“Though Jevons had successfully shown that for agents a and b with respective prices p1 and p2 for goods x1 and x2 would exhibit the relationship MU1a/MU2a=-dx2/dx1=MU1b/MU2b, where dx2/dx1=p1/p2 MU1a/P1=MU2a/p2=MUb1/p1=MU2b/p2 (in other words, the exchange ratio of goods across utilities for each good and each consumer equaled the ratio of relative prices), …” (Nikolai Rostov) That utility is not such a good starting point for a serious theory of value is known since Cournot: “The abstract idea of wealth or value in exchange ... must be carefully distinguished from accessory ideas of utility, scarcity and suitability to the needs and enjoyment of mankind... These ideas are variable, and by nature indeterminate and consequently ill-suited for the foundation of a scientific theory …” (Cournot 1897) The marginal utility of one person does not matter much, because the market transforms a great number of diverse subjective valuations into one objective price for all. The first market function is the objectification of subjectivity. Austrians still fail to show how this transformation works. For the correct answer, see The Logical Interface Between Objective Macrofoundations and Subjective Valuations https://t.co/8NXaiPVsHv The question of value does not arise outside the economic system, where labor gets a wage, and the output is sold on the market. The Value Theory presupposes a monetary market economy. The subjective value has ultimately to be backed up by an objective amount of money. The subjective value of water may be high, but if the wealth-less agent can maximally spend his income and if his income is very small, the thirsty person cannot buy enough water and leaves the market to die in some dark corner. Objectivity always beats subjective wishful thinking. The market corrects subjective valuations. The survivors understand that the market is not primarily an efficient information mechanism but a quasi-Darwinian selection mechanism that makes sure, with some unintelligible Invisible-Hand trick, that the rich person survives the poor person if scarcity becomes extreme. These methodological mistakes are sufficient to make the Austrian approach scientifically worthless. The methodologically correct approach is summarized in table AXEC233b ⇓. Microfoundations are methodologically false. A Paradigm Shift is necessary. Therefore, the elementary production-consumption economy is given with three macroeconomic axioms in lines 1, 2, 3. The sectors are later differentiated in lines 15, 16, 17. Under the initial analytical conditions of market-clearing, i.e., X=O, this yields the price P in line 9. For a start, the price is the dependent variable here. This is a starting condition that is lifted later. Under the additional condition of budget-balancing, i.e., Ec=Yw or ρE=1, the price is given in line 5. In the initial state, the price is equal to unit wage costs W/R. The workers get the whole product O. Their real wage is equal to the objective productivity, i.e., W/P=R. General wage increases are pointless. The profit Qm for the business sector as a whole is zero in line 11. Price increases can come only from wage rate increases or from productivity decreases. The quantity of money is not a price determinant. Then, the condition of budget balancing is lifted, i.e., nominal demand is not determined by income. Accordingly, the two market-clearing prices depend on the respective expenditure ratios ρE1, ρE2 and unit wage costs W1/R1, W2/R2 in lines 18, 19. The objective expenditure ratio is a measurable expression of the consolidated multitude of unmeasurable individual subjective values. As a result, relative prices are given in line 20. They depend on the expenditure ratio, the wage rate, and inverse productivity. For the special case of budget balancing, i.e., ρE1=1, ρE2=1, and equal wage rates W1=W2=W in both production lines, the relative prices are equal to the inverse productivities. They are not proportional to labor time input. With hindsight, it is obvious that both the classical and the Austrian value theories have been proto-scientific garbage. This reveals the scientific incompetence of economists from Adam Smith onward.
— AXEC (@EgmontHandtke) November 15, 2026
This blog connects to the AXEC Project which applies a superior method of economic analysis. The following comments have been posted on selected blogs as catalysts for the ongoing Paradigm Shift. The comments are brought together here for information. The full debates are directly accessible via the Blog-References. Scrap the lot and start again―that is what a Paradigm Shift is all about. Time to make economics a science.