Showing posts with label zDWT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label zDWT. Show all posts

September 18, 2018

Smart! How to make people fund their brain-washing

Comment on Down with Tyranny on ‘Want To Sound Really Smart About Economic Issues? Read This’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

Down with Tyranny argues: “When Blue America endorses a candidate, there are several ways we can be helpful to their campaigns, the most obvious being to help them raise campaign funds by connecting them to small dollar campaign contributors. This cycle one of the most valuable other ways we’ve helped candidates is by connecting them to Stephanie Kelton, America’s most brilliant economist.”

Stephanie Kelton argues: “Government debt is just the money the government spent into the economy and didn’t tax back. That’s all the national debt is. It’s a historical record of all of the times that they made a net deposit, spent more than they taxed out, and the bonds are the difference between those. One of the greatest cons ever perpetrated on the American people is this notion that the national debt belongs to us, that we are responsible in our individual capacity for a share of it.”

Everything is wrong with Stephanie Kelton’s economics
  • Her whole argumentation is based on MMT which is an economic theory that is refuted on all counts.#1
  • MMT is scientifically worthless. It is political economics, in other words, agenda-pushing in the cloak of academic authority.
  • MMT and Stephanie Kelton claim to push the agenda of WeThePeople but in fact, push the agenda of the Oligarchy.
  • All MMT policy guidance boils down to deficit-spending/money-creation.
  • Because the macroeconomic Profit Law states Public Deficit = Private Profit, MMT's economic policy boils down to the permanent growth of public debt which is nothing else than the permanent self-alimentation of the oligarchy.
  • All the social goodies MMTers promise are paid in real terms by WeThePeople themselves via stealth taxation.
  • Public debt is deferred taxation of WeThePeople which is simply pushed beyond the time horizon.
  • From the axiomatically correct Profit Law follows (I−S)+(G−T)+(X−M)−(Q−Yd)=0 which boils down to Public Deficit = Private Profit.#2 MMTers hide this distributional fact by lumping the business and the household sector together to the private sector and saying Public Deficit = Private Sector Surplus suggesting that private sector means WeThePeople. This is a verbal shell-game.#3, #4

MMT is ― to use Stephanie Kelton’s words ― “one of the greatest cons ever perpetrated on the American people”.#5

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


#1 For the full-spectrum refutation of MMT see cross-references MMT
#2 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump and exploding profit
#3 MMT is criminal economics
#4 The Kelton-Fraud
#5 MMT and grassroots movements

***
Wikimedia AXEC142

December 29, 2017

Down with idiocy!

Comments on DownWithTyranny! on ‘The Smartest Economist In America Explains What Deficits Really Mean’

Blog-Reference and Blog-Reference

This is what deficits really mean:

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke


Related 'Wikipedia and the promotion of economists’ idiotism (I)' and  'Wikipedia and the promotion of economists’ idiotism (II)' and 'Profit' and 'Wikipedia, economics, scientific knowledge, or political agenda pushing?' and 'The page where Stephanie Kelton gets macroeconomics wrong'.

See also on Twitter #MMT #LearnMMT #DebunkMMT #FailedScience #FakeScience #ScientificIncompetence #MMTers #StupidOrCorruptOrBoth #Profit #ProfitTheory  #SectoralBalances #PrivateSectorSurplus #PublicDeficitIsPrivateProfit #MacroEconomics #MacroFoundations #HowMMTservesTheRich #FreeLunch #Oligarchy #BadScienceBadPolicyBadPeople

***

COMMENT on Debtee Dec 30 and MNE on Dec 31

From macroeconomic analysis follows Public Deficit = Private Profit.#1

Either Stephanie Kelton does not understand this, then she is an incompetent scientist. Or, she understands it, then she sells a social bluff package for the benefit of the one-percenters.#2

If Stephanie Kelton is the “Smartest Economist In America” one trembles to contemplate how stupid the rest is.


#1 Keynes, Lerner, MMT, Trump and exploding profit
#2 MMT: The one deadly error/fraud of Warren Mosler

***

This pivotal MMT sectoral balances equation is false.

Source: Google Images MMT

For the axiomatically correct equation see National Accounting: scientific incompetence or political fraud? and Wikipedia and the promotion of economists’ idiotism and MMT and the magical profit disappearance and The Profit Theory is False Since Adam Smith.

This is the correct equation   (I−S)+(G−T)+(X−M)−(Qm−YD)=0 with Qm monetary profit and YD distributed profit.

Sectoral Balances: False = MMT, True = AXEC

***

There are four macroeconomic sectors (household sector, business sector, government sector, and the Rest of the world) but in the following charts one sector is missing, more specifically, the balance of the business sector = profit is nowhere to be seen. Why are two or more sectors lumped together? This obscures the crucial fact that Public Deficit = Private Profit given the balances of the household sector and the Rest of the world.

 Source: Google Images MMT











Exactly here, the rhetorical shell game starts because Domestic Private Balances is household sector's and business sector's balances lumped together. Thus profit becomes invisible.
  

The political fraud of MMT is in the false social solidarity of "We". Because Public Deficit = Private Profit "We" = ninety-nine percenters is actually "They" = one-percenters.

***

REPLY to Bill on Jan 2 and Blog-Reference MNE

You say: “Does Kelton understand that Public Deficit = Private Profit? She said as much: “the government’s −$10 is always matched by +$10 in some other part of the economy.”

Kelton’s incompetence is in these four words “in some other part”. The macroeconomic Profit Law says unequivocally Public Deficit = Private Profit and NOT in “in some other part”.#1

Either Stephanie Kelton does not know the Profit Law, which is fundamental to ALL of the economics, or she obscures it for some reason.

There is NO need to speculate about Stephanie Kelton’s ulterior motives. What has been proven is that MMT is materially and formally inconsistent, that is, scientifically worthless.#2 Therefore, ALL economic policy proposals of MMTers, including Stephanie Kelton, have NO sound scientific foundations.

Contrary to the social appearance, MMT is de facto agenda-pushing for the one-percenters. MMTers, including Stephanie Kelton, are either stupid or corrupt or both.#3


#1 For the proof see here
#2 For the full-spectrum refutation of MMT see cross-references MMT
#3 MMT: The one deadly error/fraud of Warren Mosler

***
LINK to The Kelton-Fraud and REPLY

Source: Twitter Jun 26, 2018

“THEIR” red ink is not “OUR” black ink but “THEIR” profit
because
Public Deficit (red ink) = Private Profit (black ink).
if the other sectors are taken out of the picture for the moment.

***
Twitter 2018 Nov 11, The fraud goes on

Source Twitter Nov 11, 2018
***
Twitter 2019 Feb 17

Source: Twitter Feb 17, 2019
Note that "private entities net flow of savings" is composed of the household sector's saving and the business sector's profit. The balance of the household sector is called saving. The balance of the business sector is called profit. Both cannot be lumped together to private entities' savings. This is the Humpty Dumpty Fallacy.


Twitter Jul 26, 2019

Source: Twitter

Twitter Oct 26, 2019


***

Link to Econoblog101, Dirk Ehnts, Sectoral balances of the eurozone, 2016 Jul 14

***

Twitter Jul 26, 2020


***
Twitter Aug5, 2020

Source: Twitter Alexandra Scaggs

***

Twitter Nov 9, 2020

Source: Twitter

Twitter Jan 17, 2021



Twitter Jan 29, 2021



Twitter Feb 3, 2021 Profit is the balance of the business sector but it is nowhere to be seen



Twitter Apr 1, 2021 Spain

There is NO “private sector” only the business sector (balance profit/loss) and the household sector (balance saving/dissaving). The 4-sector #ProfitLaw reads Q≡Yd+(I−S)+(G−T)+(X−M).

Twitter June 19, 2022 USA



***

Wikimedia AXEC118d