October 29, 2015

Stop knowing nothing, start knowing something

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Macroeconomic uncertainty’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

Imagine for a moment that there is one world economy, and the government consists, as Plato dreamed, of wise philosophers. There is — unfortunately, the government does not understand why — a grave problem: unemployment is rising. Understandably, this crisis shatters the faith in the economic advisers who hitherto all came from the orthodox school.

So, the Minister for Economic Affairs calls for a heterodox economist, and he speaks thus: “You know, Lars, we are unhappy with our previous economic advisers, and we have heard that you criticize these DSGE guys for several years now in no uncertain terms. It seems you know better. Are you prepared to help us to solve our current problem?

“Yes, of course, Phil but let me tell you something important about Heterodoxy first: we do not believe that we have access to this mythical Holy Grail, the data-generating process.”

“Hm, what does this mean?”

“It means that we simply do not know. We know this since Keynes' Treatise on Probability of 1921. We know, for example, that we cannot predict the rate of interest 20 years hence.”

“No problem, I talked the other day to this physicist Feynman and guess what he told me: The future is unpredictable. I understand quite well that only folks like soothsayers, astrologers, stock market gurus, fear-mongers, or prophets make predictions.”

“Yes, this is the core message of Heterodoxy: neither the economist nor the deciding individual can fully pre-specify how people will decide when facing uncertainties and ambiguities that are ontological facts of the way the world works.”

“I understand, it's ontological, ignoramus et ignorabimus as du Bois-Reymond always said. But this physicist could at least tell me how the Quarks and the Universe works. Seems he believed more in Hilbert, the axiomatist.” #1

“Heterodoxy is different, you know, we do not lull us into the comforting thought that we know everything and that everything is measurable and we have everything under control. We just admit that we often simply do not know and that we have to live with that uncertainty as well as it goes.”

“That is indeed quite honest. Like good old Socrates: I know that I know nothing.”

“Yes, and telling this truth is dangerous. Remember, the Athenians poisoned him.”

“Yes, afterward, he became the patron saint of all know-nothings. But let us put Socrates aside, he was a gossiping sitcom sophist, not a scientist.”

“He could be regarded as a forerunner of Keynesianism. After all, he was well aware that many activities, relations, processes, and events are of the Keynesian uncertainty-type.”

“I think I understand uncertainty now, but is there anything heterodox economists know beyond this?”

“Yes, of course, fooling people into believing that one can cope with an unknown economic future is a sure recipe for only one thing — economic catastrophe!”

“That's indeed a bold prediction! But, frankly, Lars, I expected that you could help us to prevent a catastrophe. Let me put it more precisely: we have rising unemployment, and some economists say that the wage rate must be lowered, others say it must be raised. #2 What, as a spokesperson of the heterodox school, is your take on this age-old chestnut?”

“As Keynes said: we simply do not know, and it is better to be vaguely right than precisely wrong.”

“And this was already in 1921, and it is still true.”

“You got it, Phil!”

“Yes, Orthodoxy means knowing nothing, and Heterodoxy means being proud of knowing nothing.”

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 Wikipedia
#2 The average wage rate must rise, see No future for the representative economist

Related 'What makes economics a failed science?' and 'Economics is not a science, not a religion, but proto-scientific rubbish' and 'Economists: scientists or political clowns?' and 'Economics and the Fallacy of Insufficient Abstraction' and 'Morons on math' and 'The Prophets of Preemptive Vanitization' and 'The philosophy of know-nothingers' and 'Heterodoxy’s scientific self-burial' and 'Scientists and science actors'. For details of the big picture, see cross-references Paradigm Shift.

***

ICYMI (comment on Jan Milch of Nov 4 on Nov 5)

Lars Syll’s heterodox methodology shares the common-sense intuition that economics belongs to the social sciences and that human behavior is the first and foremost issue. This is a methodological cul-de-sac. In order to leave Orthodoxy alone behind the curve, Heterodoxy needs a methodologically superior approach. For details, see the following posts.

► The Science-of-Man fallacy
► From PsySoc to SysHum
► Getting out of proto-scientific garbage
► PsySoc — the scourge of economics
► Redefining economics

You say “... when it comes to the Core-thinking in Economics (and other social sciences) I sadly can’t say much more than that it’s been more of regression than progress, with few exceptions for much too long.”

Yes, and here are the reasons why, see Are economists methodological retards?


***

Graphic AXEC106m


October 28, 2015

Accounting basics

Comment on FedUp of Oct 24 on ‘Keynes on the Theory of Interest’

Blog-Reference

The most elementary economy is the production-consumption economy, and it consists of the business and household sectors. For a start, the business sector produces and sells one consumption good.

First period: the business sector pays 100 units of wages to the household sector, and the household sector spends exactly this amount on the consumption good. There is no saving of the household sector. The business sector's profit is zero, and the price of the consumption good is equal to unit wage costs, i.e., P=W/R.

Second period: the household sector saves 10 units (S=10) and spends 90 units. Now, the business sector makes a loss (Q=−10). The market-clearing price is lower than unit wage costs.

Accounting result: saving=loss [Q≡–S]. The complementary notion of saving is not investment but loss. Because of this, I=S never holds. And because of this, the whole discussion of whether the interest rate or the income mechanism establishes the equilibrium/equality of saving and investment is pointless. There is no such thing as equilibrium.

At the Central Bank's balance sheet, we have at the end of the 2nd period 10 units of current deposits of the household sector and an equal amount of current overdrafts of the business sector. Without going further into details, it should be obvious that the rate of interest on the asset side and the rate of interest on the liability side must be such that their difference covers at least the costs of the central bank under the condition of zero profit.

This is how the accounting identity and the two rates of interest are objectively connected in the most elementary case. There is no need at all for the silly psycho-sociological filibuster about liquidity preference, animal spirits, or ‘comfort and confidence that individuals derive from holding money in the face of an uncertain and unknown future’. No way leads from behavioral storytelling to the understanding of how the monetary economy works. Standard economics — Keynesianism included — is in the woods and will be left there.

For a more detailed depiction of the accounting relationships, see The Profit Law.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Related 'Interest and profit' and 'End of confusion' and 'I=S: Mark of the Incompetent'.

***

ICYMI (comment on Henry of Oct 28 on Oct 29)

Total wage income Yw is 100 in period 1, and consumption expenditures C are 100. Saving S≡Yw−C is zero.

Total wage income Yw is 100 in period 2, and consumption expenditures C are 90. Saving S≡Yw−C is 10. Profit Q≡C−Yw is −10.

Accounting check: the balances of both sectors add up to zero S+Q=0.

Q.E.D
***

ICYMI (comment on djb of Oct 29)

Analysis starts with the minimum number of elementary propositions. This is known since the ancient Greeks invented science: “When the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.” #1

When you come clear with saving, investment, and profit, then the growth of real and nominal wealth emerges immediately as a result. Wealth cannot be assumed as given but must be derived from the most elementary economic configuration with zero wealth.

Keynes started from faulty premises, and because of this, the conclusion I=S is provably false. History from Keynes onwards, though, has shown that proper methodology is beyond the mental capacities of the representative economist. There is no hope for the present generation of economists (in particular for Henry, JKH, djb).

Nevertheless, for the consistent derivation of wealth, see the working paper Primary and Secondary Markets


#1 Wikipedia, resume of Aristotle’s Posterior Analytics

***

ICYMI (comment on MarkanKone of Oct 28)

The introduction of distributed/retained profit and the redefinition of saving cannot rescue I=S. No semantic maneuver can. I have clarified this case in Section 17 of the working paper Keynes’s Missing Axioms.
***

ICYMI (comment on FedUp of Oct 29)

Keynesian economics is about the monetary production economy: “The entrepreneur economy was one of Keynes’ ways of showing how and why monetary and financial matters must be integrated with real factors from the start of the analysis of a monetary production economy. It is this insight that is missing from virtually all strands of modern mainstream theory.” (Harcourt, 2010, p. 49)

The most elementary monetary production economy consists of the business and the household sector. Your two-person exchange example is obviously no acceptable representation of Keynes’s approach.

Here is a picture of the most elementary monetary production-consumption economy (Graphic AXEC31).


References
Harcourt, G. C. (2010). The Crisis in Mainstream Economics. real-world economics review, (53): 47–51. URL.

***

ICYMI (comment on Henry of Oct 29, 2:44 pm)

Sales, as seen from the business sector, are the same thing as consumption expenditures, as seen from the household sector.

In period 2, we have 90−100=−10 (not 0).

In the elementary production-consumption economy, the business sector cannot recoup its wage costs if the household sector saves. This is how loss comes into the world.

***

ICYMI (comment on Henry of Oct 29, 3:29 pm)

This is not a matter of definition but of hard, cold cash. The household sector spends C=90 units as consumption expenditures, and the business sector receives exactly this amount but calls it sales. This in no way affects the definition of monetary profit Qm≡C−Yw. Together with the definition of monetary saving Sm≡Yw−C, this gives Qm≡−Sm (or simplified Q≡−S if the distinction between monetary/ nonmonetary is not an issue). Look at the formulas and forget the names. It is the formal proof that counts and nothing else.
***

ICYMI (comment on Henry of Oct 29, 4:49 pm)

The accounting approach deals with variables that are the product of price and quantity, like expenditure or income. Normally, it is not necessary to deal with each component of the product individually. Here, it is indeed necessary because you fetch inventory investment out of thin air. Inventory changes occur if the quantity produced and the quantity sold are different.

So let us look closer at consumption expenditures, which are given as the product of price and quantity, i.e., C=PX. We start with the case of full market clearing, that is, quantity produced and quantity sold are equal and do not change because labor input and productivity do not change either. That is, the real part of the pure consumption economy is frozen.

Now, if consumption expenditures C drop from 100 to 90 in period 2 and the quantity X remains constant, the price P must fall in C=PX. The market-clearing price in period 2 is now below the unaltered unit wage costs, and this means that the zero profit of period 1 turns into a loss.

Note that the quantities produced and sold are equal in both periods 1 and 2. So there is no change in inventory, and therefore inventory investment does not occur. We have I=0 and S=10, so saving and investment are unequal.

Of course, the product market is normally not cleared, and there are inventory changes. I have dealt with this case in full generality in Primary and Secondary Markets.

The inclusion of inventory changes, though, does not alter the fact that saving and investment are never equal. And for this simple reason, the familiar story of the interest mechanism cannot be true.

***

ICYMI  comment on Biagio Bossone of Oct 30

You say: “It is not the case that Keynes didn’t have the words to speak about inequality of ex-ante and ex-post saving. Based on his income multiplier process theory, he derived aggregate saving as a pure residual variable, strictly determined by aggregate investment in a way that S = I always and invariably, both ex-ante and ex-post.”

It is not the case that we do not know what Keynes said, but it is the case that Keynesians have not realized since the General Theory that Keynes's formal argument is provably false (2011). This has only been papered over with the ex-ante/ex-post filibuster, and this Keynesian verbiage is the very proof of deeper confusion that lasts to this very day.

“Throughout the 1920s and 1930s the focus was increasingly on the role of the equality of saving and investment, but the semantic squabbles that dominated much of the debate (the distinctions between ‘ex-ante,’ and ‘ex-post,’ ‘planned’ and ‘realized’ saving and investment, the discussion of whether the equality of saving and investment was an identity or an equilibrium condition) reflected a deeper confusion.” (Blanchard, 2000, p. 1378)

This includes Keynes, “But Keynes, too, sometimes gave the impression of not having fully grasped the logic of his own system.” (Laidler, 1999, p. 281)

Beyond Keynes’s manifest confusion, the correct relationship is ‘always and invariably’ given with Graphic AXEC09
Keynes, indeed, had the words to speak about the inequality of ex-ante/ex-post saving/ investment. A lack of words had never been the problem of any economist — what has always been in short supply was logic and argumentative consistency.

“The currently prevailing pattern of economic theorizing exhibits the following three characteristics: (1) a syncopated style of argument fluctuating back and forth between literary and symbolic modes of expression, (2) naive translation, or the loose paraphrasing of formulae into sentences, and (3) loose verbal reasoning for certain aspects of theoretical argumentation where explicit symbolic formulation is lacking.” (Dennis, 1982, p. 698)

The ex-ante/ex-post argument squarely falls into the category of loose verbal reasoning, a.k.a. blather. And this carries over to the theory of interest.


References
Blanchard, O. (2000). What Do We Know about Macroeconomics that Fisher and Wicksell Did Not? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115(4): 1375–1409. URL
Dennis, K. (1982). Economic Theory and the Problem of Translation (I). Journal of Economic Issues, 16(3): 691–712. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Laidler, D. (1999). Fabricating the Keynesian Revolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

***

ICYMI (comment on Henry of Oct 30 on Oct 31)

The accounting approach always deals with nominal magnitudes, which carry a monetary dimension like euro/dollar/yen, and never with real magnitudes. Hence, ‘unit’ invariably means ‘monetary unit’ in the given context. By not realizing that the I=S debate runs in nominal terms, your whole argumentation has been empty from the outset. Perhaps it is some comfort that you share this sad fate with djb, FedUp, and JKH.

My working paper Confused Confusers: How to Stop Thinking Like an Economist and Start Thinking Like a Scientist could be of some help to deconfuse yourself.

***

ICYMI (comment on Henry of Oct 31 4:22)

Your definition of income (income = household income + enterprise income) is wrong. Total income Y is wage income Yw=WL plus distributed profit Yd=DN. Distributed profit Yd is different from profit Q.

For the complete and consistent set of foundational propositions, which includes the nominal accounting variables as a subset, see the overview Graphic AXEC04.

For details about the difference between profit Q and distributed profit Yd and retained profit Qre (and why Y=Yw+Q is deadly wrong), see Economics for Economists.

It's not so easy, indeed Keynes and many others got the distinction between profit and income wrong, and this is exactly why they all ended in the I=S cul-de-sac. #1 This is the correct relationship: Q≡Yd+I−S. This equation tells you how the profit of the business sector as a whole is generated and how important it is that the business sector’s investment is greater than the household sector’s saving, i.e., I>S. This equation also tells you how beneficial the dissaving (S with a negative sign) of the American consumer (= growth of private debt) is for the world economy (until it is reversed). But this advanced topic is forever beyond the horizon of those who are stuck with I=S.


#1 I=S: Mark of the Incompetent

Related 'Humpty Dumpty is back again'.

I=S: Mark of the Incompetent

Comment on JKH and Roger Farmer on ‘Demand Creates its Own Supply’

Blog-Reference

I=S is provably false, but the representative economist never got the point. To some degree, this is understandable because the deeper conceptual problem is that the representative economist does not even know what profit is because, as the Palgrave Dictionairy summarizes “A satisfactory theory of profits is still elusive.” (Desai, 2008, p. 10)

In simple words, this means that all economic models are defective — except those that come explicitly to grips with the foundational economic concept of profit. None are known from Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy. And this, in turn, means that all economic policy advice lacks sound scientific foundations.

The I=S blunder is not a single or isolated event but a rather typical outcome of proto-scientific thinking and widespread misapprehension of scientific methodology. #1

The following economists are representatives of the general intellectual malaise that manifests itself in the longstanding I=S debate. The list could be easily extended. #2


For a crash course in profit theory, see The Profit Law.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Desai, M. (2008). Profit and Profit Theory. In S. N. Durlauf, and L. E. Blume (Eds.), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics Online, 1–11. Palgrave Macmillan, 2nd edition. URL

#1 The axiomatically correct relationship between monetary profit Qm, distributed profit Yd, investment expenditures I, and monetary saving Sm is given by Qm≡Yd+I−Sm.
#2 For details of the big picture, see cross-references Refutation of I=S

Related 'Fundamentally flawed'.

***
Graphic AXEC172



Graphic AXEC143d


Graphic AXEC129f

October 27, 2015

Fundamentally flawed

Comment on Roger Farmer on ‘Demand Creates its Own Supply’

Blog-Reference

You say “Keynesian economics begins with a basic definition.” This is true. The fact of the matter is, though, that this basic definition is provably false and, worse, that Keynesians have not got the point until this very day (2011b).

The final proof of widespread logical incapacity is that the elementary accounting identities have been messed up. As a centerpiece of the General Theory Keynes formulated the foundational syllogism of macroeconomics. “Income = value of output = consumption + investment. Saving = income − consumption. Therefore saving = investment.” (1973, p. 63)

This elementary syllogism is conceptually and logically defective because Keynes NEVER came to grips with profit (Tómasson and Bezemer, 2010, pp. 12-13, 16). The fault is in the premise ‘income = value of output’. This equality holds initially only in the limiting case of zero profit in both the consumption and investment good industry. Hence, Keynes formally dealt with a zero profit economy without being aware of it (2011b). This means in concrete terms that the multiplier formula is provably false.

The first logical blunder kicked off a chain reaction of mistakes, because when profit is not correctly defined, income is not correctly defined, and then saving is not correctly defined. Therefore, all I=S models are logically defective.

The root cause of all accounting errors/mistakes is a complete lack of understanding of what profit is. The conceptual error carries over to national accounting (2012).

You conclude “Here, finally, is the answer to the exchange between Jo and Noah. It is always true, in equilibrium, that savings is equal to investment.”

Definitively not! It is always true that Qm≡Yd+I−Sm, that is, monetary profit is equal to distributed profit plus investment expenditure minus the household sector's monetary saving. Saving and investment are never equal. This is a testable proposition.

To repeat: all I=S models are logically defective because they fail to consistently integrate profit. A short formal proof has been given on a parallel thread.*

Not only Jo and Noah got it wrong, but Roger, too. Not to forget, of course, Keynes and Hicks and Krugman (2014) and the rest of the logically feeble profession.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011a). Keynes’s Missing Axioms. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1841408: 1–33. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011b). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2012). The Common Error of Common Sense: An Essential Rectification of the Accounting Approach. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2124415: 1–23. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). Mr. Keynes, Prof. Krugman, IS-LM, and the End of Economics as We Know It. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2392856: 1–19. URL
Keynes, J. M. (1973). The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money. The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes Vol. VII. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Tómasson, G., and Bezemer, D. J. (2010). What is the Source of Profit and Interest? A Classical Conundrum Reconsidered. MPRA Paper, 20557: 1–34. URL

* See the Uneasy Money blog or the summary End of confusion on the AXEC blog

For details of the big picture see cross-references Refutation of I=S

Proto-scientific garbage

Answer to Paul Schächterle on ‘Economics, concepts, language and the progress of science’

Blog-Reference

The most curious fact about economics is that it has not taken off the ground since Adam Smith: “... we know little more now about ‘how the economy works,’ or about the modus operandi of the invisible hand than we knew in 1790, after Adam Smith completed the last revision of The Wealth of Nations.” (Clower, 1999, p. 401)

Compare this to the contemporaneous evolution of physics, then economics has in fact fallen even further behind. What obscures this de facto regression is that economists have always taken in edge-of-science tools that have been developed elsewhere. Thus, over more than two centuries now, economists of all schools have been busily engaged in what genuine scientists like Feynman readily identified as cargo cult science (see Wikipedia).

Thus, economics gave the impression of scientific progress while it has not moved one millimeter above the proto-scientific level of Adam Smith. Why? It is obvious, and Merijn Knibbe’s contribution is a pertinent reminder, that economists have never managed to come clear with the fundamental concepts of their trade.

The term unemployment, however, represents only the minuscule tip of the methodological crap mountain that is advertised as the queen of the social sciences. The ultimate reason for the observable self-paralysis of economics is that the representative economist cannot tell the difference between the fundamental concepts of profit and income. It should be clear that without a proper understanding of the concept of profit economics is scientifically dead and what you can see still walking around is a zombie.

Among genuine scientists, all this has not gone unnoticed: “Time and again in the twentieth century, prominent physicists have chastised their economist colleagues in no uncertain terms ...” (Mirowski, 1995, p. 357)

It did not help much. In everyday life, how do we characterize people who are unable to apply coherent language?

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Clower, R. W. (1999). Post-Keynes Monetary and Financial Theory. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 21(3): 399–414. URL
Mirowski, P. (1995). More Heat than Light. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Preceding Incoherence as second nature.

Related 'End of confusion' and 'Misled by ordinary intuition and common sense' and 'The Science-of-Man fallacy.'

At this moment, Oct 27 16:20 CET, I have found out that the term Moronomics has already been invented by someone else, see the Twitter hashtag.

October 26, 2015

Is Keynes acceptable?

Comment on Lars Syll on ‘Did Keynes ‘accept’ the IS-LM model?’

Blog-Reference

You summarize: “My own view is that IS-LM doesn’t adequately reflect the width and depth of Keynes’s insights on the workings of modern market economies.” (See intro)

IS-LM never has been acceptable (2014). However, it is not only unacceptable because of Hicks's numerous blunders. It is unacceptable because of Keynes’ original logical blunder which has not been rectified until this very day (2011).

As it happens, the question has been settled a few days ago on David Glasner’s blog Uneasy Money:
— For the full thread see here.
— For Keynes' logical incapacity see Keynes and the logical brilliance of Bedlam.
— For the rectification of Keynes’ conceptual blunder see End of confusion.

The ‘width and depth of Keynes’ insights’ on the workings of modern market economies should not be overrated. His recurring mantra was “we simply do not know” and this is the most appropriate summary of Keynesianism until this day.

“In order to tell the politicians and practitioners something about causes and best means, the economist needs the true theory or else he has not much more to offer than educated common sense or his personal opinion.” (Stigum, 1991, p. 30)

Neither Keynesianism nor Walrasianism in all their variants delivered the true economic theory — both approaches are scientifically unacceptable.

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


References
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2011). Why Post Keynesianism is Not Yet a Science. SSRN Working Paper Series, 1966438: 1–20. URL
Kakarot-Handtke, E. (2014). Mr. Keynes, Prof. Krugman, IS-LM, and the End of Economics as We Know It. SSRN Working Paper Series, 2392856: 1–19. URL
Stigum, B. P. (1991). Toward a Formal Science of Economics: The Axiomatic Method in Economics and Econometrics. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Related 'Interest and profit'.

Incoherence as second nature

Comment on 'Economics, concepts, language and the progress of science'

Blog-Reference

In order to get out of eternal wish-wash, the progress of science requires a consistent set of concepts.

“The often heard rule that concepts are to be defined before they are used in a discussion is much too simple minded pre-Hilbertian. The only way to arrive at coherent languages is to set up axiomatic systems implicitly defining the basic concepts.” (Schmiechen)

The use of the word unemployment is a pertinent example of incoherent thinking and talking which is indeed second nature to the representative economist.*

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke

* For the new axiomatic approach see cross-references Curriculum