problem with these methodological essentials, but the storytellers of the so-called social sciences have always had.

The crucial point is that economics deals not primarily with individual human behavior or society at large (Hudík, 2011). This is the realm of psychology, sociology, anthropology, history, political science, social philosophy, biology/Darwinism/evolution theory, etc. Insofar as economics deals with behavioral assumptions like utility maximization, greed, power grabbing, etc., it is a dilettantish variant of Psycho-Sociology.

This PsySoc stuff, though, has been built into the axioms of Orthodoxy (methodological individualism, constrained optimization, rational expectation, and so on). And this explains why economics has never risen above the proto-scientific level.

Economics has to be redefined as systems science. Methodologically, the economic system as a whole has to be moved into the foreground. The economic system has its own logic, which is different from the behavioral logic of humans. The systemic logic is what Adam Smith called the Invisible Hand. Economic analysis has to make the Invisible Hand visible, that is, it has first of all to uncover the objective systemic laws of the monetary economy (2014).

It should be obvious to every heterodox economist that the Science-of-Man methodology has not produced much scientific value but a lot of sitcom entertainment. As far as economics is concerned, McLuhan’s dictum ‘The medium is the message’ certainly applies because the scientific content of economics is zero or close to zero.


References
Hudík, M. (2011). Why Economics is Not a Science of Behaviour. Journal of Economic Methodology, 18(2): 147–162.
Hume, D. (2012). A Treatise of Human Nature. Project Gutenberg EBook. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). Objective Principles of Economics. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2418851: 1–19. URL
Mirowski, P. (2004). The Effortless Economy of Science? Durham, London: Duke University Press.

***
REPLY to Asad Zaman on Jul 5

You say: “As ‘blocke, the’ put succinctly, there is a huge difference between social science and physical science which EKH completely fails to understand.”

Yes, there is a huge difference between social science and physical science. The difference is that the social sciences are cargo cult sciences (Feynman) and therefore have to be expelled from the sciences. The term social “science” is a misnomer insofar as the greater part of the social sciences does not satisfy the criteria of formal and material consistency.

The curious thing is, as far as economics is concerned, that beginning with Smith and including Marx, economists insist on doing science. This is either self-delusion or an abuse of the reputation of science as a highly successful producer of objective truth.

The economist and methodologist J. S. Mill was well aware of the ‘huge difference’ and he papered it over by euphemizing economics as ‘inexact and separate science’. And this goes on to this day whenever economists are confronted with the proof that what they do is storytelling, but not science. There is NO such thing as an inexact and separate science. There are only science and non-science.

For everyone who can read, my argument is that the definition of economics as a social science is the foundational error/mistake. See above: “The crucial point is that economics deals not primarily with individual human behavior or society at large. This is the realm of psychology, sociology, anthropology, history, political science, social philosophy, biology/ Darwinism/evolution theory etcetera.”

So, do not pester me further with bottomless trivialities like: “However, economic systems which deal with production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services are INTIMATELY tied to the socio-cultural norms, which vary by time and by geography.”

Yes, Si, Ja, Oui ... BUT these socio-cultural norms are the subject matter of sociology, anthropology, history etcetera and NOT of economics. The first task of economics is to figure out what profit is, and the fact of the matter is that NO socio-cultural economist has figured it out to this day. This includes blocke and, Asad Zaman and Michael Kowalik and Ken Zimmerman. It is a bit surrealistic when economists who cannot tell what profit is philosophize about economic methodology.

You say: “There are no non-trivial economic axioms which would be equally true in British Colonial India in the 19th century, Nigeria in the 21st, Brazil in the late 20th, and France during the World Wars. By ‘non-trivial’ I mean axioms which provide some insight into the functioning of the economy at the time and place specified.”

I do not make such a brain-dead claim. #1 What I say is this:
(i) The subject matter of economics is the monetary economy. The exchange of cowrie shells for bananas and ALL other precursors of the monetary economy are left to anthropologists/historians.
(ii) The theory of how the monetary economy works is based upon a set of three almost self-evident axioms to which every student with average intelligence can tentatively agree. #2 These axioms are objective-structural and entirely FREE of behavioral assumptions or socio-cultural specifics.
(iii) From this minimalist formal core follow in consistent logical steps theorems, e.g., the Profit Law or the structural Phillips Curve. These (behavior-free/structural/objective) theorems hold for monetary economies of ALL times and places and all variants of property rights. All theorems are readily TESTABLE.
(iv) In these three steps and subsequent differentiation, formally and materially consistent economics is built up. Insights about human nature/behavior/action are taken in from the so-called social sciences IF NEEDED.

Given the failure of Orthodoxy, what Heterodoxy has to do is to come forward with testable propositions about how the economic system works. What neither Heterodoxy nor Orthodoxy can do is to continue storytelling and philosophizing about methodology and to claim that this is science.

The claim that Orthodoxy is pro-capitalist and anti-worker and that Heterodoxy is pro-worker and anti-capitalist is a political argument. But politics and science are different and incommensurable things. Even if the claim is perfectly true, it is IRRELEVANT because it tells us nothing about whether orthodox economic theory or heterodox economic theory is true. In fact, BOTH are logically and materially INCONSISTENT. The proofs are on the table.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke

#1 Check my blog or my working papers first before making a fool of yourself.
#2 How to get rid of the silly Queen

***
REPLY to Michael Kowalik on Jul 5

You say: “I am totally for making theories and empirical research based on consistent axiomatic foundations, but scientific and logical rigour demands disclosure of axioms and not their merely intuitive assumption. This, I believe is the weakest link in the ‘science’ of economics, ...”

It seems that you are not aware that the axioms ARE disclosed, see ‘How to get rid of the silly Queen’. See also my reply to Asad Zaman.

The point is that both the Walrasian and the Keynesian axiom set is provably false. This is why economics has to move from traditional microfoundations and Keynesian macrofoundations to entirely new macrofoundations.

July 3, 2016

What is dead certain in an uncertain world: economists’ abysmal incompetence

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Paul Krugman vs. Mervyn King on Keynes’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Jul 11

Paul Krugman summarizes: “It’s not entirely clear ... why radical uncertainty, not quantifiable risk, is the essence of economic life. Yes, economic forecasts are often grossly wrong; yes, even smart people often have far too much confidence in their ability to assess risks. Every serious economist knows this, yet most don’t consider it sufficient reason to abandon conventional tools of analysis.” (See intro)

This evasive waffling shows one thing: the representative economist has no idea of what economics is and of what science is. First of all, science does NOT ‘predict the future’ simply because, as a genuine scientist said, “The future is unpredictable.” (Feynman, 1992)

What is called prediction in science is categorically different from the commonsensical meaning of ‘predicting the future’. The sole criterion of science is true/false and not predicting the next crash or any other extraordinary event. This is the occupation of prophets, fearmongers, astrologers, gold bugs, and other freaks/swindlers. In marked contrast, science is about invariants or ‘eternal’ laws.

So, scientists do NOT predict when the next apple will fall from the tree. What they indeed predict exactly is position and velocity at any point in time once the apple has started to fall. The commonsenser’s view of reality is entirely DIFFERENT from the scientist’s view. The commonsenser’s view is practical, trivial, and false but utterly convincing for other commonsensers. This is why false worldviews/theories that have no immediate grave negative practical consequences for commonsensers can survive for an indefinite time.

Each falling apple is a unique historical event. There are many causes for an apple to fall: a hailstorm, playing children, an exploding meteorite, material fatigue, an earthquake, and so on. In almost all cases the singular event is uncertain and unpredictable. That is so OBVIOUS that no physicist ever lost many words about the historicity and uncertainty of falling apples.

Accordingly, when the apple fell on Newton’s head* he did NOT discover uncertainty but the common principle that underlies the motion of the apple and the moon, i.e. the Law of Gravity.

Science is NOT AT ALL interested in singular historical events as such but in the underlying invariances (Nozick) or ‘eternal’ laws. Uncertainty refers to historical events, certainty refers to laws. The uncertainty of when and why an apple falls is perfectly reconcilable with the certainty of the Law of Falling Bodies.

Because of this, Keynes’ famous dictum ‘We simply do not know’ is NOT a great revelation for any scientist but proof that Keynes had NO idea of what science is all about. This, of course, holds for all After-Keynesians including Mervyn King and Lars Syll.

The real problem with economics is not commonsensical prediction but that it is NOT a science yet pretends to be one. It is of utmost importance to clearly distinguish between political and theoretical economics. The main differences are: (i) The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda, and the goal of theoretical economics is to successfully explain how the actual economy works. (ii) In political economics anything goes; in theoretical economics, scientific standards are observed.

Theoretical economics has to be judged according to the criteria true/false and NOTHING else. The history of political economics from Adam Smith to Keynes and beyond can be summarized as an utter scientific failure. This includes Krugman but also the whole bunch of heterodox political economists.

Krugman’s manifest scientific incompetence is condensed in his methodological tenet: “… most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.” This means in more detail that he subscribes to this set of foundational propositions, a.k.a. axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub 1985)

Methodologically, these premises are forever unacceptable but economists swallowed them hook, line, and sinker from Jevons/Walras/Menger onward. The failure of methodological individualism and all other psycho/socio approaches can be stated as an impossibility theorem: NO way leads from the explanation of human nature/behavior/action to the explanation of how the economic system works.

There is NO such thing as a behavioral axiom because there is no such thing as a certain, true, and primary (Aristotle) behavioral proposition. The simple fact of the matter is that behavior is not only influenced by uncertainty but is itself the source of uncertainty: “… we might say that the human factor is the ultimately uncertain and wayward element in social life and in all social institutions.” (Popper, 1960)

Because of this, it is methodological idiocy to take behavioral assumptions into the set of axioms. HC1 to HC5 is inadmissible. All models based on this set are worthless.

But things become even worse. Krugman is also a sorta-kinda Keynesian. Unfortunately, Keynesianism too is based on false axioms. Keynes defined the formal core of the General Theory as follows: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.”

This two-liner is defective because Keynes never came to grips with profit: “His Collected Writings show that he wrestled to solve the Profit Puzzle up till the semi-final versions of his GT but in the end he gave up and discarded the draft chapter dealing with it.” (Tómasson et al., 2010)

Let this sink in, Keynes had NO idea of the fundamental concepts of economics, viz. profit, and income. Because profit is ill-defined the whole theoretical superstructure of macroeconomics is false, in particular, ALL I=S/IS-LM models including, of course, Krugman’s.#1

Krugman has not realized during a long career that (i) the neoclassical axioms are false, (ii), that Keynes’ axioms are false, and (iii), that the two axiom sets are formally incompatible ― no ― he senselessly cobbles all this garbage together and derives his policy advice from it. Needless to say, all these gross logical inconsistencies sail smoothly through all peer-reviews into quality journals and textbooks.

Krugman is provably false, Keynes is provably false, Orthodoxy is provably false, Heterodoxy is provably false, and last but not least the profit theory has been false since Adam Smith. After more than 200 years of poor performance, there is no hope at all that economists will ever say anything worthwhile about uncertainty. Methodologically retarded economists let the world know ‘We simply do not know’ and this, indeed, is an unintended true summary of current economics. One thing, at least, is certain: economics is a failed science.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Mr. Keynes, Prof. Krugman, IS-LM, and the End of Economics as We Know It

* It does not matter in the present context that the apple-on-the-head story is, of course, a historical myth.

July 2, 2016

The other half plus the hitherto missing true foundations of macroeconomics

Comment on Richard Koo on ‘The other half of macroeconomics and the three stages of economic development’

Blog-Reference

Richard Koo’s paper about macroeconomic development is descriptively accurate and historically rich in detail. It is far above the low level of familiar orthodox and heterodox economics. What is lacking, though, is a sound theoretical foundation. This cannot be otherwise because economics as a whole lacks sound foundations. There is no longer anything to dispute, BOTH microeconomics and macroeconomics is a scientific failure.

Koo puts it thus: “Macroeconomics is still a very young science compared to such disciplines as physics and chemistry. It started when Keynes began talking about the concept of aggregate demand in the 1930s, only 85 years ago. As a very young science, it has achieved only limited coverage of the broad range of economic phenomena and remains prone to fads and influences.”

Reality is far worse, indeed. Keynes based macroeconomics on logically and conceptually defective foundations and neither Post Keynesians nor New Keynesians nor Anti-Keynesians have realized Keynes’ foundational blunder in 85 years (2011b; 2014).

Keynes defined the formal core of the General Theory as follows: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” (1973, p. 63)

This two-liner is defective because Keynes never came to grips with profit: “His Collected Writings show that he wrestled to solve the Profit Puzzle up till the semi-final versions of his GT but in the end he gave up and discarded the draft chapter dealing with it.” (Tómasson et al., 2010, p. 12)

Let this sink in, Keynes had NO idea of the fundamental concepts of economics, viz. profit and income. Because profit is ill-defined the whole theoretical superstructure of macroeconomics is false, in particular, ALL I=S/IS-LM models (2011a; 2013b).

Koo starts his analysis as follows: “One person’s expenditure is another person’s income. It is this unalterable linkage between the expenditures and incomes of millions of thinking households and businesses that makes the study of the economy both interesting and unique.”

Note that Koo’s first sentence is identical to Keynes’. For every economist, this proposition is pure common sense ― a mere accounting identity. As a matter of fact, it is provably false and this explodes the whole of macroeconomics. Economists do not grasp the elementary mathematics of accounting (2012a) and this goes a long way to explain why economics has never risen above the proto-scientific level.

To get out of failed economic theory requires nothing less than a full-blown paradigm shift from accustomed microfoundations and Keynes’ flawed macrofoundations to entirely new macrofoundations. In other words, the faulty axiomatic foundations of standard economics have to be replaced.

In the following, a sketch* of the formally and empirically correct price, employment, and profit theory is given. The most elementary version of the objective structural Employment Law (2012b) is shown on Graphic AXEC62


From this equation follows:
(i) An increase in the expenditure ratio ρE leads to higher employment (the Greek letter ρ stands for ratio). An expenditure ratio ρE greater than 1 indicates credit expansion, a ratio ρE less than 1 indicates credit contraction.
(ii) Increasing investment expenditures I exert a positive influence on employment; a slowdown of growth does the opposite.
(iii) An increase in the factor cost ratio ρF≡W/PR leads to higher employment.

The complete and testable Employment Law is a bit longer and contains, in addition, profit distribution, public deficit spending, and import/export.

Items (i) and (ii) cover Keynes’ and Koo’s arguments about aggregate demand. What is missing in the Keynesian multiplier is the factor cost ratio ρF as defined in (iii). This variable embodies the price mechanism, which, however, does not work as the representative economist hallucinates. As a matter of fact, overall employment INCREASES if the average wage rate W INCREASES relative to the average price P and productivity R.

For the relationship between real wage, productivity, profit, and real shares, see (2015, Sec. 10)

The correct macroeconomic Profit Law reads Qm ≡ Yd+I−Sm (2014, p. 8, eq. (18)). Legend: Qm monetary profit, Yd distributed profit, Sm monetary saving, I investment expenditure. The interaction of I and Sm underlies Koo’s description of economic expansion and balance sheet recession (2013a). What is entirely missing in Koo’s description is the interaction of Qm and Yd.

The profit equation gets a bit longer when import/export and government are included.

Note that the OVERALL profit and, by consequence, the income distribution have nothing to do with productivity or low wages or market power. These and other factors affect only the DISTRIBUTION of overall profit BETWEEN firms. What holds on the firms’ level does NOT hold for the economy as a WHOLE. Not to realize this is the fatal insufficiency of economists’ feeble-minded ruminations about the relationship between (average) wage rate, price, productivity, and employment.

Keynes’s approach is macrofounded but incomplete because he had no deeper understanding of the profit, the credit, and the price mechanism. Koo’s approach is a clear improvement with regard to the credit mechanism, but shares the fundamental conceptual error that is embodied in this simple proposition: Income = value of output. It is as commonsensical and scientifically false as the sun goes up.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011a). Squaring the Investment Cycle. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1911796: 1–25. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011b). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2012a). The Common Error of Common Sense: An Essential Rectification of the Accounting Approach. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2124415: 1–23. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2012b). Keynes’ Employment Function and the Gratuitous Phillips Curve Disaster. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2130421: 1–19. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2013a). Redemption and Depression. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2343561: 1–28. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2013b). Settling the Theory of Saving. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2220651: 1–23. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). The Three Fatal Mistakes of Yesterday Economics: Profit, I=S, Employment. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2489792: 1–13. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2015). Major Defects of the Market Economy. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2624350: 1–40. URL
Keynes, J. M. (1973). The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Tómasson, G., and Bezemer, D. J. (2010). What is the Source of Profit and Interest? A Classical Conundrum Reconsidered. MPRA Paper, 20557: 1–34. URL

* Students are referred to the working papers on SSRN for all details and the consistent formal underpinning of all assertions