October 29, 2017

How to make economics a science

Comment on Dániel Oláh on ‘If You Look Behind Neoliberal Economists, You’ll Discover the Rich: How Economic Theories Serve Big Business’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

The one question in science is about the truth of a theory, i.e. its material and formal consistency: “In order to tell the politicians and practitioners something about causes and best means, the economist needs the true theory or else he has not much more to offer than educated common sense or his personal opinion.” (Stigum)

Economists do not have the true theory. They have many different opinions but nothing in the way of scientific knowledge. Since the founding fathers, there is political economics and theoretical economics. The main differences are: (i) The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda, and the goal of theoretical economics is to successfully explain how the actual economy works. (ii) In political economics anything goes; in theoretical economics, the scientific standards of material and formal consistency are observed.

The fact is that the agenda pushers of political economics have captured theoretical economics (= science) from the very beginning with the result that economics has produced nothing of scientific value in the last 200+ years.#1 Economics has until this day no scientific truth-value, only some political use-value. This applies not only to Orthodoxy but also to Heterodoxy.

Orthodoxy is defined since Jevons/Walras/Menger by methodological individualism. The neoclassical concretization translates into the following hardcore propositions a.k.a. axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub)

Obviously, this axiom set contains three NONENTITIES: (i) constrained optimization HC2, (ii) rational expectations HC4, (iii) equilibrium HC5. Every theory/model that contains a nonentity is A PRIORI false. As a consequence, the economics of the Walrasian-Arrow-Debreu type and its offspring until DSGE/RBC/New Keynesianism is scientifically worthless.

The wonder of economics is twofold: (i) how can it be that this rather obvious proto-scientific garbage has been swallowed hook, line, and sinker by the majority of every new generation of economists for 150+ years? and (ii), why did heterodox economists during this long time span only come up with repetitive critique but not with something better?#2

What Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy have in common is scientific incompetence and the erroneous belief that economics is a social science.#3 The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent, and all got the foundational concept of the subject matter ― profit ― wrong.

Economics is one of the most embarrassing scientific failures of all time and the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel” is either an absurd self-delusion or a deliberate deception of the general public.#4

Since the founding fathers, economists violate the principle of the separation of science and politics. Economics is what Feynman famously called a cargo cult science and neither right-wing nor left-wing economic policy guidance has sound scientific foundations since the soapbox economists Adam Smith and Karl Marx.

In order that economics becomes a science, the following steps have to be taken:
• a public declaration that economics is a failed science,
• the abolition of the fake Nobel,
• the unceremonious shredding of Econ 101 textbooks,
• the strict institutional separation of science and politics,
• the eviction of all political economists from science,
• the Paradigm Shift from false Walrasian microfoundations and false Keynesian macrofoundations to correct macrofoundations.

It is high time that economics frees itself from the all-pervasive and all-corrupting grip of political agenda pushers. New Economic Thinking does not consist of more lipstick on the dead pig but of the long-overdue Paradigm Shift.#5

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 For details of the big picture see cross-references Failed/Fake Scientists
#2 The stupidity of Heterodoxy is the life insurance of Orthodoxy
#3 A social science is NOT a science but a sitcom
#4 The economics Cargo Cult Prize
#5 This is New Economic Thinking? Give me a break!

Related 'Show first your economic axioms or get out of the discussion' and 'Economists: scientists or political clowns?' and 'Replacing sand with granite' and 'Basics of monetary theory: the two monies'. For details of the big picture see cross-references Political Economics and cross-references Axiomatization and cross-references Paradigm Shift.

October 28, 2017

Lethal criticism of economics? Here it is!

Comment on Cameron Murray on ‘Decent criticisms of economics? Here are 111 of them.’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

Economists are scientifically incompetent. In colloquial terms, both orthodox and heterodox economists are stupid or corrupt or both.

Economics is a failed science for 200+ years. The four main approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/formally inconsistent, and all got the pivotal concept of the subject matter ― profit ― wrong. With the pluralism of provably false theories, economics is what Feynman called a cargo cult science.#1

What the representative economist does not understand until this day is that economics is NOT a science of behavior and that both Walrasian microfoundations and Keynesian macrofoundations are false.#2 Methodologically it holds: if it isn’t properly macro-axiomatized, it isn’t economics at all.#3

The decent criticism of economics is insufficient and counterproductive: “The moral of the story is simply this: it takes a new theory, and not just the destructive exposure of assumptions or the collection of new facts, to beat an old theory.” (Blaug)#4

Economics is a failed science and incompetent critics like fresh-thinker Murray are an essential ingredient of the mess.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Economics: 200+ years of scientific incompetence and fraud
#2 For details of the big picture see cross-references Failed/Fake scientists
#3 Ten steps to leave cargo cult economics behind for good
#4 The stupidity of Heterodoxy is the life insurance of Orthodoxy

October 26, 2017

Note on Edward Fullbrook’s My evening with Joan Robinson and the Tractatus

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference


Egmont Kakarot-Handtke

Basics of monetary theory: the two monies

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘INET conferencing beyond disappointment’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference on Oct 30

Frances Coppola tweeted on Oct 25, “He [Pontus Rendahl] says (I quote) ‘Banks can’t create money or we wouldn’t have had to bail them out.’ What’s the fallacy in that statement, Twitter?”

And Ann Pettifor echoed: “Pontus Rendahl disagrees banks can create money. Only true if CB complicit with this’ Extraordinary! We do not live in CB dictatorship.”

Lars Syll assisted, “And to even for a second think that a visionless neoclassical economist like Rendahl should have anything to do with new thinking in economics is of course totally gobsmacking!”

Time to finally settle the theory of money.

Because economics is a failed science, it has to be reconstructed from scratch. Walrasian microfoundations and Keynesian macrofoundations have to be scrapped.

As the new analytical starting point, the pure production-consumption economy is defined with this set of macroeconomic axioms: (A0) The objectively given and most elementary configuration of the economy consists of the household and the business sector, which in turn consists initially of one giant fully integrated firm. (A1) Yw=WL wage income Yw is equal to wage rate W times working hours. L, (A2) O=RL output O is equal to productivity R times working hours L, (A3) C=PX consumption expenditure C is equal to price P times quantity bought/sold X.

Under the conditions of market-clearing X=O and budget-balancing C=Yw in each period, the price is given by P=W/R, i.e., the market-clearing price is equal to unit wage costs. This is the most elementary form of the macroeconomic Law of Supply and Demand. For the graphical representation, see Figure 1. #1


The price is determined by the wage rate, which takes the role of the nominal numéraire, and productivity. The quantity of money is NOT among the price determinants. This puts the commonplace Quantity Theory forever to rest.

Monetary profit for the economy as a whole is defined as Qm≡C−Yw, and monetary saving as Sm≡Yw-C. It always holds Qm≡−Sm, in other words, the business sector’s surplus = profit (deficit = loss) equals the household sector’s deficit = dissaving (surplus = saving). This is the most elementary form of the Profit Law. Under the condition of budget-balancing total monetary profit is zero.

What is needed for a start is two things: (i) a central bank which creates money on its balance sheet in the form of deposits, and (ii) a legal system which declares the central bank’s deposits as legal tender.

Deposit money is needed by the business sector to pay the workers who receive the wage income Yw per period. The need is only temporary because the business sector gets the money back if the workers fully spend their income, i.e., if C=Yw.

Overdrafts are needed by the household sector for consumption expenditures if the households want to spend before they get their income. This time sequence is no problem for the central bank because the temporary overdrafts vanish with wage payments.

For the case of a balanced budget C=Yw, the idealized transaction sequence of deposits/overdrafts of the household sector at the central bank over the course of one period is shown in Figure 2. #2


The household sector’s deposits/overdrafts are zero at the beginning and end of the period. The business sector’s transaction pattern is the exact mirror image. Money, that is, deposits at the central bank, is continually created and destroyed during the period under consideration. There is NO such thing as a fixed quantity of money. The central bank plays an accommodative role and simply supports the autonomous market transactions between the household and the business sector.

From this follows the average stock of transaction money as M=κYw, with κ determined by the transaction pattern. In other words, the average stock of money M is determined by the autonomous transactions of the household and business sector and created out of nothing by the central bank. The economy NEVER runs out of money.

The transaction equation reads M=κYw=κPX=κPRL in the case of budget balancing and market clearing, and this yields the commonplace correlation between the average stock of money M and price P for a given employment and productivity level, except for the fact that M is the dependent variable.

Money comes into existence on the balance sheet of the central bank as soon as the central bank enters an overdraft for the business sector on the asset side and a deposit of an equal amount on the liability side (step 1). This deposit is then transferred to the household sector as wage payment (step 2) and returns in the form of consumption expenditures (step 3). For the graphical representation of the complete cycle, see Figure 3. #3


Now, commercial banks are introduced. They can create and destroy ‘money’ technically exactly in the same way as the central bank, except for the fact that it is bank money and not central bank money. The crucial condition for the functioning of the two-monies system is that the business sector and household sector accept bank money as practically identical to central bank money. For a graphical representation, it is only necessary to change the account titles in Figure 3 from Central bank to Commercial banks.

What happens if the households that possess money in the form of bank deposits (step 1 in Figure 4, #4) demand real = central bank money?


The commercial banking sector has to turn to the central bank, which creates overdrafts and deposits out of nothing (2). In the last step (3) the commercial banks then transfer their central bank deposits to the households. The banking money vanishes completely from the system. This does, in principle, not hinder the commercial banks from creating new bank money by handing out loans in various forms, from overdrafts to long-term mortgage loans. This quantitative expansion, though, can be limited in various ways.

Conclusion: Pontus Rendahl is right, banks cannot create money only bank money, which is, in normal times, and for all practical purposes, functionally identical to central bank money. However, if the household or business sector demands money, the commercial banks have to turn to the central bank because, in the final analysis, the modern monetary system consists of two tightly coupled monies. As always, the “new” thinkers Frances Coppola, Ann Pettifor, and Lars Syll have made blogging fools of themselves.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Graphic AXEC31 Elementary production-consumption economy
#2 Graphic AXEC98 Idealized transaction pattern, household sector, balanced budget
#3 Graphic AXEC114 Creation and destruction of transaction money at the central bank
#4 Graphic AXEC115 Switch from bank money to central bank money

Related 'Essentials of Constructive Heterodoxy: Money, Credit, Interest' and 'Reconstructing the Quantity Theory (I)' and 'Everything you know about MMT is wrong'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references MMT.

***
Cross-posting on Oct 30

In her Guardian article ‘How the actual magic money tree works’ Zoe Williams repeats the argument that banks can create money. The fact is that banks cannot create money only bank money. This has been explained in detail already to other silly journalists and stupid economists in the following post.

***
COMMENT on Tom Hickey on Oct 31

You say: “What is at issue is the operation of a monetary production economy, that is, how finance, which is concerned with financial instruments, and economics. which is concerned with real resources, interacts. Even most economists don’t understand this. How can the public?”

True. The task of economists is to explain how the actual monetary economy works ― not less, not more. But to this day, economists (Walrasians, Keynesians, Marxians, Austrians, and Pluralists) have no idea how the economy works; that is, they lack the true theory.

Why is economics a scientific failure/fraud? Because economists never had the intellectual capacity or the time to do proper science. What they were busily occupied with instead was political agenda-pushing. Agenda pushing is the natural choice for morons because one needs only an opinion, a big flap, and some acting talent. #1

Neil Wilson demonstrates here for everyone to see how easy it is to derail science by switching to politics: “And the hot button political issues have little or nothing to do with money.” André and Calgacus immediately jump on the bandwagon by telling their Bad Guy story. Thus, the whole discussion of what Keynes called the ‘monetary theory of production’ degenerates into a Pavlovian exchange of age-old political crap. It is the same pattern on all levels of economic discussion. There is no scientific substance in Krugman, Kelton, and Hickey, and all the rest.

What the representative economist has not realized in 200+ years is that politics is NOT his business: “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.” (J. S. Mill)

From an economist, society expects scientific knowledge of how the actual economy works, just as it expects from engineers all the scientific knowledge that is necessary to get a huge metallic construct against gravity off the ground.

Economists have no such knowledge. They have wasted 200+ years since Adam Smith and Karl Marx with political blathering and agenda-pushing. MMT is no exception.#3 Economics is a scientific failure/fraud, and MMT is part of it.

#1 For details, see cross-references Political Economics/Stupidity/Corruption
#2 For details, see cross-references Failed/Fake scientists
#3 For details, see cross-references MMT

***
REPLY to Tom Hickey on Nov 1

You say: “MMT shows how finance and economics overlap and interact interdependently in a monetary production economy. It is a continuation of the analysis of a modern monetary production economy that Keynes initiated explicitly, although it was implicit in classical economics. Neoclassical economics ignored the monetary aspect in focusing on a barter economy and viewing the monetary aspect as a neutral veil that was useful in resolving the necessity for ‘double coincidence of wants’ in a pure barter system.”

It is true, of course, that orthodox economics in general and orthodox monetary theory, in particular, is provably false yet at the same time insufficient: “The moral of the story is simply this: it takes a new theory, and not just the destructive exposure of assumptions or the collection of new facts, to beat an old theory.” (Blaug)

In other words, orthodox economics has to be fully replaced, in methodological terms, economics needs a paradigm shift, in technical terms, the neoclassical axioms have to be fully replaced, and ALL of economics has to be reconstructed based on consistent macrofoundations.

Keynes initiated the move from microfoundations to macrofoundations but failed. He failed because he did not understand macroeconomic profit: “His Collected Writings show that he wrestled to solve the Profit Puzzle up till the semi-final versions of his GT but in the end he gave up and discarded the draft chapter dealing with it.” (Tómasson et al.)

This failure not only proves the utter scientific incompetence of Keynes but also of those who came before and after him. Economists do to this very day not understand the foundational concept of their subject matter. This means that ALL economic policy guidance since Adam Smith and Karl Marx is misleading, disastrous, or at best ineffective.

This is well-known among heads of state. Napoleon claimed “… that he had always believed that if an empire were made of granite the ideas of economists if listened to, would suffice to reduce it to dust.” (Viner) Because of this, politicians do not take economists seriously; they employ them as useful idiots.

MMT profit theory, as embodied in the balances equations, is false, and by consequence, the whole theoretical superstructure is false, and by consequence, MMT economic policy has no sound scientific foundations, just like neoliberal policy, Keynesian policy, and Marxian policy.

What the spokespersons of MMT, Mitchell, Tcherneva, Mosler, Wray, Kelton, Fullwiler, Forstater, Kaboub, Hickey, etc., are in effect doing is political agenda pushing without one jot of scientific competence. And, clearly, it is NOT the agenda of We-the-people.

October 24, 2017

Economics: Stories, narratives, and disinformation

Comment on David Glasner on ‘The Standard Narrative on the History of Macroeconomics: An Exercise in Self-Serving Apologetics’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

Keynes has to be credited for realizing that the economics of Jevons/Walras/Menger/ Marshall was false at its core and that nothing less than a Paradigm Shift was needed: “The [neo-]classical theorists resemble Euclidean geometers in a non-Euclidean world who, discovering that in experience straight lines apparently parallel often meet, rebuke the lines for not keeping straight ― as the only remedy for the unfortunate collisions which are occurring. Yet, in truth, there is no remedy except to throw over the axiom of parallels and to work out a non-Euclidean geometry. Something similar is required to-day in economics.”

After Keynes, every economist who still does not see the necessity of a Paradigm Shift is simply scientifically incompetent. One spokesperson of this prevailing majority is Krugman, who debunks himself with: “… most of what I and many others do is sorta-kinda neoclassical because it takes the maximization-and-equilibrium world as a starting point.”

The fact is that maximization-and-equilibrium economics has already been dead in the cradle 150+ years ago.

Keynes, though, messed up the shift from microfoundations to macrofoundations. His lethal blunder can be exactly located in the GT: “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” (p. 63) This elementary syllogism is conceptually and logically defective because Keynes never came to grips with profit. (Tómasson et al.)

Because profit is ill-defined, the whole analytical superstructure of Keynesianism is false.#1 Yet one of the outstanding characteristics of the cargo cult science economics is that refutation is persistently ignored: “In economics we should strive to proceed, wherever we can, exactly according to the standards of the other, more advanced, sciences, where it is not possible, once an issue has been decided, to continue to write about it as if nothing had happened.” (Morgenstern)

As a result of the continuous violation of scientific standards, the history of economic thought boils down to a narrative of incompetence, failure, self-deception, and lame excuses.#2 What we have today is the pluralism of provably false theories.

After-Keynesians never realized Keynes’ foundational blunder and thereby became part of the abysmal failure of what was meant as a Paradigm Shift.#3, #4 Neither DSGEers nor Post Keynesians up to MMT can define macroeconomic profit until this very day.

Science is indeed the search for invariances (Nozick), a.k.a. laws. In economics, though, the invariances are NOT in Human Nature/motives/behavior/action but in the properties of the economic system. Because of this, economics has to move from subjective-behavioral microfoundations to objective-systemic macrofoundations.#5 Nothing less than a Paradigm Shift will do, and it is overdue for 150+ years. It holds: If it isn’t macro-axiomatized, it isn’t economics.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 How Keynes got macro wrong and Allais got it right
#2 Failed economics: The losers’ long list of lame excuses
#3 Why Post Keynesianism Is Not Yet a Science
#4 Heterodoxy, too, is proto-scientific garbage
#5 Ten steps to leave cargo cult economics behind for good

Related 'Narrative economics and the imperatives of the sitcom' and 'How the representative economist gets it wrong big-time' and 'United in the social science delusion' and 'Macroeconomics and the fake History of Economic Thought' and 'Econogenics in action' and 'Econogenics: economists pose a hazard to their fellow citizens' and 'Circus Maximus: Economics as entertainment, personality gossip, virtue signaling, and lifestyle promotion' and Ch. 13, The indelible scientific disgrace of economics, in Sovereign Economics.

***

Graphic AXEC112a Basic Laws of the elementary production-consumption economy


Everything you know about MMT is wrong

Comment on Bill Mitchell and Thomas Fazi/Social Europe on ‘Everything You Know About Neoliberalism Is Wrong’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

There is the political sphere, and there is the scientific sphere. It is quite obvious that both are fundamentally different, and because of this, it is of utmost importance to radically separate the two. The mixing of the two has been the crippling defect of economics since the founding fathers propagated Political Economy.

The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda; the goal of theoretical economics (= science) is to successfully explain how the actual economy works. In political economics, anything goes; in theoretical economics, the scientific standards of material and formal consistency are observed.

The fact is that the political agenda pushers have hijacked economics and messed it up. Political economics has produced nothing of scientific value in the last 200+ years.

MMT, too, violates the first rule of science, i.e., the strict separation of politics and science. This rule is known since J. S. Mill: “A scientific observer or reasoner, merely as such, is not an adviser for practice. His part is only to show that certain consequences follow from certain causes, and that to obtain certain ends, certain means are the most effectual. Whether the ends themselves are such as ought to be pursued, and if so, in what cases and to how great a length, it is no part of his business as a cultivator of science to decide, and science alone will never qualify him for the decision.”

Needless to emphasize that all economic schools violate this rule and are in the business of agenda-pushing. This is why economics is a failed science, or what Feynman called a cargo cult science.

So, it is not the question of whether what Mitchell/Fazi say about sovereignty and the role of the nation-state is convincing or not. The point is that all questions about the realization of the Good Society have to be discussed and decided in the political sphere. When economists start to talk about liberty and democracy and liberalism and free markets and state intervention and the road to serfdom/freedom, they are exceeding their scientific authority and becoming clowns in the political Circus Maximus.

The really bad fact of the matter is that economists should be able to tell how the actual economy works, yet they are not. The major approaches ― Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, Austrianism ― are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, materially/ formally inconsistent, and ALL got the foundational concept of the subject matter ― profit ― wrong. MMT is no exception.

MMT claims on Wikipedia: “Therefore, budget deficits add net financial assets to the private sector; whereas budget surpluses remove financial assets from the private sector. This is widely represented in macroeconomic theory by the national income identity: G−T=S−I−NX where G is government spending, T is tax, S is savings, I is investment, and NX is net exports.”#1

For G, T, NX = 0, this equation boils down to Keynes’ famous I=S. The remarkable fact is that neither MMT’s national income identity nor Keynes’ basic formalism says anything about the pivotal economic magnitude profit.#2 It should be obvious that a model/theory which does not explicitly contain the variable profit is a priori false. After all, the concept of profit is for economics what the concept of energy is for physics. So, there is no need at all to occupy oneself with the rest of the theoretical superstructure of MMT. The fundamental methodological rule says that if there is an inconsistency in the premises/axioms, the whole theory is scientifically worthless.

The axiomatically correct balances equation reads Qm≡G−T+I−S+NX, with Qm as monetary profit. And from it follows directly Public Deficit = Private Profit. The preferred policy measure of MMT, i.e., deficit spending, is in effect a profit booster program.

Exactly at this point, the political agenda pushing sets in. MMT never talks about the profit of the business sector but says “budget deficits add net financial assets to the private sector” suggesting that private sector = household sector = ninety-nine percenters. #3 In fact private sector = business sector = one-percenters.

With the argument that deficit spending in the form of a Job Guarantee or other social benefits “add net financial assets to the private sector” MMT tries to sell its policy to socialist movements like Sanders/Corbyn.

MMT is NOT a new economic paradigm but political agenda pushing for the one-percenters in a social bluff package. #4 This holds for all of economics: when profit is false, the whole theoretical superstructure is false, and economic policy guidance has NO sound scientific foundations. MMT is political economics = proto-scientific garbage.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Wikipedia Modern Monetary Theory
#2 How Keynes got macro wrong and Allais got it right
#3 MMT and the magical profit disappearance
#4 For the full-spectrum refutation of MMT, see cross-references MMT

***

Graphic AXEC118d Sectoral Balances: False = MMT, True = AXEC


***

ICYMI on billy blog 'When the mainstream Left gets lost down its Europhile hole' on Oct 28
Everything you know about MMT is wrong

October 22, 2017

How the representative economist gets it wrong big-time

Comment on Barkley Rosser on ‘Remembering Black Monday’

Blog-Reference

Barkley Rosser summarizes: “One other outcome of Black Monday also was that it was the beginning of the end for the dominance in economic theory of the rational expectations axiom. Yes, it is still around and strong in the whole DSGE modeling world. But increasingly people take more behavioral assumptions seriously, and Black Monday was a body blow to ratex big time.”

Economics has been a failed science for 200+ years. How does this cargo cult science survive nonetheless? An important ingredient of the time-tested survival strategy of incompetent scientists is to readily admit and superficially fix striking defects in the so-called protective belt in order to save the methodological core. Let us call this the epicycle stratagem because it was by adding epicycle after epicycle that the geocentrists tried to postpone the final admission of empirical and logical refutation.

Economists have always been incompetent scientists, but managed to cover it vis-à-vis the general public with some skill in the application of what Popper called immunizing stratagems.

The inevitable failure of economics started with Jevons/Walras/Menger but was officially institutionalized much later by Arrow with this methodological specification: “It is a touchstone of accepted economics that all explanations must run in terms of the actions and reactions of individuals. Our behavior in judging economic research, in peer review of papers and research, and in promotions, includes the criterion that, in principle, the behavior we explain and the policies we propose are explicable in terms of individuals, not of other social categories.”

The neoclassical concretization of methodological individualism translates into the following hardcore propositions a.k.a. axioms: “HC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.” (Weintraub)

Obviously, this axiom set contains three NONENTITIES: (i) constrained optimization HC2, (ii) rational expectations HC4, (iii) equilibrium HC5. Every theory/model that contains a nonentity is A PRIORI false. By consequence, the economics of the Arrow-Debreu type and its offspring until DSGE/RBC/New Keynesianism are scientifically worthless.

The economist’s immunizing stratagem consists of admitting the most blatant defect but adhering to the paradigm of methodological individualism. One example is the replacement of the obviously idiotic behavioral axioms of constrained optimization and rational expectations by something more commonsensical, which is readily provided by Behavioral Economics. It should be obvious that Behavioral Economics is not a new paradigm but just another version of methodological individualism as defined by Arrow. #1

One of the loudest proponents of the proto-scientific approach of Behavioral Economics is Barkley Rosser and his buddies in the econblogosphere. #2 What these folks do not understand is that economics is NOT a science of behavior and that if it isn’t macro-axiomatized, it isn’t economics at all. #3

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 See also Joan Robinson and the early death of Behavioral Economics
#2 Rather weird examples of Behavioral Economics are The Case of the Spitting Legionnaire and Why I Lack Sympathy For The Catalan/Catalunyan Independence Movement, and many others at EconoSpeak
#3 For details of the big picture, see cross-references Failed/Fake Scientists

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Oct 23

Most people/economists have no proper understanding of what economics is all about. Therefore, it is, first of all, of utmost importance to distinguish between political and theoretical economics. The main differences are: (i) The goal of political economics is to successfully push an agenda; the goal of theoretical economics is to successfully explain how the actual economy works. (ii) In political economics, anything goes; in theoretical economics, the scientific standards of material and formal consistency are observed.

Theoretical economics has to be judged according to the criteria true/false, with truth well-defined as material and formal consistency. Political economics has produced NOTHING of scientific value in the last 200+ years. The four major approaches — Walrasianism, Keynesianism, Marxianism, and Austrianism — are mutually contradictory, axiomatically false, and materially/formally inconsistent. Economics is a failed science, but economists award themselves the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel” (note the brain-dead plural).

The political agenda pushing of orthodox and heterodox economists normally comes in the form of a verbal/formal model/theory that pretends to satisfy scientific criteria. This, of course, is what Feynman called cargo cult science.#1 However, soapbox economists like you and Sandwichman do not even care about pretending to do science but vomit their political agenda directly into the econblogosphere.

To argue that you have done this already at the predecessor of this blog does not make things better but worse. It proves only that the scientific self-governance never worked in economics. #2

You are right in assuming that I do not discuss the crash of 1987 with you. #3 For cargo cult scientists who have until this day not realized that constrained optimization, rational expectations, supply-demand-equilibrium, Arrow-Debreu economics up to DSGE, Behavioral Economics, Keynesian I=S, Post Keynesianism up to MMT, is proto-scientific garbage, and who, after 200+ years, still do not understand what profit is there is only one message: get out of the way.


# 1 Krugman is a case in point, see Mr. Keynes, Prof. Krugman, IS-LM, and the End of Economics as We Know It
#2 For the perversion of peer review, see Heckman Publishing and Promotion in Economics: The Curse of the Top Five
#3 For the correct economic crash theory, see Mathematical Proof of the Breakdown of Capitalism

***
REPLY to Anonymous on Oct 24

BloombergView writes: “Economists have come to rival even journalists and politicians in lack of public esteem. That might be partly because so many economists seem as interested in journalism and politics as in advancing their science. But there’s also a deeper problem: Far from advancing, the science of economics has been going backwards.”

The article is titled ‘Why Not Make Economics a Science?’ Hmm, stupid folks at Bloomberg! Have they never heard of the “Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel”? Take notice of the plural, Bloomberg editors: economics is already sciences not merely science.

Obviously, someone is taking the general public for a ride; is it the journalists or the ‘Nobel’ committee?

To make economics a science presupposes the eviction of all failed/fake scientists and political blatherers like you, Sandwichman, and Barkley Rosser. You complain that this is not very polite. That is true, but misses the point.

Here is Schumpeter’s good advice for all complainers: “Remember: occasionally, it may be an interesting question to ask why a man says what he says; but whatever the answer, it does not tell us anything about whether what he says is true or false.”

Refute my post above if you can, but spare the world the horrors of your ruminations about politeness.

***
REPLY to Barkley Rosser on Oct 25

You say: “… you have said nothing you have not said a thousand times previously in your now two new posts above.”

Even you, in your utter confusion, should understand that to repeat a thousand times 2+2=4 does not make it false. Physicists have repeated the Law of the Lever for more than 2000 years, and it is still true. To repeat a thousand times the statement of fact that Barkley Rosser is a scientifically incompetent political agenda pusher does not alter the fact.

You hallucinate: “I have refuted these arguments many times and am not going to waste peoples’ time by indulging you with more refutations, …”

My argument is that the profit theory is false since Adam Smith. #1 The axiomatically correct macroeconomic relationships are:
  • Qm≡−Sm in the case of the elementary production-consumption economy,
  • Qm≡I−Sm in the case of the investment economy,
  • Qm≡(I−Sm)+Yd+(G−T)+(X−M) in the general case.
Legend: Qm monetary profit, Sm monetary saving, I investment expenditures, Yd distributed profit, G government expenditures, T taxes, X export, M import.

You say, “I have refuted these arguments many times”. Fact is (i) that you have NOT refuted them once, and (ii) that you have blathered your lifetime about economics without understanding the pivotal concept of the subject matter.


#1 For details and sources, see cross-references Profit